I was born and raised in the pizza business. I learned everything from my father and my uncle. They our the ORIGINAL owners of BROTHERS PIZZA (19th and Paxton st in the early 70s). We make our dough , bread, sauces etc fresh everyday. Come check us out!
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony’s Pizzeria – Middletown, PA – 302 W Main St – Hours, Menu, Order
Taste the best pizza in Middletown. Middletown is home to the ever-popular Tony’s Pizzeria. With great pizzas on the menu, it isn’t hard to see why.
Tony’s Pizza Middletown – Facebook
Tony’s Pizza Middletown. local owned pizza shop. been in business since 2007 in other locations. we serve pizzas, stromb …
Tony’s Pizzeria – 302 W Main St, Middletown, PA 17057 – Slice
White Thin Crust Pizza. Original White Pizza. Fresh garlic, olive oil, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese. $15.89 …
Last Updates
Reviews
Angela F (Ang)
A Thanksgiving Twist Worth Raving About!
I wasn’t sure what to expect from a Thanksgiving Turkey Stromboli, but wow—this absolutely blew me away. Imagine all the best parts of Thanksgiving dinner wrapped up in a warm, golden, perfectly baked Stromboli. The turkey was tender and flavorful, the stuffing added the perfect savory touch, and the cranberry sauce gave just the right hint of sweetness to balance everything out. Every bite tasted like the holiday, but without any of the heaviness.
The crust was beautifully crisp on the outside and soft on the inside, holding everything together without overpowering the flavors. It’s comforting, creative, and downright delicious—an unexpected combination that just works.
If you’re looking for a fun seasonal twist or simply want to enjoy Thanksgiving flavors in a completely new way, this Stromboli is a must-try. I’m already planning to get another one. Absolutely fantastic! From the Middletown Great Clips Stylists ❤️
… moreI wasn’t sure what to expect from a Thanksgiving Turkey Stromboli, but wow—this absolutely blew me away. Imagine all the best parts of Thanksgiving dinner wrapped up in a warm, golden, perfectly baked Stromboli. The turkey was tender and flavorful, the stuffing added the perfect savory touch, and the cranberry sauce gave just the right hint of sweetness to balance everything out. Every bite tasted like the holiday, but without any of the heaviness.
The crust was beautifully crisp on the outside and soft on the inside, holding everything together without overpowering the flavors. It’s comforting, creative, and downright delicious—an unexpected combination that just works.
If you’re looking for a fun seasonal twist or simply want to enjoy Thanksgiving flavors in a completely new way, this Stromboli is a must-try. I’m already planning to get another one. Absolutely fantastic! From the Middletown Great Clips Stylists ❤️
Dalton Fisher
I was in town visiting and decided to stop here for a couple slices. I’ve had pizza all over the country and this place is easily in my top 5. Outstanding pizza.
… moreLinda Gomboc
Everything I have ordered has always been delicious. Very reasonable prices. Also must try and eggplant parmesan dinner. Fish and fries is delicious also!
… moreJourney Through Life
I’ve been in the area for several weeks for training. I’ve eaten here on several occasions and have always really enjoyed my meal. The staff is very friendly and the food is great! Keep up the good work guys.
… morecody rosati
Check this shop out, best prices and quality around! I got a chicken parm sub, they serve the BEST sub rolls soft, chewy, firm, and taste great. Their mozzarella is also top notch! Locally owned go check them out delicious!
… moreBeatriz Garcia
Very good food, had me an Italian sub toasted , the sub was nice and warm to my liking, and a slice of buffalo chicken pizza . Will recommend for quick bite to eat
… moreTroy Baker
Some menu prices are higher than what is shown on google and Facebook. It’s probably an honest oversight, but the employees made no effort to take responsibility and correct their mistake.
I also had the magherita pizza. It only had a few sparse clumps of mozzarella cheese, no tomatoes to be seen at all, and the basil wasn’t fresh but dried flakes. Other than that the pizza was pretty dry and tasteless. They have a similar pizza shown on their facebook, so they must know how to make it, but just don’t care too much about it. I wouldn’t recommend this restaurant.
… moreI also had the magherita pizza. It only had a few sparse clumps of mozzarella cheese, no tomatoes to be seen at all, and the basil wasn’t fresh but dried flakes. Other than that the pizza was pretty dry and tasteless. They have a similar pizza shown on their facebook, so they must know how to make it, but just don’t care too much about it. I wouldn’t recommend this restaurant.
makinley brooks
Had a fantastic Stromboli! It was made fresh right there. I ordered a small but I could have (should’ve, but didn’t) split it with another. So good!
… moreStew Ireland
Antipasta salad and a couple slices always satisfies! The homemade tiramisu is bangin’!
… moreMiles Joyner
We were visiting PA for a business trip and I was craving a cheese steak so this was the only place that seemed recommended from a Google search. I wasn’t expecting Philly level but… This was pretty bad.
Why do places put marinara sauce on the steak without a request? I strictly asked for grilled onions, cheese, and Mayo yet I still I got the red sea when I unwrapped it. Lacked flavor and seemed to not have much seasoning.
Fries were delicious though.
Edit: I appreciate the owner’s response! I will be back in the area and will try the pizza.
… moreWhy do places put marinara sauce on the steak without a request? I strictly asked for grilled onions, cheese, and Mayo yet I still I got the red sea when I unwrapped it. Lacked flavor and seemed to not have much seasoning.
Fries were delicious though.
Edit: I appreciate the owner’s response! I will be back in the area and will try the pizza.