Jason M
Great folks! As far as the pizza goes, it is perfectly serviceable as a local option (maybe an 8/10?). You will find objectively better elsewhere (9/10), but I think this place shines in particular for the quality of their proteins, like the meatball and sausage.
My go-to is a Sausage and Pepper hero, hold the cheese, and probably a side of meatballs. I’ve had iffy results ordering these early in the day, but at night like 9 PM is when they’ve always been amazing. I think it slow-cooks or marinates? Though, my subjective correlation isn’t causation and I might be wrong.
The last meatballs I had were incredible.
And, to be constructive, I think the sauce on the pizza is a little unusually sweet. I think the dough and cheese are perfect, the cook is perfect, but the sauce asserts itself a little much. Might try light sauce on my next pie!
… moreJul L
Coming from south Jersey…the buffalo chicken pizza was delicious! Just a little chilly inside!
… moreEric Fan
Been going here since my college days, great buffalo chicken pizza and heros. The knots and wings are good too, and this is coming from someone who eats wings out of Buffalo, NY.
… morekarina k
When I miss NY style pizza this Station Pizza is the place I go to . I have been going to this place since 1990 and it’s my favorite place on Long Island! The cheese is fresh and chewy and the sauce is just right w lots of tomatoes and flavor and the crust ID thin and crispy but chewy. Everywhere I go in the US I crave Station Pizza. You have to try it. Always happy and satisfied every time and so do all my friends.
… moreTom Ph
OMG SO GOOD
Large pie 1/2 Pineapple & Bacon, 1/2 Mushroom & Sausage, plus garlic knots
Every bit was incredible!
Delivery took 30min and when I received the food I immediately noticed that the pie was a lot heavier than any other local establishments. It’s nice to get more for your money. But even more impressive was how tasty everything was. It’s like eyes roll back in your head tasty! WOW
… moreScott Rodriguez
Many places charge an arm and a leg for a slice of pizza. Station is fair with pricing, the pies are made well, and I love the old school vibes. Their other dishes are good too. Get out of your comfort zone!! Been coming here for 11 years.
… moreJuliana cardoza
omg best white pizza I’ve ever had(better than nyc) 10/10. The plain cheese side was very good. The staff was very sweet and personable. My new go to pizza spot ❤️❤️❤️❤️
… moreDave Lee
Mushroom Pizza Pie. Not a pizza I would recommend. I dont know how this place received 4.5 stars. I dont feel the love in the pizza, Felt lazy, thrown together instead of a bit of work, such as sauteing the mushrooms. The sauce is a bit sweet for my taste. Good luck if you go there. Probably a hit or miss place.
… moreDebbie
Oh, man. This pizza is slammin!!!!
Plain cheeze’ll do ya!
Hot, gooey, and yummy sauce.
Thank you, Tom, the owner!
All the best!!
(Debbie the customer. )
Delicious meatballs, too!!!
… moreAdam Zeng
A great, reliable local spot easily accessible from Stony Brook University. Pizza tastes great and don’t forget to check out their heroes too! They’ve been around forever and you can’t go wrong with Station Pizza.
… more