Olivia
The most delicious pizza around. The shop smells amazing as soon as you enter the doors and the flavor of the food speaks for itself. Try it and tell everyone you know, this place deserves all the support. Will happily be returning
… moreJustin Fox
First time customer at this pizza place. First impression is why would there be a gas powered snow blower in the dining room . My order was quick and on time. The pizza was hot when I arrived home after a 5 min drive. Wings were way over cooked and most were uneatable , No blue cheese or celery and most of the wings were very small. The pizza was hot and cooked well but dripped with grease while eating.
… moreLeon Reed
We have been talking about trying this restaurant for quite a while… now I wish we had tried it much sooner! We caught the last day of the April special when 16″ specialty pizzas were just $11. We ordered two specialty pizzas (a meat lovers and a Sis) and three “drums”.
The crust of the pizza is a thin crust, which I don’t usually like, but this one was wonderful. It has good flavor. texture, and held up well to folding in true New York style. The toppings were plentiful on both pizzas and the flavors mixed well.
The “drums” were equally delicious, and cooked to perfection. The skin had just a hint of crispiness and the meat was juicy and tender. The best part however was the sauce. We tried the Mango-Habenero which was an amazing blend of the two flavors that created a hot, but sweet combination that we all agreed was fantastic.
In short, we will be returning to Elmo’s a lot in the future, and with all the varieties of pizza and sandwiches available, I can’t wait to try them all!
… moreJordan Beardsley
The white sauce Pizza and the Ricotta pizza is amazing and the prices on the pizza and wing specials are to die for two large pizzas with 20 wings for $45 you can’t get better than that thanks for the amazing pizza Elmo’s
… moreMegan Whipple
This place is the definition of amazing, quality food in an under the radar spot. We just tried it for the first time and it easily beats the other pizzas we’ve tried in town. The owner was incredibly kind in our two minute interaction and it’s clear his heart is in his food. This is going to be our new go to.
… moreMarcus Thorn
I have to say that I just had gyros from Elmos Pizza and they are some of the best I’ve had in years. The ingredients are fresh, the lamb was cooked to perfection.
If you’re thinking about fast food? Think again. Go get a gyro from Elmos. Healthier & 10 times more delicious! Thanks Elmo!
… moreDave Whipple
Best pizza in Jamestown. Owner is kind and really cares about what he offers. We have loved everything we’ve had from Elmos.
… moreBrian Fruchey
Some of the best pizza ever. It appeared as if just the owner was on shift. Our pizza was a little late being finished, but he gave us our pizza at a discount. This owner will make things right with and for the customer. Plain pepperoni was even special. Also had the Margherita pizza. Will go again if ever in the area. The man knows how to run a pizza business.
… moreNeil Delaney
I have been curious about trying this place for quite awhile. I did tonight. In all honesty I dont know if I even have the words to properly review. All I can say is that my mind was blown away! Something that good was under my nose this whole time and I can not believe it exists in this town. Alot of pizza places in the Jamestowm Area. Some a good and alot of them are not. This was neither of those. Because its hands down great!! You need not look further than almost. 10 out of 10!
… moreKalisyah rivera
the best pizza!!! So good and the wings were so good!! 10/10 butter garlic sauce I pray one day he gets a better place he really does deserve it and 10/10 customer service I don’t even write reviews but this was worth logging in to make one!
… more