Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 12 N Main St, Warsaw, NY 14569
Phone: (585) 228-1246
Website: http://stefanosnystyle.pizza/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Stefano’s Pizzeria | Warsaw NY – Facebook
Stefano’s Pizzeria, Warsaw. 1455 likes · 52 talking about this · 162 were here. NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA.
Stefano’s Pizzeria – Pizza, Family Restaurant, Pizza Pasta Delivery …
Stefano’s. Since 1985. Serving homemade Pizza, Pasta, Subs, Salads, Wings and more. Family Restaurant. Delivery, Pick up, Eat In.
Stefano’s Pizzeria, 12 N Main St, Warsaw, NY 14569, US – MapQuest
Stefano’s Pizzeria is a New York-style pizzeria located in Warsaw, NY, known for its commitment to using fresh ingredients in every dish.
Reviews
Abel theGuru
Very good New York Stye, haven’t had such good pizza in a while. Garlic knots are awesome and sauce was A+
… moreRachel Ampe
Pizza was alright tasting. Put good amount of toppings on. Garlic bread with cheese had an off flavor, not good. Both my fiance and I had upset stomachs shortly after we ate.
… moreKraig Lyons (VinjiOfTheDeep)
Ordered: Large Turkey Club with Lettuce, Onions, Tomatoes, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Provalone Cheese, and Blue Cheese
The sub was mostly just tasting dry bread. As you can see from the 1/2 of sub on the plate, they were missing my black olives. There is 1 very thin onion on the entire half. There is 2 1/2 banana peppers on the entire half. The bacon was soggy and honestly tasted terrible. The Lettuce was soggy and gross. I’m highly disappointed for this to be the product they put out to their customers. This cost me almost $12. You want business, then you should demonstrate that you care about what is servers to your customers. 1 out of 5 stars.
… moreThe sub was mostly just tasting dry bread. As you can see from the 1/2 of sub on the plate, they were missing my black olives. There is 1 very thin onion on the entire half. There is 2 1/2 banana peppers on the entire half. The bacon was soggy and honestly tasted terrible. The Lettuce was soggy and gross. I’m highly disappointed for this to be the product they put out to their customers. This cost me almost $12. You want business, then you should demonstrate that you care about what is servers to your customers. 1 out of 5 stars.
Justin Novak
By far the best pizza here in town. The staff and quality of the food is fantastic, and the atmosphere of perfect for a western NY town.
… moreRicky Davis Sr.
Without question low value…Nothing on the order was right ..look at this 40.00 pizza and it’s not even cooked.
This is raw dough. That we waited for over an hour and half for..
Unbelievable..
this is the 4th time.
In Warsaw and need to eat? Keep driving until you are somewhere else
… moreThis is raw dough. That we waited for over an hour and half for..
Unbelievable..
this is the 4th time.
In Warsaw and need to eat? Keep driving until you are somewhere else
Lorenza Dimartino
Oh my god this place is so amazing I love the old antiques and photos everywhere. Everyone is so nice and friendly. On top of that the food is delicious this place has the best pizza ever. Eat here if you want good pizza!!!!!!!
… moreDerrick Hunter (Guarded Life LLC)
Man, spare of the moment hunger hit me at 9:30 pm. The small Pepperoni pizza and mild wings were delicious. True NY style.
From ya friendly yinzer nieghbor. I suggest a stop in.
… moreFrom ya friendly yinzer nieghbor. I suggest a stop in.
W. B
Excellent pizza. Good and quick customer service.
Place was quiet on a Sunday evening. Both guys working were very helpful..
Pizza is said to be New York style and it is but crust slightly former. Really enjoyed it.
Place looks a bit dated but expected from a quaint little town. Friendly people.
… morePlace was quiet on a Sunday evening. Both guys working were very helpful..
Pizza is said to be New York style and it is but crust slightly former. Really enjoyed it.
Place looks a bit dated but expected from a quaint little town. Friendly people.
Dave Gardingham
Being from downstate NY, I’m always on the hunt for authentic NY style pizza in the WNY region. Stefano’s came through! Solid crust, super cheesy, and a perfectly tart, subtle sauce.
… moreLeslie G
Food was delicious. We got boneless wings, pizza, mozzarella sticks, and cheesesteak sub. The wings were very delicious and saucy. The mozzarella sticks were nice and crunchy. Pizza was freshly made and very good. Didn’t try the sub but looked very meaty and tasty.
… more