Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4919 Oleander Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34982
Phone: (772) 828-3057
Website: https://www.toasttab.com/downtown-bennys-pizza-midway
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Benny’s Downtown Pizza – Stuart and Port St Lucie Pizza
We hear it time and time again that Big Apple Pizza has the best NY style pizza in Florida. … GET DIRECTIONS TO BIG APPLE PIZZA IN FORT PIERCE · 1007 SEAWAY …
Downtown Benny’s Pizza – Midway – Order Online
Downtown Benny’s Pizza – Midway. 4919 Oleander Avenue, Fort Pierce, FL. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 4919 Oleander Avenue, Fort Pierce, FL. Schedule your order …
Downtown Benny’s Pizza – 4919 Oleander Ave, Fort Pierce, FL 34982
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Fort Pierce, FL! Downtown Benny’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Reviews
Gabriel Shames
HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! I stopped by on my way home from work and got the Anti Pasta salad and two slices of cheese pizza, I think delicious is an understatement!! The service was great and the gentleman working the kitchen was very helpful and friendly!! Wish I knew sooner about this place.
If you are looking for a reasonably priced lunch/dinner cooked right this is your place!
… moreIf you are looking for a reasonably priced lunch/dinner cooked right this is your place!
Soraya Marini
Went in for dinner after a long day and this place did the job. The pizza came out hot with a solid crust, not too thick and not paper thin either. Sauce had a nice balance, not overly sweet, and the cheese was melted just right. I tried a pepperoni slice and a veggie one, both were decent and filling. Staff was friendly and didn’t rush us, which I appreciated. The dining area was clean, though a little noisy during peak time. Prices felt fair for the portion sizes. Not the fanciest pizza I’ve had, but it’s a reliable spot I’d come back to again.
… moreTina Kunshier
The pizza is amazing!! We ordered there and ate in their small dining room. I had meat lovers gluten free and my wife had regular crust meat… amazing!!
While we were there tons of people came in for to go orders. They poor their hearts into the pizza!!
Not fancy; just delicious!!
… moreWhile we were there tons of people came in for to go orders. They poor their hearts into the pizza!!
Not fancy; just delicious!!
Jess Blizzy
I had to stop in the middle of eating just to write this! This was my first time at this restaurant but it DEFINITELY won’t be the last. I ordered the small meat calzone…..PEOPLE, THIS IS THE SMALL! It was huge and so perfect. It has FIVE different meats and none of them fell out of the calzone while eating it. The marinara sauce makes me want to try their pizza. It was the best balance of sweet and tangy. The staff is awesome and very socially pleasant. If you’re ever on Midway Road, look over in the orange plaza and give Benny’s a try! Love, love, LOOOOVE it!
… moreBodi Anderson
We have been going to Downtown Benny’s for a couple years now and when they opened up a midway store, we were excited. Last July the store changed to new owners and somehow the Pizza has gotten even better. The folks who run it are from Queens, New York, so you know they can make a killer pizza. All of them are so friendly and I’ve talked with him so much. I know them by name. For the price, it’s the best pizza in town, The super friendly staff just make it all the better. I would definitely recommend
… moreRandy and Trish Lake
Pizza was awesome. One of the best that we had in Florida. Only thing that they don’t have is a soda fountain.They do offer cans of pepsi & coke products however.We had cheesey garlic bread,it could of used a little more cheese but it still tasted good. We had a cheese/ sausage pizza & a Benny’s special pizza.Both were awesome.Staff was friendly. There is indoor eating which is a plus.Deffinately recommend this place. We will be back.Only wish they offered small size salads . Update: They do offer small side salads now.Also check their specials.You can get a good deal.
… moreP Rivera
If you’re looking for NYC/Jersey style pizza — large slices and the famous thin crust that makes that undeniable crunch sound as you bite into it — this is the place! Picked up a pie for take out and while I waited they welcomed me to a free can of soda (my choice). Quality service and delicious pizza. Pizza pie pricing is a little high, however the product is quality. The only eyesore is their location as the plaza is in need of a new facelift. However, their interior dining area although small appears very organized and clean.
… moreTheresa Orellana
Benny’s Pizza is hands down one of the best! The owners are always so friendly, and they make ordering super easy and customizable. The pizza is absolutely delicious and-bonus-it’s easy on my sensitive tummy, which is rare to find. We’ve used them countless times for catering orders, and they always go above and beyond. Everything arrives hot, fresh, and right on time.
On top of that, their prices are very affordable. While the pizza is the star, they have so much more to offer. My kids love their wings, pasta, calzones, and desserts, and there are tons of tasty appetizers to choose from too. Truly a local gem we’re grateful to have!
… moreOn top of that, their prices are very affordable. While the pizza is the star, they have so much more to offer. My kids love their wings, pasta, calzones, and desserts, and there are tons of tasty appetizers to choose from too. Truly a local gem we’re grateful to have!
Jaismane Niacaris
We ordered the Hawaiian pizza, garlic Parmesan wings and tiramisu. The pizza was delicious. The wings were not done, they were dark pinkish red in the center. The sauce was good so I was disappointed. The tiramisu was frozen in the middle. It was our first time ordering from here so not sure about eating here again.
… moreRichard Shilling
Excellent pizza, great tasting crust, generous toppings. We really loved the the Pasta ala Vodka, a very large portion and the appetizer portion of the sausage was incredible. The salad was fresh and crisp. Highly recommend this restaurant. Delivery was fast and very courteous.
… more