Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Butter Maid Bakery is a 5th generation small family owned and operated bakery. We specialize in 15+ flavors of kolachi and a variety of cookies. Our products have been handmade the old-fashioned way with simple ingredients – just like Mom & Grandma baked – for over 150 years. Our history dates back to our first bakery in Ohio in 1903, and our 1800s bakery in the old country. We’ve been shipping kolachi and other baked goods to all 50 states & Military addresses since 2006, from our bakery right here in Youngstown, Ohio. When you order from our kitchen, we’re going to treat you like you’re here for Sunday dinner. We put immeasurable care into everything we do and are truly committed to baking and delivering the highest quality products.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 100 Victoria Rd, Youngstown, OH 44515
Phone: (844) 688-7655
Website: http://buttermaidbakery.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Butter Maid Bakery: Buy Homemade Nut Rolls Online
Butter Maid Bakery is a 5th generation small family owned & operated bakery. Our products have been handmade the old-fashioned way for over 150 years.
Butter Maid Bakery | Youngstown OH – Facebook
Our Boardman Plaza location is open now through the 24th from 9am – 5pm, and our new Austintown location at 100 Victoria Rd is open 7am – 4pm through the 23rd, …
Butter Maid Bakery, 100 Victoria Rd, Youngstown, OH 44515, US
Butter Maid Bakery is a fifth-generation, family-owned bakery located in Youngstown, Ohio, dedicated to crafting handmade baked goods using traditional methods …
Reviews
Sherri Coots
I am from PA and so I was very familiar with these. My family is German and Hungarian. Then I moved to CA. We could not find anything like this there. From there we went to TX and now recently to MN. We have been ordering the nut and the apricot the most. We have tried other flavors but those two are our favorites. We always make sure we have them for the holidays! They freeze well, taste just like when you first received them. Their customer service is amazing! They are a little expensive but they do sometimes have discount codes. Definitely worth it. It warms my heart to have a piece of my heritage every time I bite into a piece. We will continue to order these. The best ever!
… moreLindsay Hamel
Ordered closepin cookies for my wedding. They arrived well packed and taste great, but maybe a little too sweet.
The problem is when you read the ingredients. It’s all industrial waste products.
These are nothing like homemade. Preservatives and canola oil galore.
Might as well buy Little Debbie’s for a fraction of the cost of you want sweet poison to eat.
… moreThe problem is when you read the ingredients. It’s all industrial waste products.
These are nothing like homemade. Preservatives and canola oil galore.
Might as well buy Little Debbie’s for a fraction of the cost of you want sweet poison to eat.
Diana S
I’ve had both the Honey Walnut and Apricot Kolachis and they are both amazing! I was surprised that there was a lot of filling all the way through to the very ends! Yummy down to the very last bite! I will buy these again! I’m looking forward to trying the lemon cream filled one!
… moreChristin Smith
What a gem of a find! Delicious, impeccably made, fresh kolachi cookies, nut and poppyseed rolls delivered to my doorstep!
Where I live, it is difficult to find this old world style of pastry and I wanted to get my husband a special dessert for his birthday so I gave Butter Maid a try.
So glad I took a chance on this one, my order shipped the day after it was placed and arrived at our doorstep beautifully wrapped and baked to perfection. If you are looking for anything they have to offer, this is the place to order your baked goods! Will definitely order again in the future! They deliver nationwide, if you’re even vaguely in the market, order right away and your happiness level will increase dramatically when that pink box arrives at your home.
… moreWhere I live, it is difficult to find this old world style of pastry and I wanted to get my husband a special dessert for his birthday so I gave Butter Maid a try.
So glad I took a chance on this one, my order shipped the day after it was placed and arrived at our doorstep beautifully wrapped and baked to perfection. If you are looking for anything they have to offer, this is the place to order your baked goods! Will definitely order again in the future! They deliver nationwide, if you’re even vaguely in the market, order right away and your happiness level will increase dramatically when that pink box arrives at your home.
Kathy Duncan
I did not go to the bakery! I have ordered many times from Butter Maid Bakery and I wanted to order a special gift for my out of state brother for his 80th birthday! Something that would send him loving memories since I do not see him often! There is 7 years between my brother and myself and when we were kids we would go to my grandmothers house to eat dinner, which was always the same: homemade noodles and chicken soup with nut kolachi cookie and nut rolls which the nuts would overflow just like Butter Maid Bakery! The delivery was the next day and my brother was so surprised and excited to receive his gift! He open his gift and in a matter of minutes the cookies were half gone and the nut roll was sliced! He called me in tears that gift was so delicious and brought the memories of my grandmother making our Sunday Dinner! We talked about when we were kids and all the loving thoughts way back in our lives especially the food Grandma would make! My grandmother was from Poland and as we both are older now, our stories we shared brought so many wonderful memories which was so close to our hearts! As you get older you learn to cherish all the memories you can hold on to! Thank you, Butter Maid Bakery for bringing happiness to two older siblings!
… moreWARD NELLIGAN
My mom and aunt use to make the poppyseed roll every year for holidays. With them gone I’ve never found any that tasted right they were always too dry. Butter Maid makes the poppyseed roll just right not too dry. Then I tried the pumpkin roll that was wonderful as well. I know where to go for this treat now Butter Maid.
… moreDarcy Amick
I have never been close enough to visit but always do on-line orders. But they have been very prompt with all my orders & the kolachi rolls I’ve purchased have been delicious & enjoyable! They also are very prompt to answer all questions & concerns.
… moreLynn Wagner
Mail order gift to my husband. The Kolachi rolls favorably compare to his Hungarian grandmother’s and he loves them. Great gift!
… moreLaura W
My grandson just joined the Army, graduated Basic Training and is in California for Tech School. Every year at Christmas I make buckeyes and he LOVES them. I’m in NC and knew it would be hard for me to ship across the country and also be very expensive and I doubt they would have made it there in one piece. Buttermaid ships free through FedEx. I ordered 2packages of these and 1 package of nut Kolachi cookies and they were in his hands in CA 4 days! And FREE SHIPPING!!! They were beautifully packed and in perfect condition! Such a such a sweet surprise and he LOVED them!!! Thanks Buttermaid!!! PS. I’ve ordered several Kolachi Rolls and they are always AMAZING!!! I would highly recommend Buttermaid!!!
… moreFrances Conley
It is really good, however, I think the dough should be a little thicker in between the layers so that it doesn’t taste like it is raw.
Just a little thicker so not to taste like it needs to be baked more.
… moreJust a little thicker so not to taste like it needs to be baked more.