Jennifer R.
I wasn’t the one to pick up the food, so I’m not sure how the place was. I called in the order. The kid on the phone was nice. We ordered from a coupon. Two medium one topping pizzas and six pizza rolls. We did a pepperoni pizza and a green pepper pizza.
The green peppers were shaved super thin. I couldn’t really taste them or tell they were on the pizza. Normally they’re more chopped. You get the crunch and nice flavor. This was basically a cheese pizza with a tad of pepper flavor when you got a good bite. The pepperoni pizza was good. Their pepperoni has a decent kick of spice to it, and not in the best way. But that’s me personally. The pizza rolls were okay.
Overall, it wasn’t bad. The pizza is filling because the dough is on the thicker side. The sauce was good and flavorful. Honestly, I don’t think we’d get here again based on this experience. But, that’s why there are so many pizza place options! There’s something for everyone somewhere.
… moreErika Mendoza
This place is one of my favorites since I was a kid. This pizza brings back so many memories from my childhood I cannot say enough how delicious this pizza always has been and continues to be! Tonight I met the owner and he was just the sweetest & so kind. You don’t see owners like this any more it’s why I stick to the small business there more humble :)!!! Please come by and give them a try, you won’t be disappointed
… moreRyan Corey
Gonna be honest, for me personally, the greatest appeal is the discounted pizza rolls on Sundays. The food isn’t like insanely great, but for the price, it’s hard to top. I love the locally owned and operated vibe, it definitely makes the food a lot better. Ever since that small little pizza roll place in the mall closed down, this has been my go to pizza roll guru. Wish they had a tad bit more flavor, or were a tiny bit bigger, but all things considered, very good and well done.
… moreMark Dinkel
Called two hours early to place my order for 12:30 pm got there right on time went in to pick up my order they haven’t even started yet I for the manager his response was you can always cancel your order, Not sure what other people might think about this but I don’t think I’d like too have amanager working for me that doesn’t have any respect for the customer.
… morePreston Hadley
I’m newer to Greeley and like to look for new food spots to try. I came here after being recommended by a friend. The 2 owners were very friendly and eager to make sure I had a great experience. I ordered at the front counter and they were very prompt.
I ordered the Pepperoni pizza and Pepperoni pizza rolls with some wings. All were made with quality ingredients. I really enjoyed the pepperoni pizza rolls! They were even half off on Sundays which I didn’t know prior to coming in.
I highly recommend trying this place. Super friendly owners and quality food and service as well.
… moreiliana estrella
This place is incredible!!!!! Give them a shot, they deliver far too! Fresh dough, sauce and cheese. If you want authentic, chose them.
… moreZz Z
I was hungry and looking for a decent pizza. When the pizza i ordered arrived. It was a major disappointment. I mean, middle school cafeterias do a better job than this place.
A good 30% of the pizza was missing cheese and toppings. Like what? Did ya’ll run out of cheese? Or are you just cheap.
… morebill c
If u try the pepperoni rolls u will never order regular pizza again. It’s the nectar of the Greeley Gods. On Sundays they’re only $1 each. Best value on the planet. Just try them and tell me I’m wrong!
… moreAmy Schafer
Placed delivery order at 5:11 & was told it be here in 45 minutes. Once it hit an hour, I called and was told ,”he’s in route. He should be there in a little bit.” Twenty more minutes went by. The food should have been delivered warmer than it was. No apology or anything from the driver. Hardly any meat on the belly o double stack! Considering we live within 15 minutes of the restaurant and we only ordered 1 belly o, 6 pizza rolls and a calzone not to mention they took my phone number (to call me id have assumed if driver is lost , delayed or whatever ). I give one star because my hungry 7yr old approved of the pizza rolls.
… moreBrittany G
Bring back the original ranch! We have been coming to pizza street for 20 years and since the ownership has changed so has the food and service.
… more