RedWhiteAndBlue4evr1
Fantastic place. Everything made fresh as usual. The meatball appetizer is great any time. Pizza is NY style thin. Ive tried almost every house pizza and they’re all great. Ive been coming here since they opened, and Ive never had a bad experience.
… moreJenifer Calvert
Absolutely wonderful experience! I was greeted quickly and offered a table by Meghan, a delightful and efficient young lady. While taking my order, she offered honest advice about my selection and made excellent recommendations. My salad was PERFECT! The ingredients were fresh, the grilled chicken was tender and the house vinegarette was exactly right! Although the exterior of the brick building is humble and unassuming, the interior is inviting and lively decorated. I can’t wait to visit again! Thank you Meghan for a wonderful experience!
… moreDeb Brenner
This is my second review about this place, but it deserves a second one because we arrived to the restaurant tonight at 7:56 p.m. It closes at 8:00 and Meghan our super sweet efficient server said no problem, come sit down! And she put in our order for the most delicious supreme pizza which we ate up. And then she hand dipped yummy scoops of ice cream which we could have finished at the table, but it was so beautiful outside so we sat just outside and enjoyed the sunset. This place never disappoints, the service is top notch, the decor will bring you back in the best way, and it’s just a really good piece of America. So drive over and enjoy a good pizza and also try the amazing Caesar salad. But get there before it closes
… moreLibby Grizzle
We ate lunch here when we were camping at George H Floyd State Park. Our son told us about it. Great food and excellent, friendly waitress. My husband had a Calzone, and I had a veggie pizza. Very good. Love that it was part of an old cotton mill. We will definitely go back when visiting Summerville again.
… moreE B
We can’t decide which is best – the food or the service. Enjoyed a classic pepperoni pizza and garden salad. Wait staff was very attentive and fun to chat with. Thanks for a great lunch as we were “just passing through! Love to support local
… moreClint Sobie
We were passing through Summerville today on our way back to Alabama. Looked on Google for a place to eat, and The Crushed Tomato came up. We decided to give it a try. When we pulled up to the restaurant we thought what have we got ourselves into ? I will say don’t let the look of the outside of the restaurant detour you. The food was delicious. We ordered the meat lovers callzone, and the Chicken Alfredo . If you have never had pizza from a wood fired oven , it brings your food to another level. This place is a must have. Great friendly service, and great food. Not to mention a wonderful rustic look to the inside of the restaurant. Also if you are a lover of antique signage they have a great collection of antique signs hanging all over the restaurant. From what they told me it used to be a old cotton mill back in the day.
Highly recommend The Crushed Tomato.
… moreAnita Mitlyng
Fabulous pizza! First time here and I’m a big city foodie, was as good as anything I have ever had pizza wize. Great service from Makenzie and the decor is charming.
… moreScott Cortimilia
Delicious brick oven pizza.
I love brick oven pizza. Haven’t had one in years.
The service was fast and very informative on any questions we had.
We had a Margherita and a Hawaiian. I really couldn’t get enough!
Got a Rattlesnake pizza to go for my daughter she said a 4 out of a 5.
Was a little dark inside when we got there, then they turned up the lightning.
We are from out of town nearby. I had to ask how long they were there. Thirteen years. Wow! I’ve been missing out on some great pizza!
My grandson said he may just have his birthday dinner here.
Wouldn’t hurt my feelings at all.
Great brick oven pizza.
Keep up the good work because I’ll stop there every chance I get when I’m in Summerville, Ga.
… moreDannis Cole
We visited on Wed Nov 8th at about 5 pm. I didn’t go in, but the pizza was absolute heaven! We got an 18″ half and half [note that to get half and half at this size you must go to one of their stores]. Maggie got the Philly Cheesesteak and I got Rattlesnake [BBQ Chicken with Jalapenos but I got it without the peppers].
We also got ice cream and mine was Turtle Tracks. Maggie loved the Philly Cheesesteak pizza! I really loved my Rattlesnake Pizza! BBQ sauce was spicy and flavorful, and enough without overpowering the pizza. And, oh, what yummy pizza! The crust was crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. Perfectly cooked.
Our order was ready fairly quickly even though Maggie didn’t order online, so this was in-person. I sat in the van ’cause I was really tired. But, getting into the store wouldn’t have been a problem for my walker if I had gone in.
I got a couple pictures outside in the parking lot, and Maggie got all of the indoor pictures. Food pix, I took them at home because we got dinner to go.
The turtle tracks ice cream pleased me very much. Tasty and I do love any kind of ‘tracks’ in my ice cream. When I saw the pictures of inside I really want to go in next trip and see it for myself. Awesome piece of history, and they also have a brick oven. Which just makes their pizza taste even better!
I highly recommend this place. Parking is easy and there is a handicapped space right beside the building on the way to the parking lot. I really love the atmosphere and Maggie said the staff were helpful and friendly. Definitely want to go back!
The main picture from the parking lot shows the handicapped parking space between where we parked and the building. The parking lot itself is gravel but well-maintained. There is a sidewalk leading to the entrance.
I also took a picture of a post-like object because I was curious about it. It is a PIV and is for the sprinkler system. So when Summerville Cotton Mill was here, it needed to be present for that. It’s such an interesting building!
… moreJohn Dant
3rd time getting take-out. Good service. Had the bruschetta and meathead pizza. Consistently good food! Highly recommend
… more