Jacquelyn G.
Cute little cafe. The service and food were excellent! Our server was awesome. We tried the wedge salad, broccoli cheese soup & the fish tacos. The fish tacos could have used a little more flavor, but everything else was great.
… moreLisa Lewey-Shields
The ambiance, decor, waitstaff and food is amazing. Both breakfast and lunch were yummy and spot on. Very reasonable, good portions, and home cooking. And then you add in the bakery items and desserts, not enough words to describe how good they were. We will be back again and again…… So well worth the 92 miles round trip.
… morejoh King
Anachronistically charming place with modern-day prices. They have a limited menu, and don’t serve breakfast on Wednesdays and Thursdays. :/
… moreBeth Thompson
Been wanting to try this place for a while. My family finally made the trip to Fairbury IL to try this place and I can say we were all happily pleased. I love the vintage atmosphere, as the restaurant looks like it was once a bank. My SO had the brisket sandwich and he ended up taking half of it home because it was almost too much for h I really enjoyed my French onion soup. My daughter wanted to take home one of their GIANT cinnamon rolls, and I’m not kidding, the thing is about the size of my head!! Really looking forward to trying it out, and also making another trip in the future!
UPDATED 2-11-24: My SO and I stopped here for lunch as we were in the area. This time we had the chicken salad croissant and he had the pot roast beer cheese sandwich. Both were incredibly tasty and well portioned. Finished our meal with a slice of fresh baked apple pie and ice cream. We also picked up their infamous cinnamon rolls from nearby Dave”s Supermarket to take home for Sunday morning breakfast. Never a disappointment when we stop at Lost In Time!!
… moreH Jim , Mary Caswell
Great Breakfast, Farmers Omelet was wonderful and the sausage gravy was possibly the best I’ve ever had
… moreChelsea Whitcomb
Lost In Time catered a work lunch for a large group of us off site. The food was AMAZING! Sarah was so great to work with. Going to make this an annual event for our team can’t wait to work with the Lost In Time crew again!
… moreLeni Johnson
Was a very historical place to eat at. And very interesting that it was a Bank. Just wish I could tour the rest of the building. People there were very very nice and polite. If I’m in the area again I will definitely go back
… moreWhitney Martin
Excellent service. The building tells the story of all the owners. It’s a Midwest must do. The sandwich and soup were truly delicious and tasted of homemade love. Stop by pop in for a spell or grab it to go. You will not be disappointed.
… moreBrad Smith
A really quaint place with great food for an affordable price. Small touches really make the food better, like homemade lemonade and using fresh (not canned) pineapple.
The selection of glass bottle sodas is fun, too.
And of course you have to try a dessert from the connected bakery.
I also have to mention that they did an amazing job using the history of the building in the architecture and decor of the place. It’s fun to see a kitchen prep room that used to be a bank vault.
… moreAshton Melchert
Fresh ingredients & homemade recipes make this an awesome hometown hotspot! Not to mention the GIGANTIC cinnamon rolls and ALL the history in this building make it a perfect stop for locals & travelers alike!
… more