Address and Contact Information
Address: 346 NY-25A #66, Rocky Point, NY 11778
Phone: (631) 744-6611
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fresh and Hot Bagels Delivery Menu | 346 Route 25A Rocky Point
Order delivery or pickup from Fresh and Hot Bagels in Rocky Point! View Fresh and Hot Bagels’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants …
Fresh And Hot Bagels – Rocky Point – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Fresh And Hot Bagels at 346 New York 25A in Rocky Point. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Fresh and Hot Bagels – Rocky Point, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for Fresh and Hot Bagels in Rocky Point, plus popular items & reviews.
Reviews
Kristinapedia
UPDATE 11/23/2025: My last review was about three weeks ago and I figured I’d give them another try because I physically went in today. I asked for an Egg everything bagel with VEGGIE cream cheese and ham. I was going to check it before I left but I didn’t. I figured, “I’m here,. they couldn’t possibly screw it up.”
WELL, THEY DID. They gave me REGULAR cream cheese and ham. Of course I ate it as I had left work to pick it up and can’t go back but COME AWWWWNNNN… I literally told the woman what I wanted. (insert facepalm here).
So I will now have to test them and write it down on a piece of paper for them. If they screw it up then, I have lost all hope.
ORIGINAL REVIEW 11/09/2025:
I’ve been going here for decades since I’ve lived in this town for 40 years. However over the last six months the ability of them to get sandwiches correct has dropped considerably. I’m noticing a common theme among other reviewers is that they seem to forget the cheese and that has happened to me more times than I can count. Or I ask for extra cheese and I get one slice. Today I ordered a western omelet with bacon and extra cheese. The bacon was chopped up and put into the omelet which has never happened before and they put the cheese in the omelet which it pretty much invisible or they put cheese on it.
Last week I got egg whites, turkey and extra Swiss with hot sauce. I had one slice of Swiss and no hot sauce.
Sometimes I am lucky enough to get hot sauce for like two or three drops.
Let me say that I really have no issues with the employees up front they’re all Pleasant and friendly! I don’t know if someone’s not writing down the orders or the cooks are screwing it up. But there’s nothing worse than someone who’s hungry and gets wrong sandwich. it takes nothing away from an employee if you write an order down. I worked in a deli many years ago and wrote everything down. Even if I knew I could remember it, I still wrote it down because– multitasking. That’s what happens when you work in a service industry. I would be proud of an employee who wrote down orders instead of trying to remember it.
As for prices, prices are high everywhere and they’re in line with other places.
… moreWELL, THEY DID. They gave me REGULAR cream cheese and ham. Of course I ate it as I had left work to pick it up and can’t go back but COME AWWWWNNNN… I literally told the woman what I wanted. (insert facepalm here).
So I will now have to test them and write it down on a piece of paper for them. If they screw it up then, I have lost all hope.
ORIGINAL REVIEW 11/09/2025:
I’ve been going here for decades since I’ve lived in this town for 40 years. However over the last six months the ability of them to get sandwiches correct has dropped considerably. I’m noticing a common theme among other reviewers is that they seem to forget the cheese and that has happened to me more times than I can count. Or I ask for extra cheese and I get one slice. Today I ordered a western omelet with bacon and extra cheese. The bacon was chopped up and put into the omelet which has never happened before and they put the cheese in the omelet which it pretty much invisible or they put cheese on it.
Last week I got egg whites, turkey and extra Swiss with hot sauce. I had one slice of Swiss and no hot sauce.
Sometimes I am lucky enough to get hot sauce for like two or three drops.
Let me say that I really have no issues with the employees up front they’re all Pleasant and friendly! I don’t know if someone’s not writing down the orders or the cooks are screwing it up. But there’s nothing worse than someone who’s hungry and gets wrong sandwich. it takes nothing away from an employee if you write an order down. I worked in a deli many years ago and wrote everything down. Even if I knew I could remember it, I still wrote it down because– multitasking. That’s what happens when you work in a service industry. I would be proud of an employee who wrote down orders instead of trying to remember it.
As for prices, prices are high everywhere and they’re in line with other places.
The Egg
They mess up food a lot. It’s the type of place you should check your food before you leave. The service kind of sucks some of them kind of have attitudes but the atmosphere is okay lol
Small place tho and crazily over priced. $10+ for a basic egg sandwich.
… moreSmall place tho and crazily over priced. $10+ for a basic egg sandwich.
Rp FB
This bagel place is a staple of the area, they’ve always had a good deal for high schoolers after class and you have to respect that. Anyone who’s complaining about this place simply doesn’t know how to order a good sandwich. That’s just my opinion.
… moreElizabeth
the older women behind the counter are extremely unpleasant. they screwed up a simple order and apologized in a very sarcastic manner. this place reminds me of middle school, a bunch of means girls who blab away in a foreign language and laugh while talking about others. to save yourself a hassle DOUBLE check your order before you leave, or better yet don’t go here. i do not recommend
… moremeaghan hannon
We’ve been coming here for years, but no more. The prices keep increasing and the quality of food is decreasing. I ordered a turkey wrap and was shocked to see it was $13! I figured like most delis on LI, it would at least be overstuffed, nope! It was a few slices of turkey, a slice of cheese, litterally two slices of onion, and stuffed with lettuce. At this point, our favorite local deli is just ripping our community off, and I’m done.
… moreM.
Long time customer here. I can’t afford to come here anymore. Prices are extremely high compared to other deli’s. Service was much more pleasant with the younger workers, The new older workers are very rude. not worth coming in anymore
… moreMichele L
I spend a lot of money here 5-6 days a week. Every time I ask for an egg sandwich it is loaded with pepper … even when I ask for no pepper. Manager told me the cooks don’t put pepper on unless asked. . Wrong. this is the 5th time now in two weeks I received a BEC on a roll, LOADED with pepper. It’s absolutely ridiculous. Esp after spending over $35 on 2 bagels and 2 sandwiches that when we get home and open the sandwiches they’re not what we asked for.
… moreEric Werthner
I feel like the price is kind of high here but the egg sandwiches are always great. So at least you get what you pay for I’d rather spend a little more for their quality and taste.
… moreMark Swanson
The ongoing problem here is the inability for the staff to get orders right. I just ordered an egg white sandwich with American cheese & catchup. I got a burnt roll with egg whites & no American cheese. I also ordered a buttered roll with grape jelly. The girl who waited on me asked me if I wanted grape or strawberry jelly. I got a toasted roll which I didn’t ask for and strawberry jelly!!! She did not write the order down -first mistake, she did not check the order before it was packed up- second mistake, the person making the egg sandwich knew the roll was burnt but let it go- big mistake!!! Through all of these mistakes, no manager was obviously involved- biggest mistake of all! All of the above requires basic employee training. An egg sandwich, buttered roll & one coffee was over $16 bucks!!! The least they could do for that price is get the order right!!!!
… moreSkyler DiPalma
I’ve never experienced such rude service- I got a toasted bagel with butter and when the worker handed me the plate i could see the hunk of butter between the two halves. When i went back up to ask her for a plastic knife, she rolled her eyes at me. Like really?
… more