Lorraine McCoy
Very good rustic food. The staff makes sure your food is hot and tasty. The best soft ice cream around, very generous servings.
… moreKim LaRose
This is a great place to get some really great food. The staff is so nice and friendly, the food tastes wonderful and who doesn’t like ice cream? The prices are good and the portions are just right! Wonderful place to eat!
… moreTatar Schulz
I’m not one for writing reviews I’ve been to the Custard Cottage twice this year since it’s had new owners. Twice the new owner has walked past me and not said hello nor how are you doing. being a new business owner in town you think she would be a little more friendly at least come out and see how you’re doing especially if she’s standing right in front of you. The food pretty good the ice cream was pretty good. The girl that took my order was extremely nice.. My biggest thing is if you’re a new business owner and you see new faces maybe you should interact with them a little bit more I understand sometimes people get busy. But she wasn’t that busy on her phone worrying about a package that had been delivered to her house. Interaction with customers brings them back especially the ones that they have not seen before or does not know. Not just with people she knows. Because you know they’re gonna come back and spend money people you don’t know first impression says it all. I’ll go back just because I like the ice cream for the conversation and take my grandson there because that’s what I’ve done with him for the 9 years .
… moreJohn June
Yummy. Every time I travel back to Gouverneur, I make sure I go here at least twice. Can beat it!! It’s been a lot of years now, last time was in 2011 and we went there four times.
… moreLisa Hendricks
They have the best ice cream in all of St. Lawrence County!
… moreErica M. Gardner
Recently this was my first visit in many years since my childhood. Nothing has really changed as well. I got the chocolate and vanilla soft serve ice cream cone.
… moreShana Silva
The new management is top notch. Ready to contribute to the community. Hard working. Classic food with improvements (yay, grilled chicken). Produce stand is in the works and we love the Hershey’s ice cream. Came for dinner & stayed for ice cream. Can’t wait to see what is next.
… moreEarl Mashaw
Been visiting the Custard Cottage my whole life and it never dissapoints. Go with the Maple Walnut scoops, you’ll see why
… moreWill Gallup
This is such a classic landmark whenever I’m going through on route 11. The prices are amazing and the workers are nice. The soft serve is amazing!
… more