4.4 – 215 reviews • Pizza delivery
Welcome to Plus 1 Pizza, we have you covered, with the best pizza in Coshocton, OH, pizzeria near you!! Making award-winning pizza since 1977. Voted best pizza. We specialize in delicious homemade sauces, fresh ingredients in every one of our takeout pizzas, prompt pizza delivery, and convenient pizza online ordering to satisfy your cravings anytime. At Plus 1 Pizza, we take pride in offering irresistible pizza specials and exclusive coupons to deliver the best value to our customers. Whether you’re looking for pizza delivery or planning a pizza night at home, our freshly prepared pizzas are always crafted with the finest ingredients to ensure exceptional taste in every bite.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
plusonepizza.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
Jay
WARNING! GREASY GREASY GREASY!!! I got pepperoni pizza to go. I was riding in the passenger seat, so naturally I’m holding the pizza on the ride home. Mind you is only a 5-10 minute ride to get there. So we pull in I get out of the car and then I see it grease covered paints. So much grease in that short time it soaked through the box and ruined my new Dockers. Normally no big deal but being my first time wearing them and just spent $80 on them it was kinda disappointing…. Just wanted to warn people so this don’t happen to anyone else ruin any more clothes, or worse big grease spots on car seats, carpet or anything else for that matter. Because trust me it doesn’t come out. If nothing else, at least put tons of napkins down under the boxes to help keep grease off whatever you don’t want ruined. Wish I would’ve…
… moreDirt Every Weekend
So this is my first time here we got 2 different pizzas and a desert they were all great!! I highly recommend eating here and look forward to trying more options next time.
… moreChristopher Anderson
First time trying the pizza here and it was really good. We got 3 different pies and all 3 were hot and exactly as expected, I definitely recommend this spot.
… moreDarci Untied
Quick pick up, easy access, and wonderful food. Delightful retro pizza shop. Skip the chain eateries and get pizza at this local shop!
… moreHope Sponsel
Just bought my first pizza here (basic pepperoni) it was AMAZING! Very kind staff too.
… moreBOSSD UP
One of the best pizza places in the area. The variety is incredible and pricing is fair. Highly recommended.
… moreSandra Walker
Ordered two cauliflower crusts specialty pizza’s today. They were absolutely amazing.
… moreSusie Bible Enos
We were in the mood for meatball subs and fries.I was surprised when their menu popped up with more than pizza in google. We decided to order meatball sub and pepperoni and sausage pizza to try both.Heck,with the fries.They were both great! The service was awesome also.We will be back.
Susie&Rick Enos
… moreRed Topol
Paid extra for additional toppings and did not receive them, wings were soggy to the point the texture was so bad I could not eat them. Really sad because we like plus one, but the Coshocton location really let us down.
… moreLisa Weisgarber-trigg
We order delivery frequently and have never gotten anything we don’t like. The pizza is delicious and the delivery is always on time. The only issue is it’s hard not to eat too much because it’s so good. It’s definitely a favorite!!
… more