Adrian Farrow
Pulled up to Silver Eagle and let me tell you — they’re doing their thing out here in Monona ️
What We Had
Clam Chowder – Warm, comforting, and exactly what you want when you order chowder.
Fried Shrimp – Completely fried, golden brown, cooked in fresh grease. Clean crunch, no heaviness.
Walleye – Cooked to perfection. Flaky, flavorful, and done right — Midwest fish lovers, you already know
The Beans – Don’t sleep on these. Absolutely amazing and worth the mention all by themselves.
All the Trimmings – They give you everything you’re supposed to get — no shortcuts.
Service
Now let’s talk service — A+. Our waitress went over and beyond, checked in at the right times, and made the whole experience smooth. Food came out fresh, hot, and on point.
⭐ Final Score
Food: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4-star food)
Scale: 9.1 out of 10, baby
Silver Eagle is a solid stop if you want good food, great service, and no nonsense. Respect to the kitchen and the staff — keep cooking like that
— Mr. AATOTD
When it’s right, I say it’s right. ️
… moreiNguyening
The food was great. I had the fish fried (3 pieces baked cod). Should have an old-fashioned with, but as it was REALLY busy I wanted to make it simple and not go crazy for the bartender. The service was better than average, and I figured it would be better if it was not so busy. Kinda crazy to ask a restaurant NOT to be busy though, right? Pretty much everything on my plate was good, the mashed potatoes were good. If there is anything to complain about, it was the bread roll. The bread roll isn’t my thing anyway, so not such a big deal. Yes, I have had some bread rolls that were amazing…so I’m not counting them out completely. Even the coleslaw was good. I do like mine a tad bit more tangy tasting, but U can’t ask for it all, right? RIGHT? The clam chowder was great btw. Over all, it was a nice experience, at least this time I remember. I had fond memories of this place probably over 30 yrs ago! Wonder if it still has the same owner. it was one of those nights hanging out with the boys and looking for a place to have a few.
… moreMark Buehl
Our first Friday Night Fish Fry and it was fantastic! Both the Cod and Walleye were really great! The service was friendly and really good given how busy it was. We were there before for bar burgers and they were fantastic. So we HAD to try the Friday Night Fish Fry and were not disappointed!
… moreElijah Toay
6 stars! Got Local beers for only $5! Got the taco Tuesday menu less than 10 bucks! We sat ourselves, all of our food was super fast I even commented in pleasant surprise. Ashley was the best as well! I found my favorite spot ! love this place!
… moreMonica Lucid
The music was too loud. I understand you don’t want to hear other people’s conversations but I would like to hear the people I’m with. This is a great place to watch sports as there are a lot of TVs. There are a few gambling machines. The restrooms were clean and stocked. There are several small and large tables to sit at for groups. They don’t know how to make mocktails except Shirley temples or if you tell them what to make. I don’t know if they serve food here. It was late at night and nobody was eating.
… moreCanne
Lunch here is nearly guaranteed to get you in and out in under the hour. And the food is flavorful. There seems to be only one “low” table and the rest are bar stool height – that’s the only minus. Love their fries!
… moreNicole Wnek
Stopped here for lunch and was very pleased with the tasty walleye sandwich. Great service and tasty food. Will stop again.
… moreTorina Fraboni
Absolutely love this bar & grill! Fantastic menu options and accommodations to aversions. Love the bartenders and waitstaff, very witty and clever. I enjoy all the different events, menu specials, the sunny patio, beer selection and quantity of televisions. Cannot say enough great things about this bar!
… morethomas walsh
For a neighborhood hang out, this place was quite festive. The fried cod was cooked to perfection, the pork & beans/with lima beans with bacon was excellent, the Cole slaw was decent (nothing like moms), the French fries could have been better, if the oil was changed. All in all, it was a good time.
… moreLIKE AFOX
Drove by this place for decades finally went in, had tators and tacos good and why so cheap? Have I been missing out all these decades, I think so! Mostly blue collar workers there at lunch, they must know!
… more