Devlynn Deitrick
We ordered custom cookies for our rehearsal dinner and they were the perfect touch! We sent a photo of our welcome sign as inspiration, and they came out absolutely perfect. Not only were they adorable, but they were also delicious, a huge hit with everyone!
… moreLuisa
My partner’s thoughtful surprise brought home an array of specialty cookies, and what a treat it turned out to be! From the first to the last bite, each cookie surpassed the previous in flavor, leaving us thoroughly impressed. The freshness and genuine taste of the ingredients added a delightful touch, making every bite memorable.
The establishment itself is a testament to quality – well-kept, bright, and inviting. The ambiance only added to the overall positive experience. I’m eagerly anticipating my own visit to explore more of their offerings and plan to place orders for upcoming work events.
Comparing these delightful treats to the well-known Crumble Cookie, and for the low price of $3 a cookie I don’t see where you can go wrong here ! there’s no competition – they effortlessly outshine the competition. A solid 5/5 rating across the board! Highly recommend trying these unique and delicious cookies.
… moreFrancesca Martin
I ordered a custom cake for my best friend’s bridal shower and it was absolutely amazing! So beautiful and delicious and exceeded my expectations. Highly recommend!
… morerachael swisher
We ordered cookies from here for my baby shower and OMG! I could not be happier with how they turned out. Not only did they look amazing but they tasted amaaazzzzzzing. All my guests loved and raved about them. We will be ordering all our future cookies from here.
… moreJackie T
I look forward to see what cookies they have every weekend! Their desserts are always a hit at home and at parties.
Kelsey and staff are super friendly. Thank you!
… moreMarissa Green
finally got to go to lily gray sweets after wanting to forever but never having time. i got the gluten free funfetti cookies. i took a bite as soon as i got in my car and they were amazingggg. it’s so nice that they have something gluten free. just a heads up for anyone else, i have a gluten intolerance and am fine with cross contamination. if you’re celiac it may not be safe for you! currently writing this review in my car as well lol
update: i went back and got two more cookies today
… moreBenjamin Capp
LilyGray Sweets exceeded my expectations with the birthday cake I ordered for my brother. The cake was not only exceptionally fluffy but also featured the perfect amount of frosting. The beautiful decoration added a delightful touch, making it not just a dessert but a work of art. LilyGray Sweets has truly mastered the art of balancing taste and aesthetics. If you’re seeking a delicious and visually appealing cake for a special occasion, I highly recommend their exceptional creations.
… moreKelli Brenner
Stopped in for the first time today during week-end “cash and carry” hours. Adorable little place, cakes and pies looked gorgeous, but my mind was on cookies. We tried five of their Christmas themed varieties. Each one was so yum! Of course I can’t remember the adorable names. My favorite is a double chocolate cookie with German Chocolate cake type frosting. The baker has a really great touch with frostings; creamy, but light, sweet, but not too sweet. You can tell she uses good ingredients. I can’t wait for an excuse to buy a cake.
… moreLee Caramma
A small Bakery with a very comfortable and inviting atmosphere. The cookies are large and delicious. My wife and I purchased the lemon, mint chocolate , pistachio and butter pecan. You won’t be disappointed.
… moreAnnie Wenz
The best around! We’ve custom ordered cakes for weddings, showers, birthdays and more. They’re beautiful and delicious. We love LilyGray Sweets!!
… more