Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Amelio’s pizzeria is the only restaurant in Sidney featuring signature brick oven pizza, as well as specialty sandwiches and salads, pastas, and a variety of appetizers. We are family-owned, and want our restaurant to welcome a family style atmosphere!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 115 S Ohio Ave, Sidney, OH 45365
Phone: (937) 658-6270
Website: https://ameliosdowntown.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Amelio’s Pizzeria | Sidney OH – Facebook
Amelio’s Pizzeria is the only restaurant in Sidney featuring signature brick-oven pizza, as well as specialty sandwiches and salads, pastas, and a variety of …
Photo: Amelio’s closes its doors – Sidney Daily News
Amelio’s Pizzeria has closed its doors, the business announced in a … Sidney OH, 45365. Facebook X. © Copyright AIM Media Texas, LLC.
Amelio’s Pizzeria 115 South Ohio Avenue – Order Online
Get delivery or takeout from Amelio’s Pizzeria at 115 South Ohio Avenue in Sidney. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Agathe M
Nice little Italian restaurant in downtown Sidney, OH. Really enjoyed my meal and drinks.
The server was super sweet & caring.
Went on a Tuesday night and the place wasn’t crowded. So there was plenty of parking space right outside.
If you come at night, the door will likely be locked: make sure to knock go get someone’s attention or else you’ll miss their delicious meals.
Overall, loved the place. Will definitely stop by whenever I’m in town 🙂
… moreThe server was super sweet & caring.
Went on a Tuesday night and the place wasn’t crowded. So there was plenty of parking space right outside.
If you come at night, the door will likely be locked: make sure to knock go get someone’s attention or else you’ll miss their delicious meals.
Overall, loved the place. Will definitely stop by whenever I’m in town 🙂
Future Mortician
Love the atmosphere.
We were the only one there lol which was nice with two two year Olds.
We got a pepperoni with house made sauce and mozz ch.
The sauce was delicious and it was super cheesy. The only reason it’s not 5 stars cause for the addiontional price to get pepperoni there wasn’t very much.
… moreWe were the only one there lol which was nice with two two year Olds.
We got a pepperoni with house made sauce and mozz ch.
The sauce was delicious and it was super cheesy. The only reason it’s not 5 stars cause for the addiontional price to get pepperoni there wasn’t very much.
Rock
Wow. Just wow. This place is AMAZING to say the least. Service was amazing! Every worker I encountered was friendly and had a smile on their face. As for the food… SO GOOD!! I got a sub (so did my boyfriend) and it was delicious. We couldn’t stop talking about how great our subs were. I mean they were just the right temperature and taste. The bread was soft but yet crunchy on the outside. The thing practically melted in my mouth it was so good! And the fries…. Oh boy the fries were like no other. I asked for ketchup at first (creature of habit) but I ended up not even needed it because the taste of the fries alone were amazing. Everything was awesome and I can’t wait to go back! Way to go amelio’s!
… moreDesdemona Duncan
Awesome old world Italian food! Great atmosphere with an old meets new cozy kind of vibe. They make their own marinara and it shows. Homemade pizza crust with fresh toppings. Freshly cut mozzarella wrapped in a wonton wrapper and fried is their new take on a boring old cheese stick, and it is good! Especially when dipped in some leftover garlic sauce from the homemade garlic knots! Toni (the owner) is a sweetheart and the pride she takes in her family heritage shows.
… moreBecca Giguere
Had similar experience to previous review. Burnt pizza, we ordered pick up at 8, closed doors at 830 although closing time posted says 9. Paid too much for burnt pizza to not say something.
… moreSarah Couch
Almost $60 for burnt pizza. Smashed cake on the bar. Door was locked at 8:30 when they close at 9:00. Our pizza was takeout. Ordered ahead of time so it’s not like they didn’t know they’d have customers.
… moreDeanna Chappie
I definitely recommend the Italian Stallion sandwich. It was quite tasty, but beware that the bread is crusty and will do a number on the roof of your mouth. The side salad is small, but mighty, especially with the Parmesan Peppercorn dressing. Super satisfying! The peach mimosa was delicious, especially the caramel cinnamon drizzle on the glass. The atmosphere is festive and fun, but noticably loud. Overall, we enjoyed our dinner and will come back again.
… moreDan Wise
Excellent. Best pizza in town by far. Don’t overlook the pastas and subs. They excel at them too. An amazing addition to the downtown dining scene.
… moreKevin Ellis
Ordered porketta parm pasta the pork was old and rotten the nastiest pork I’ve ever tried and they for got the salad this isn’t the first time I’ve ordered and it was disgusting usually I don’t do reviews but beware this was awful
… morerenee woodward
The food was good. I enjoyed the full bodied flavor of the crust on the pizza as well as the dipping sauce for the garlic knots. We ordered their version of a deluxe pizza and were surprised at the rustic cut of the vegetables. The restaurant is very eye appealing.
We will go there again but will do so earlier in the day to see if it is quieter. Based on our experience if you are looking for a quiet, more romantic dinner, this was not the place the night we were there. However, it does have the right atmosphere to be romantic.
… moreWe will go there again but will do so earlier in the day to see if it is quieter. Based on our experience if you are looking for a quiet, more romantic dinner, this was not the place the night we were there. However, it does have the right atmosphere to be romantic.