Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 586 River Rd, Fair Haven, NJ 07704
Phone: (732) 852-2033
Website: https://www.nicholascreamery.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
FAIR HAVEN | NicholasCreamery
Located right in the town center of Fair Haven, NJ, Nicholas Creamery is the perfect place to walk with family and friends to grab a a scoop and catch up …
Nicholas Creamery: Homemade Small Batch Ice Cream
Nicholas Creamery was created out of a love for homemade ice cream, high … Fair Haven, NJ 07704. 732-852-2033. . Hours: Sun-Thurs: 12PM to 9PM. Fri- Sat …
Nicholas Creamery (@nicholascreamery) · Fair Haven, NJ – Instagram
New Jersey Homemade, Small Batch Ice Cream Atlantic Highlands▪️ Fair Haven◾️Tinton Falls▪️Long Branch▪️Middletown▪️Wall #nicholascreamery …
Reviews
KGQ NYC
Great little spot for delicious, small batch, artisan ice cream. Original flavors like Fluffernutter (peanut butter and marshmallow, of course), Brown Sugar Cookie Dough, Mango Coconut and more “adult” flavors like Cherry Goat Cheese and Tahitian Vanilla. There were so many tempting flavors, we considered a “flight” of 6 scoops but begrudgingly talked ourselves out of it. We maintained self control and vowed to be back soon to try another flavor or two.
… moreCharlie Slavin
Great ice cream spot with many varied flavors, along with soft serve options. House made ice ream, very delicious. Would highly recommend
… moreGrace McKay
This place is . The brown sugar cookie dough would have been enough for an EASY 5 stars, but I also tried peanut butter palooza and coffee crunch, both of which were super flavorful and delicious. This ice cream is RICH – although surprisingly the prices were not. 3 scoops in a large cup for $5.95 is a win all around. The spoons were sturdy, I didn’t try a cone because I only saw homemade waffle which looked awesome but unfortunately the one downfall of this place is that they’re cash only and I was already scrounging to afford my much needed ice cream. Pst – A lot of only cash places have started taking Venmo. Although they do have an ATM inside at least.
… moreDaniel Sclafani
So delicious! Everyone in our group enjoyed our ice cream. It was so creamy & sweet, just fantastic! Between us, we got 5 or 6 different flavors and they were all incredible. I’ll come back here in a heartbeat.
… moreKatrina
Nicholas Creamery always has new flavors, I’m always trying something new every time I visit. The ice cream is fresh, the staff is friendly & awesome, can’t wait to visit all of their locations.
… moreAaron Chang
It’s safe to say that Nicholas Creamery sells the best ice cream in Monmouth County. The flavors are always fresh, the service is always efficient, and the owners are outstanding. I also went to school with Mr. Harary’s son and can say that they’re an amazing family. Super kind, skilled, and welcoming
… moreRon Foley
I buy the staff of tutors at Foley Prep Nicholas Creamery ice cream every time I’m in Fair Haven. Today I had sweet Jersey Corn and Coffee Bourbon Chip in a warm, crispy, perfect home made waffle cone. Inventive flavors but all within the range of amazing to delicious. Go go go!
… morePastor Kenneth Gorman
Nice little ice cream shop. Good flavors. Scoop are small but for the price, I think it works out. $5.25 for two scoops. The young lady seemed to be annoyed since we were asking questions since it was our first time here.
… moreDaniel Sean
The best ice cream on the bay shore. Fresh ingredients, great service, and most of all, amazing ice cream ! The coffee crunch ice cream was one of the best I’ve had in a long time.
… moreMichael Puello
Overrated! I was very disappointed because I only came due to the great reviews. We tried peaches and cream, watermelon, and vanilla. The Ice-cream are not creamy, don’t feel fresh and barely have any taste. Honestly one of the worse ice-cream I’ve ever had. Two stars because the staff was Amazing and welcoming.
… more