Square Peg Pizzeria Storrs is a popular Italian restaurant located near Storrs, Connecticut, offering a unique dining experience with a focus on delicious pizzas and brunch options. Our cozy restaurant is known for its authentic Italian cuisine, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re craving a traditional Italian dish or a mouthwatering pizza, our menu has something for everyone. Visit us in Storrs CT and taste the flavors of Italy at Square Peg Pizzeria Storrs.
Order Online – Square Peg Pizzeria
Order online from Storrs, including STARTERS, SALADS, WOOD FIRED PIZZAS … Square Peg Pizzeria Storrs. 9 Dog Lane, Storrs, CT. Change location. Delivery.
Daniel Robertson
Dangerous food prep. Do not eat here! Raw chicken served to my 9 month pregnant wife. Can’t even call them to complain. Phone is busy. Entire order for $100 was screwed up. Salad for $20, no dressing included so can’t eat tit. Wings under cooked, boneless wings were raw!!! Shut this place down!!!
… moreSam Forbes
If you are looking for the best pizza in the UConn area, Square Peg Pizzeria is an absolute must-visit! Located right in Downtown Storrs, it has quickly become my go-to spot for an incredible wood-fired pie and a great vibe.
The menu is much more than your standard pizzeria. I highly recommend the “Oh Honey” or the “Figgy Piggy” if you want something unique, but even their classic pepperoni is top-tier with a perfectly chewy, charred crust. Their fried mozzarella is a total game-changer (they serve both sticks and balls!), and you can’t leave without trying the Pasta Alla Vodka.
The atmosphere is fun and energetic—perfect for a post-game meal or a casual night out with friends. Despite how busy they get with the college crowd, the staff is always friendly and efficient. Whether you’re a local or just visiting campus, Square Peg is the “Disneyland” of Italian-American comfort food. Five stars all the way!
… moreJ N
Stopped in for quick snack after moving my junior into her apartment. Our server was fine, very pleasant and attentive.
We ordered the calamari app and a couple salads with chicken. The calamari was just OK, quite a bit heavier than we expected, but I’ll chalk that up to a preference thing.
The salads however, were terrible. The roast chicken was OK, but both salads (a ceasar and a beet) were just so soggy we just couldn’t get them down. The beet salad did not have many beets, and somehow there was a potato chip in it! Being very tired and just wanting to get back home after a long morning of moving, we just took our leftovers and left. We won’t be eating them. I just didn’t have the energy to complain at the time. $60 plus tip for 2 people with no drinks is a steep bill. Feels even steeper when the food is that disappointing.
… moreIshan Thakur
Food especially during happy hour is the best bang for the buck in the UConn area. Marina provides great service and provides a friendly atmosphere, very professional servers in general but she is most notable in my opinion. Food off happy hour menu is good as well for full price options still great bang for the buck. Overall great place, great food, great service.
… moreDanielle Toper
Picture of the margarita pizza should speak for itself lol. Worst looking margarita pizza I’ve ever seen! Just horrible looking pizzas. Ordered 5 total and they were all put together poorly – barely any toppings, scattered in random spots, by no means evenly distributed. Arrived cold. Not to mention one of them incorrect/not what we ordered. Very disappointed!
… moreAlani Navarro
Came in and grabbed a seat at the bar and had such a great experience. I ordered the Caesar salad and wow — it was so good, fresh, perfectly dressed, honestly one of the best I’ve had. Shoutout to the cook Teddy — absolute legend. Amazing food, great vibe, and awesome people. Will definitely be back.
… moreReese Jasminski
Last week I dined in at Square Peg. The food, service, atmosphere – all of it was amazing. I had Mekhi as my server, he was attentive and timely. Not to mention he was hilarious and we had some good laughs – you don’t find many people these days like that. Anyways, definitely visit Square Peg in Storrs!! And request Mekhi if you can!!
… moreAllison Mercado
If you’re visiting your child at uconn or coming by for a home game, make sure to stop by Square Peg Pizzeria. The pizza I had the other day before the game was absolutely out of this world. Ricky recommended his favorite, “The Carnivore,” which is like a meat lovers type of pie, but when I say it was so good I ordered one to take home.
Thank you Rick for the great hospitality!
… moreKeegan Appleby
Mekhi was an exceptional bartender. He was attentive, personable, and effortlessly skilled. He crafted every drink with care and made the entire experience feel elevated and welcoming. After a long week of being laid off, losing my job, and getting fired — he offered top-tier service to turn my frown upside down. Thanks Mekhi!
… moreConner Landry
I’ve gone here a few times and every time I have had a fantastic experience. One server in particular, Mekhi, has been my favorite. He is extremely personable and goes above and beyond to provide great service. The Lemon Pepper wings are some of my favorite to order!
… more