Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 82 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009
Phone: (973) 239-2200
Website: https://www.thepilgrimdiner.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pilgrim Diner Restaurant
Conveniently located at 82 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ, Pilgrim Diner is … Join us today and see why we’re known as a top dining destination in New Jersey.
Pilgrim Diner Restaurant | Cedar Grove NJ – Facebook
82% recommend (90 Reviews). . $. . Closed now. . 82 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ, United States, 07009. Links. . thepilgrimdiner.com. Services. .
Pilgrim Diner Restaurant Delivery Menu – Cedar Grove – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Pilgrim Diner Restaurant in Cedar Grove! View Pilgrim Diner Restaurant’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Reviews
Eve
Their display case of beautiful desserts blew me away upon walking in! I didn’t have much time on lunch break but I decided to grab some Manhattan clam chowder, which was recommended and absolutely delicious! I also had one of the best tiramisu slices I have ever had!
… moreKira Lang
I stopped here on a Friday night around 7:30 pm with my husband after attending a viewing at Shooks Funeral Home. We are not from the area and noticed it on our way there and decided to give it a try.
At first when I saw the price listed for most of the non-breakfast items I didn’t realize that it included a soup and a choice of coleslaw or pasta salad. I ordered a Napolitano Panini, the matzoh ball soup, and the pasta salad. I was extremely satisfied with each item I thought the soup and pasta salad was really delicious. When the main meal arrived I knew right away I was going to need to go box! The Panini was delicious and I liked that the french fries were served in a little dish, just the right around to have some and take some home with my leftover panini. My husband ordered the Ruben with corned beef, a manhattan clam chowder and coleslaw. He also enjoy his meal, tried bit of mine, and had a huge to go container to take home for leftovers.
I know we visited when it wasn’t a high volume time, but at the time where there were still a decent amount of tables. Our server was friendly and got our order perfect. Yum! We would absolutely go again.
… moreAt first when I saw the price listed for most of the non-breakfast items I didn’t realize that it included a soup and a choice of coleslaw or pasta salad. I ordered a Napolitano Panini, the matzoh ball soup, and the pasta salad. I was extremely satisfied with each item I thought the soup and pasta salad was really delicious. When the main meal arrived I knew right away I was going to need to go box! The Panini was delicious and I liked that the french fries were served in a little dish, just the right around to have some and take some home with my leftover panini. My husband ordered the Ruben with corned beef, a manhattan clam chowder and coleslaw. He also enjoy his meal, tried bit of mine, and had a huge to go container to take home for leftovers.
I know we visited when it wasn’t a high volume time, but at the time where there were still a decent amount of tables. Our server was friendly and got our order perfect. Yum! We would absolutely go again.
Irene Laz
The waiter was setting the tables for the next day during dinner time, and I noticed her touching the heads of every single fork and knife on the tables with her bare hands.
As for our food, I didn’t even touch it. The milkshake turned out to be just cold chocolate milk, and the chicken fingers were tasteless and looked unappetizing.
However, the pastrami sandwiches were particularly concerning; they appeared to have been prepared a long time in advance. Just look at that meat, bread and pathetic waffle fries.
… moreAs for our food, I didn’t even touch it. The milkshake turned out to be just cold chocolate milk, and the chicken fingers were tasteless and looked unappetizing.
However, the pastrami sandwiches were particularly concerning; they appeared to have been prepared a long time in advance. Just look at that meat, bread and pathetic waffle fries.
Susan O’Neil
We had a wonderful lunch with friends today! The atmosphere was friendly and pleasant. Our server, Maged, was very prompt and upbeat! He always has a big smile and we joke around with him. They have a large menu and offer free refills on beverages. We had a delicious grilled chicken salad. It was very large and filling! We loved it!
… moreJacqueline Balza
A clean and vibrant diner with a lively atmosphere and outstanding service. Our server was incredibly friendly and, despite a small mix-up with my order, went above and beyond to ensure I felt valued as a customer.
… moreJudy Ryan Hall
This is an average diner. Waiters were lovely. I got cheesecake French toast and it was two pieces of French toast with a slab of cheesecake in the middle. I was expecting it to be warm – to have been fried together. But it was cold. Just a little odd. Nice big servings though.
… moreFabio Velasquez Ardila
Disrespectful staff. The host was a man around 70 years old who didn’t even smile. The waitress was very nice, but the cashier didn’t respond to our thank-you — she just looked at my shoes and moved on to the next customer. I don’t think the host or the cashier were regular employees. Now I understand why the restaurant was almost empty. Next time, I’d rather stay hungry than come back again.
… moreJennifer Coates
Was driving through Cedar Gtove to show my mother in law what her childhood town looks like. She highly recommended Pilgram Diner and remembers it to be one of her favorite places to eat in town. My husband and I stopped in for lunch. We had no wait. We were greeted immediately and sat in a booth. Our drink order was taken by the manager. The waitress was nice and attentive. My husband ordered the Denver omelet with hashbrowns, toast, and a side order of taylor ham. I ordered the 2 egg breakfast, with scrambled eggs, 2 pancakes, and hashbrowns.
My eggs were good, hashbrowns were a bit wet and not very tasty, and my 2 pancakes were hard to cut, thick, and rubbery. My husband said his omelet was good, he ate all of his hashbrowns and he said the Taylor ham wasn’t his favorite (it was his 1st time trying this type of meat).
The outside and inside looked recently remodeled. There was hardly any parking, the diner was full. Overall very clean and welcoming. Would recommend visiting and ordering something from the very large menu!
… moreMy eggs were good, hashbrowns were a bit wet and not very tasty, and my 2 pancakes were hard to cut, thick, and rubbery. My husband said his omelet was good, he ate all of his hashbrowns and he said the Taylor ham wasn’t his favorite (it was his 1st time trying this type of meat).
The outside and inside looked recently remodeled. There was hardly any parking, the diner was full. Overall very clean and welcoming. Would recommend visiting and ordering something from the very large menu!
Jon Fergesen
Great matzo ball soup, not so good Charley Daniels chicken and ribs. The soup was very fresh and tasty. The ribs were pretty good, but the sweet potato fries were soggy because they were provided next to the Charley Daniels sauce. The chicken was slightly overcooked. I will get the full rack next time, and with a side that is not French fries.
… moreRob Dan
Good to excellent DINER experience. Service was fast and efficient. We were greeted and seated promptly. Everything was good. Do not know what some folks are complaining about. These folks are serious about delivering a good experience to their customers
… more