Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Elyria, OH, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Elyria pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Elyria or stop by 811 Chesnut Commons for carryout to order the best pizza in Elyria, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 811 Chestnut Commons Dr, Elyria, OH 44035
Phone: (440) 328-3030
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Chesnut Commons – Elyria
At Papa Johns Pizza in Elyria, OH, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. … Elyria pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in …
papa johns stores in elyria, oh
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Elyria, Ohio to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa Johns Pizza Delivery & Carryout – Best Deals on Pizza, Sides …
Enjoy the ease of ordering delicious pizza for delivery or carryout from a Papa Johns near you. Start tracking the speed of your delivery and earn rewards …
Last Updates
Reviews
James Bell
What a disaster! I ordered and had two pizza bowls delivered.They didn’t bother to even cook the food it seems. I received a platter full of raw onions and green peppers under just barely melted cheese. I ordered extra sauce. Where was the sauce? Instead it was swimming in water from the raw vegetables. Disgusting! My mistake was not getting Marcos Pizza bowl. They actually cook the food and are really good. I thought I’d give Papa Johns a try. NEVER AGAIN! I called the store and just got an insincere sorry about that.
If I weren’t so tired from working all day, I would have taken them back up to the store.
It’s getting harder and harder to find just mediocre quality in fast food but this was a disaster! At least cook the damn food for goodness sake. I could of just got a raw onion and green pepper and had it for dinner because I didn’t receive much better than that!!!
… moreIf I weren’t so tired from working all day, I would have taken them back up to the store.
It’s getting harder and harder to find just mediocre quality in fast food but this was a disaster! At least cook the damn food for goodness sake. I could of just got a raw onion and green pepper and had it for dinner because I didn’t receive much better than that!!!
Kristen G
So, I ordered a pizza and cheese sticks. The delivery driver got it to me on time, even though it was a literal blizzard out! That was great!
But, when I opened my pizza, my pizza was correct but they gave me bread sticks instead of cheese sticks (the box sticker even said cheese sticks…). So I call the store and spoke to a very pleasant lady who gave me the choice of either getting a correction sent out, but it would take 45 minutes to an hour, or she could credit my account. I wasn’t going to wait for the cheese sticks, nor would I want to cause someone to drive in that weather again, so I chose the credit. She informed me she’d credit me for the whole order. I don’t know if this meant a refund (I would have expected her to say that), so I assumed it would be credited in points on my account, but no idea…
Either way, I have seen no such credit and I’m a bit ticked about it. All I see, in terms of points, is what I earned from the order and then turned into ‘dough bucks’ or whatever it’s called. But that is just from the points I already have, and regardless, if it wasn’t, I don’t think 15 points is enough of a credit… Especially because the bread sticks are terrible. Nothing against how they’re made, I just don’t like them, like, put some seasoning or something on them… If I wanted just straight bread I’d get a loaf out … Besides, they only give you enough sauce for 1 or 2 dips, then your just eating straight bread that is no different than what I use for PB&j… Anyway, I digress…
Overall, long story short ..too late… The driver was amazing, the lady on the phone was pleasant, but the order was messed up and the resolution never happened…. So… Not really feeling too good about this papa johns right now…
If they fix the mistake, I’ll change the star and edit the review… But more than likely, without resolution, I won’t be ordering pizza from here again…
… moreBut, when I opened my pizza, my pizza was correct but they gave me bread sticks instead of cheese sticks (the box sticker even said cheese sticks…). So I call the store and spoke to a very pleasant lady who gave me the choice of either getting a correction sent out, but it would take 45 minutes to an hour, or she could credit my account. I wasn’t going to wait for the cheese sticks, nor would I want to cause someone to drive in that weather again, so I chose the credit. She informed me she’d credit me for the whole order. I don’t know if this meant a refund (I would have expected her to say that), so I assumed it would be credited in points on my account, but no idea…
Either way, I have seen no such credit and I’m a bit ticked about it. All I see, in terms of points, is what I earned from the order and then turned into ‘dough bucks’ or whatever it’s called. But that is just from the points I already have, and regardless, if it wasn’t, I don’t think 15 points is enough of a credit… Especially because the bread sticks are terrible. Nothing against how they’re made, I just don’t like them, like, put some seasoning or something on them… If I wanted just straight bread I’d get a loaf out … Besides, they only give you enough sauce for 1 or 2 dips, then your just eating straight bread that is no different than what I use for PB&j… Anyway, I digress…
Overall, long story short ..too late… The driver was amazing, the lady on the phone was pleasant, but the order was messed up and the resolution never happened…. So… Not really feeling too good about this papa johns right now…
If they fix the mistake, I’ll change the star and edit the review… But more than likely, without resolution, I won’t be ordering pizza from here again…
Ariel
Got delivery and everything was good. Pizza came hot, tasted great, and I especially liked the cheese sticks. Solid experience overall.
… moreHeidi Belfiore
Pizza is so good, and so is the pepper they put in the box. Also got wings, Chipotle and naked or plain or whatever they call them, annnd very good too, and don’t pass on the knots either. They have great offers and specials.
… moreDusti Dobbins
Ordered buffalo wings, they came plain. They forgot our pop. Also, oreos do not come with icong, as advertised. When i called to get our issues resolved, the manager was RUDE and didn’t care that THEY messed up.
… moreTom Basham
I’ve always loved Papa John’s growing up but my most recent order will be my last. I ordered a large “the works” pizza and two cheesy bread orders – one was to be bacon and jalapeno. I received a cheesy bread and a bacon cheesy bread, with no jalapeno. The pizza sauce dips were sour and made my whole family sick. The pizza itself was just as uncooked as a lunchables. All for $56?? No, no. Never again
… moreCassandra Thompson
The past few visits at this location have been top tier!! Delicious and yummy!! Made to perfection even the staff are amazing wish they had sandwiches though but still one of my top 5 pizza places that are a reasonable price.
… moreJohn S.
Hire more people to answer the phones instead of using an answering service from India. I’ve never had issues making an order with shop personnel. You’ve taken 50 steps back. Smh. ♂️ ♂️
… moreMarie Kubow
these comments on here I just want to say we do fix orders and we make mistakes like anyone but we always take accountability and fix them papa John’s is amazing, please give us another try I promise you won’t regret it .
… moreJohn Atkinson
Ordered extra bacon pizza. This is the second time it came with what equals to be normal amount on other pizza brands. Either they don’t care about what equals “extra” or they don’t read the order. Not getting what I paid for. Dissatisfied.
… more