Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
#Knotjustbagels Bagel Boys isn’t just your average bagel shop. Located conveniently in the heart of Cedarhurst, it boasts a full range of appetizing delights, including a diverse selection of spreads, salads, pastas, soups, pastries, and more. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or catering for a special occasion, Bagel Boys offers a kosher-certified menu that promises to tantalize your taste buds.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 598 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516
Phone: (516) 374-7644
Website: https://bagelboys.godaddysites.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bagel Boys
Welcome to Bagel Boys … We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours. Bagel Boys. 598 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, New York 11516, …
Bagel Boys On Central – Vaad Hakashrus
Business Info. 516-374-7644 · 598 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY, USA. Inbox. 0 Review For Bagel Boys On Central. Overall. 0.0. Average Rating. 0. 5. Poor. Add a …
Friday brunch at Bagel Boys in Cedarhurst – Facebook
1 reaction ·. 20 comments. . Breakfast at Bagel Boys in Cedarhurst, New York. Monika Anavim ▻ Great Kosher Restaurants Foodies. 1y · Public …
Reviews
Yehuda Egert
5 STARS
Great food. Not cheap on the portions, also have lettuce stalks instead of romaine for that extra freshness. Surprisingly large selection of each item (i.e. for tuna you can get: original, regular, veggie, balsamic, spicy, honey mustard, or low fat veggie). Service was great, lot of staff to keep it moving and not have to wait.
… moreGreat food. Not cheap on the portions, also have lettuce stalks instead of romaine for that extra freshness. Surprisingly large selection of each item (i.e. for tuna you can get: original, regular, veggie, balsamic, spicy, honey mustard, or low fat veggie). Service was great, lot of staff to keep it moving and not have to wait.
paul Smith
I walked in, and there was an older gentleman who was upset, feeling that he was purposely being overlooked. Two of the managers, who I assumed were managers, came out. They tried their best to console him. I could see in their faces that they were even more upset that he felt this way. They genuinely cared, and to me, that means more than any service anybody could provide. That is top-notch service.
… moreShaya Kohn
The bagels are good. The service isn’t great though. The workers are nice and friendly but the wait is very very long. Desperately in need of a renovation
… moreSteven S.
Love eating here with my daughter on Tuesday mornings before school. Best mini bagels in town, perfect for little kids! Great bagels, grest pastries and great muffins too! Also, has plenty of open seating with plenty of space, as well as a nice open, corner view of Central Avenue.
… moreYisroel Brownstein
I wanna start off by recommending the german chocolate cake coffee. Out of this world!
I know the owner personally. He is an extraordinary individual!
But I can easily tell you to put that aside and assure you that I would choose this specific bagel shop over any others in the Tri-state area. Especially if you’re going kosher! After all, bagels are and originated from the Jewish culture. The shop is run well and you can be guaranteed the highest quality and freshest food on the market! I wish I could give you one specific favorite dish. It’s difficult because it’s all really good. I hung out there on one particular night, but I specifically went back and ate there to truly ensure that it’s the same quality, It has always been. This review is up-to-date.
The pastries are phenomenal as well!
I recommend pretty much anything on the menu, but if coffee is something you enjoy, you absolutely must check out this specific one I recommended in this review.
… moreI know the owner personally. He is an extraordinary individual!
But I can easily tell you to put that aside and assure you that I would choose this specific bagel shop over any others in the Tri-state area. Especially if you’re going kosher! After all, bagels are and originated from the Jewish culture. The shop is run well and you can be guaranteed the highest quality and freshest food on the market! I wish I could give you one specific favorite dish. It’s difficult because it’s all really good. I hung out there on one particular night, but I specifically went back and ate there to truly ensure that it’s the same quality, It has always been. This review is up-to-date.
The pastries are phenomenal as well!
I recommend pretty much anything on the menu, but if coffee is something you enjoy, you absolutely must check out this specific one I recommended in this review.
Eli Blau
After multiple visits, each time the food is served wrong. Sometimes it’s the wrong bagel, other times its them ADDING additional stuff to my sandwich and CHARGING me for it.
One time, they didn’t even let me finish ordering before they made the food.
If I come, I’m hungry and I don’t have patience to deal with the utter disrespect this establishment provides. Shame on them.
… moreOne time, they didn’t even let me finish ordering before they made the food.
If I come, I’m hungry and I don’t have patience to deal with the utter disrespect this establishment provides. Shame on them.
Andrew Liebowitz
We needed to cater in Breakfast for our Breakfast Connect Membership Drive that was held on January 8th, 2025 in the Hewlett Fire Department Ballroom. One of our members, Rosalie recommended Bagel Boys in Cedarhurst. We sat down with the very nice owner who was extremely accommodating and personable. He worked out a great deal for us and stayed within our budget. I was assured that the breakfast would be ready for pickup at 7am. As I drove up to Bagel Boys window, I saw everything nicely laid out at 6:50am, ahead of time. Even though he offered free delivery, I chose to pick it up. I walked in and was happy to see the owner and his crew bring the entire spread along with coffee out to my car. Everyone at the event enjoyed the breakfast. It was really great food! They did an amazing job. I am going back to Bagel Boys for our next event in the Spring. If you want quality, quantity and great food from a friendly business owner, I strongly recommend Bagel Boys on Central Avenue in Cedarhurst. Their catering is Absolutely Fantastic!!
… moreDavid Akhamzadeh
Great food great service and very welcoming , we had to grab some kosher foot on the way to the airport and they where very helpful.
… moreDaniel Heideman
Bagel was ok. Definitely a small bagel, but generous with toppings. The bagel also took 20 min to be ready. Bagel + drink was $11
… moreLeora Goldberg
I catered our holiday office party from Bagel Boys and was so impressed with the quality and quantity of food that I then catered my family holiday too! Yossi was an absolute pleasure to work with. They are more than just bagels – we ordered sides of salmon, salads, pasta dishes, wraps, and desserts! I will definitely be catering from them again!
… more