Heather Perez
I’ve heard good things about their sauce that originated in Italy and has been passed down for generations. It didn’t disappoint. It was also a pleasant surprise that anchovies were a topping option. You dont see that often anymore and it reminds me of my nanny that passed decades ago. ♡ I ordered a large with pepperoni, Italian sausage and half anchovies. Oh, and a small chef salad.
… moreLeroy Wertz
6/21/25
Nice quite place
If I were to order again, I’d go with thin crust. We got the regular and it seemed a bit thick.
6.5 out of 10
… moreLevi Burns
I’ve been ordering here for years, and I’ll admit, my order is disgusting… double pineapple, double anchovie.
However, I bring this pizza home, throw a few slices in a 400° oven for 5-6 minutes, and it is easily the best neopolitan pizza within 1000 miles. And I’d have to compare slice for slice to even say its not the leader.
I feel bad for the staff that has to make my order, but my goodness, with the extra toasting in my own oven, this is worth every inch of the drive to pick it up.
… moreBenjamin Gage
Well they were the only place open so figured we’d try them out. Pretty bad customer service when ordering through the phone. Asked for light cheese and got the response “you know well cheese melts right?” Yes obviously cheese melts.. “The Sauce does not have a good flavor, the dough neither and wasn’t enjoyable. Honestly your better off with frozen pizza.
… moreDane Essig
Oh my goodness, taste of yesteryear! Back in town and yummy, yummy stuff from back in the day! To top it off, our delivery guy, Aaron, was the absolute friendliest and respectful delivery person ever! Funny thing is he has a bit of history with my mom and brightened her day tremendously! Thanks Roma’s and extra special thanks to Aaron!
Oops, forgot the onions but who cares when a pizza is that yummy.
… morejohn kowalsky
The only place for deep dish pizza in the Coloma area. I only saw the take out counter but is possible for dining in, also nice menu selections. The sauce and cheese blended well.
And slices cut smaller is easier to hold.
… moreJessica Flores
The teens running this place when we went in impressed us. Very personable and professional tending to everyone’s requests 100%. Good food!
… moreElijah Luth
Multiple times I’ve ordered food for delivery and the sauce is forgotten. The first time I understand , no problem. The second time was a pickup order and they forgot the cheese bread, which they did deliver the cheese bread after we called to explain (1.5 miles away from the pizza shop). The third and fourth time the sauce was forgotten , yet again. The fourth time with the forgotten sauce, one of two pizzas were air temperature cold. Upon receiving the pizza at delivery, the fourth time the sauce was forgotten, the guy says “usually they put the sauce inside the box” when I know for a fact they wrap the sauce in aluminum foil. For a $15 tip, you’d think they’d drive a mile to the shop and back to bring you your sauce. That’s the last melon.
… moreJohn Page
Always a good pie here. Sauce is phenomenal and always fast turnaround to pick up order. I can’t wait to go up there when dine in reopens.
… moreTracey Horner
I am very disappointed in the flavor of this pizza. I paid almost $30. By the time you include the $5 they charged me for delivery plus the tip it was $30.
The pizza wasn’t nothing like I would have expected, it looks good online and it looked great when it was delivered but there was no flavor, it was a one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had. The sauce is what ruined this pizza for us. It tastes like nothing I’ve ever had before on a pizza. I’m never going to order from here again. This was a waste of good money, we ended up throwing it out because none of us liked it. Sorry just being honest, this is our opinion but you can see many other people like the flavor of the food here. So try it if you want but I’ll never order from them again.
… more