Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
At Lena’s, every dish is crafted with passion and pays homage to generations of Italian heritage. From our artisan pizzas to our amazing pastas, mouthwatering sandwiches to our desserts, gelato and handcrafted Italian cream sodas. Every bite will make you feel like you are transported to the old country.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 112 N Muskogee Ave, Tahlequah, OK 74464
Phone: (918) 316-4545
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lena’s Italian Kitchen | Tahlequah OK – Facebook
. 90% recommend (7 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 2028 Mahaney Ave. , Tahlequah, OK, United States, 74464 …
Reservations – Lena’s Italian Kitchen
Tahlequah, Oklahoma. (918) 316-4545. [email protected]. Hours: January 2026. Privacy Policy · Terms & Conditions. © 2025 by Lena’s Italian Kitchen …
About Us – Lena’s Italian Kitchen
Discover the journey behind our restaurant at 202 Mahaney Avenue, Tahlequah, OK. Learn about our story and what makes us unique. Visit now!
Reviews
Spike Speedwell
The pizza is sold at the Tahlequah Drug Co. because it is “Dope!”
Included with this review is a picture of the best pizza in Tahlequah, maybe even northeastern Oklahoma. My wife picked it, The Meathead. An amazing 14” pie loaded with Italian meaty goodness; meatballs, sausage, prosciutto, pepperoni and salami, beautifully arranged on a layer of marinara sauce and mozzarella. But wait there is more. Look closely at the picture, fresh basil. The crust, a work of artistic perfection. Thin crisp immaculate. This is a pizza made with pride. Just when we thought it couldn’t get any tastier the owner brought out a small cup of his mild Calabrian pepper chili sauce. Ask for it. A must. Use it to dip or spread on the pizza.
So, the ambiance is a little different. Kind of like an old timey drug store diner feel. Great service. Super friendly owner. More than pizza. Pictures of the big Italian menu are with this review. The Menu is also on line.
The restaurant is easy to find. Don’t look for Lena’s Italian Kitchen, look for the Tahlequah Drug Co. red brick building on the south of Hwy 62, right next to the McDonald’s. Park, go in, you are there.
We use to eat pizza at the joint downtown. But, No More. You know the one; its name rhymes with salmonella.
… moreIncluded with this review is a picture of the best pizza in Tahlequah, maybe even northeastern Oklahoma. My wife picked it, The Meathead. An amazing 14” pie loaded with Italian meaty goodness; meatballs, sausage, prosciutto, pepperoni and salami, beautifully arranged on a layer of marinara sauce and mozzarella. But wait there is more. Look closely at the picture, fresh basil. The crust, a work of artistic perfection. Thin crisp immaculate. This is a pizza made with pride. Just when we thought it couldn’t get any tastier the owner brought out a small cup of his mild Calabrian pepper chili sauce. Ask for it. A must. Use it to dip or spread on the pizza.
So, the ambiance is a little different. Kind of like an old timey drug store diner feel. Great service. Super friendly owner. More than pizza. Pictures of the big Italian menu are with this review. The Menu is also on line.
The restaurant is easy to find. Don’t look for Lena’s Italian Kitchen, look for the Tahlequah Drug Co. red brick building on the south of Hwy 62, right next to the McDonald’s. Park, go in, you are there.
We use to eat pizza at the joint downtown. But, No More. You know the one; its name rhymes with salmonella.
OklahOma SightS
The food tastes great. I’ve tried their ravioli, pizza, a sandwich, caesar side salad, tomato soup, & a dessert item. The manager and all the staff seems pleasantly nice. The restaurant’s atmosphere is in a pharmacy setting but you still get the restaurant feel, it’s a good combination. Go in, order, pick up medicine, enjoy some fine dining, & grab you some gifts for some family and/or friends; they have a variety of gift items inside. I will definitely be back, qnot just for the convenience, but for the delicious food & tea also.
… moreMo Casorla
Great local Italian eatery, local is the best. However, is hard to find because is located in the first floor of the building with a Pharmacy retail store sign. Owner is super nice, they also have great gelato.
… moreBrittany Elrod
If you’re looking for a fresh made from scratch pizza this is the place to go! Friendly service and we will be back! Hands down best pizza in town!!!
… moreKaren Carney-Beutler
I got the chicken Parmesan, with a Caesar salad, a side of fettuccine Alfredo, And the bruschetta with house marinated tomatoes. An for desert I had chocolate hazelnut crunch gelato! That was amazing! It was a wonderful experience! Absolutely loved the food, the staff are so attentive! Nick the owner is a fantastic cook, with a wonderful personality! Definitely watches out to make sure your experience is great! Give them a try!
… moreMelanie R Bench
What a delight to meet Nick, owner, and his father Mr. Davis. The cold, refreshing Cherry Italian Soda was a generous-sized beverage. And, the Classico Pizza is a new favorite. Kudos for Lena’s Italian Kitchen for featuring roasted mushrooms!
… moreJohn Morano
A little hard to find but we’ll worth the search, authentic Italian food in the middle of tahlequah is really hard to find. We tried to sampler, a small pizza, and the fellow even custom made us an antipasto. To top it all off the cannolis are to die for.
… moreSamantha Holderbee
Y’all! If you want a slice of Italy from scratch without the commute, hit up Lena’s in the Quah!! So much to choose from BUT I could rant praises for weeks about the Mossimo pizza, cannolis, and Italian wedding cake!! I love all pasta, but this homemade pasta, I can’t even describe it! Sure, you’ll wait a minute, and the wait staff is young, but you’ll be happy you stopped by!
P.S. if you like it SPICY, get that Diavolo Pizza, that my dad loves so much! It’s got honey in the sauce!!
And if you’re not a food critic, just stop by for an Italian cream soda or gelato and ask him about where this came from. He’ll light up talking about her!! ❤️
So happy to finally have a locally owned, hand crafted, family traditions, recipes dating generations back, Italian restaurant!! You don’t want to miss it!
… moreP.S. if you like it SPICY, get that Diavolo Pizza, that my dad loves so much! It’s got honey in the sauce!!
And if you’re not a food critic, just stop by for an Italian cream soda or gelato and ask him about where this came from. He’ll light up talking about her!! ❤️
So happy to finally have a locally owned, hand crafted, family traditions, recipes dating generations back, Italian restaurant!! You don’t want to miss it!
Bucky Braun
The food was fantastic! Probably the best Italian food I’ve had in recent memory! Service was great! It was an all around five star experience for my wife and I!
… moreCharles Campanella
Phenomenal food, I ordered the meathead pizza and it was so good, the staff was very friendly and accommodating I highly recommend this place!
… more