Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 75 N Main St, Cortland, NY 13045
Phone: (607) 756-0900
Website: http://pudgiescortland.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pudgie’s Pizza Cortland
Fresh Custom Made Pizzas, Millions sold since 1963! Pudgie’s Pizza Menu Hours of Operations: Sunday -Thursday: 11am-9pm (Deliver till 9pm) Friday – Saturday: …
Pudgie’s Pizza Cortland – Facebook
. Follow. Details. . $$. . Closed now. . 75 N Main St, Cortland, NY, United States, 13045. Links. . pudgiescortland.com. Services. . Specialties. Dine-in …
Pudgies Pizza – Southern Tier’s King of Pizzas Since 1963
… pizza from Pudgie’s! Brings back many good memories and it’s still … A little greasy but it’s NY style pizza. Made that way on purpose. Food: 5/5 …
Reviews
Constance Masten
I ordered a stromboli tonight. It was all dough not much filling. I had one in December that was Great. I not sure if they have new people making food but it wasn’t good. I usually don’t complain but it was just bad.
… moreJeff Shepard
We entered the establishment and politely placed a to-go order. The pizza was exceptionally delicious. Upon our arrival, we realized it would have been advantageous to have placed an order in advance due to the bustling atmosphere. Numerous customers came and left during our visit. Despite the evident busyness of the establishment, we were pleasantly surprised that our wait time was not excessively long.
… moreTee B
Ordered a sheet pizza and wings special for Superbowl and it was great. Order was done just as asked, and hot and ready for pick up for time that needed. Employees were very friendly.
… moreLaw-Enforcement and community
I ORDERED A SHEET PIZZA EXTRA CHEESE THE PIZZA WAS DELICIOUS! THE THICK-PUFFY !FRESHLY MADE CRUST WAS PERFECT! LIKE FRESHLY MADE HOMEMADE BREAD FROM SCRATCH! FLAVORFUL CHEESE THE PROPER AMOUNT OF OLIVE OIL! THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF SAUCE!!!!! PERFECTLY CUT!!!!! NO! PROBLEMS! WITH! SELF! SERVE! NOR! ANY! PROBLEMS! WITH! SERVE-SAFE!!!!! BRAVO TEAM!!!!! PERFECT-10!
… moreBrianna Miller
The first time I went to Pudgies was in august of 2020. We ordered a pepperoni sheet pizza. It was very undercooked pizza. It was like eating raw dough.
The second time, was today. Ordered a medium pizza with sausage, onions and green peppers and 10 medium hot boneless wings and 10 traditional mild wings. There were barely any onions or peppers on the pizza. Also, the boneless wings were very dry and barely had any sauce on them. However, the traditional wings were good. We also paid extra for extra blue cheese x2 and and extra medium hot sauce on the side. We didn’t receive any extra sauces that cost .55$ extra each. I called and asked if they could deliver the condiments and they agreed. They didn’t send the condiments until 50 minutes later.
I will not be ordering from here, again,
… moreThe second time, was today. Ordered a medium pizza with sausage, onions and green peppers and 10 medium hot boneless wings and 10 traditional mild wings. There were barely any onions or peppers on the pizza. Also, the boneless wings were very dry and barely had any sauce on them. However, the traditional wings were good. We also paid extra for extra blue cheese x2 and and extra medium hot sauce on the side. We didn’t receive any extra sauces that cost .55$ extra each. I called and asked if they could deliver the condiments and they agreed. They didn’t send the condiments until 50 minutes later.
I will not be ordering from here, again,
Steve Dumond
Ordered a snack pack. Extra cheese, mild wings, charbroiled absolutely delicious and the girl that waited on me was very friendly. I’ll be back again.
… moreSteve
The party pack is a tried and true staple of a good pizza party. If you have to feed a lot of people, it’s a solid option as it includes everything all in one deal.
… moreKandy Contento
Every time I come here, I always get a shitty pizza. It’s either burnt or there’s not enough sauce on it. Dried up cardboard
… moreNicholas DeLessio
It’s fine. Not the worst pizza I ever ate by any means, but far from the best.
This must’ve been a much better option at one point. People who have lived in the area for a long time all seem to really like Pudgies, but I personally think there are many better options in the Cortland Homer area.
… moreThis must’ve been a much better option at one point. People who have lived in the area for a long time all seem to really like Pudgies, but I personally think there are many better options in the Cortland Homer area.
jon p
Literally have gotten Pudgie’s for thirty years grew up on it. Had the worst party pack ever. No cheese on 90% of the sheet pizza. Clearly they don’t care about quality anymore but will still charge over $50 for an inedible party pack. Pretty bad when I should have gone to little Caesar’s instead of Pudgie’s. They’ve been slipping for a while but this was unacceptable.
… more