Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shop is a premium sandwich shop. Our shops offer hand sliced proprietary proteins and cheeses topped with sauces that are made daily. All sandwiches are served on our fresh baked rolls, including our famous Dutch Crunch roll. Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shop offers best in class sandwiches including the famous Big Jake, Reuben, and of course The Mr. Pickle. Our twenty- six plus years of success is rooted in the simple formula of “Making the Guest Happy” by providing craveable sandwiches, exceptional guest service, and local community involvement.
Regional chain serving hot & cold specialty sandwiches & salads over the counter.
Hours
| Friday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 20674 Rustic Dr, Castro Valley, CA 94546
Phone: (510) 398-8532
Website: https://www.mrpickles.com/location/mr-pickles-castro-valley-ca-rustic-drive/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Mr. Pickle’s Castro Valley, CA – Rustic Drive
Find store hours and information for Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shop located in Castro Valley and come enjoy one of our award winning sandwiches.
Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shop | We are a premier full service-sandwich …
We are a premier full service-sandwich shop specializing in innovative sandwiches, salads and catering.
Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shops | Castro Valley CA – Facebook
Mr. Pickle’s Sandwich Shops. Mr. Pickle’s sandwiches are made with high quality meats & cheeses, served on delicious San Francisco style breads – freshly baked.
Reviews
Evez Journey
This was my first time there so it took a few minutes for me to decide on what to get bit the person making the sandwiches was patient and answered my questions. We ended up getting the “hang loose” and it was so good! One of the best sandwiches I’ve had in my 41 years of living (besides the ones I make at home). They even gave us courtesy chocolate chip cookies in our bag! My son was so happy! What a great way to spend new years day 2026.
… moreJessica Jackson
Edit: I did finally hear back from someone and the issue was resolved.
I generally love Mr. Pickles and I hate leaving such a low review. I accidentally placed an pick-up order instead of delivery. I realized immediately and tried to call to cancel or change the order. I’ve called 8 times over 15 minutes now and the call won’t go through. The phone number either asks for a remote access code or says the mailbox is full.
… moreI generally love Mr. Pickles and I hate leaving such a low review. I accidentally placed an pick-up order instead of delivery. I realized immediately and tried to call to cancel or change the order. I’ve called 8 times over 15 minutes now and the call won’t go through. The phone number either asks for a remote access code or says the mailbox is full.
Jewel
This was my first time trying Mr. Pickles, and I ordered pastrami, on Dutch crunch bread, with mayo, mustard, avocado, pickles, and cucumbers, lettuce, pepper jack cheese, American cheese, with a bowl of macaroni salad. It was a great portion and was very tasty. I received a chocolate cookie that was given with no extra cost. I would recommend it, and I will be ordering here again.
… moreSaira Sereal
I choose this shop 9 out of 10 times because, honestly, one sandwich counts as both lunch and dinner for me. Mr. Pickle’s has a unique menu and ingredients list that I think sets it apart from other larger chains—think Dutch crunch rolls, peperoncinis, avocado at no extra charge in some recipes, and potato salads. My favorite part, though, is the surprise chocolate chip cookie (or sometimes multiple cookies) that I find at the bottom of my bag every time. It’s a small detail, but one that really influences my decision to come back. Many other sandwich shops charge for snacks, but I admire that Mr. Pickle’s throws one in on the house as a light bite. I also appreciate the kindness of the staff at this location and their dedication to preparing every order with the mindset of choosing quality over quantity.
… moreMarie G
I live this place. The always get my order right and I like how there are 3 different sizes of every sandwich. Also, it seems like their the only ones who sell DUTCH CRUNCH.
Low cost and healthy. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreLow cost and healthy. I’ll definitely be back!
T T
THESE GUYS ARE HUSTLING. The workers here are always professional and the food is really good!
… moreGenesis Nambo
Ordered two sandwiches from this place. My
Husband really enjoyed his Philly cheesesteak. I got the Mr.Pickels and it was
Good. The customer service is amazing. Try the cookies and you won’t be disappointed.
… moreHusband really enjoyed his Philly cheesesteak. I got the Mr.Pickels and it was
Good. The customer service is amazing. Try the cookies and you won’t be disappointed.
Tony Padilla
Restaurant in Castro Valley California. Very nice. Nice atmosphere people very helpful. Enjoyed the food. I loved the place.
… moreJess Linde-Goodfellow
Let me preface this by saying I went to this location on a Sunday night…
My sandwiches had barley anything added to it: 1 tomato, 4 thin slices of onion, little to no lettuce, and hardly any chicken. Not to mention that the bread tasted stale. There was also no cookie given. I understand that it was a Sunday night and it was the end of the week, however, there was no discount offered to account for the significant lack of toppings given. Although the sandwich tasted fine, I needed to add toppings of my own once at home. For an order of 2 sandwiches amounting to $26, I expect a bit of a higher quality. I understand inflation is through the roof but the rise in cost should not correlate with a depletion of quality.
… moreMy sandwiches had barley anything added to it: 1 tomato, 4 thin slices of onion, little to no lettuce, and hardly any chicken. Not to mention that the bread tasted stale. There was also no cookie given. I understand that it was a Sunday night and it was the end of the week, however, there was no discount offered to account for the significant lack of toppings given. Although the sandwich tasted fine, I needed to add toppings of my own once at home. For an order of 2 sandwiches amounting to $26, I expect a bit of a higher quality. I understand inflation is through the roof but the rise in cost should not correlate with a depletion of quality.