Rachel Plank
Absolutely delicious. You can see and taste the passion that is put into this pizza. The owner is patient when it comes to orders over the phone and always seems to be in good spirits which reflects in the food he makes. Love is put into this food and in these days of almost every restaurant serving reheated frozen food Marcos pizza is a breath of fresh air!
… moreGarrett Dickerson
I have visited Buffalo Bill’s a few times and have never been disappointed with the food! The dough is made fresh every day & you can tell. Nothing is better than a freshly made Neopolitan-style pizza. Plus, The staff here have always been friendly and great to talk to.
Today I finally tried some of their Old Fashioned Soda Pop and fell in love!
I highly suggest checking out this Pizzeria!
… moreEddie Jacobs
Decided to try someplace new and was not disappointed! Pizza was amazing. Made with fresh dough, homemade sauce and a ton of cheese! The owner was very friendly and fun to talk too. Definitely worth the short drive from Greenfield and we will definitely revisit.
… moreRifleman8892
Some of the best Pizza I have ever tasted. Owner is one of the friendliest people you will ever meet. Traveled 2 and a half hours to try it. Will definitely do it again.
… moreBrandon Sheets
Some of the best pizza and service I have experienced. Will come back to visit. Owner was really friendly
… moreJonathan Brading
Best pizza in town by far!
Crispy, firm, cheesy, and downright delicious, the owner is very hospital and very respectful, he would come around and check up on all of us, not too much, not too little, his drinks were SPOT on, the cream soda was perfect.
The environment is very nice, good music, doesn’t smell weird, cool but not cold, and a nice opening so you can talk to him even if he’s working. Not the slightest hesitation to help a customer.
It’s a one man show, show some respect for the guy he’s a busy man. If he ain’t open he ain’t open, nobody’s perfect, and everyone’s gotta make a living.
… moreKasey Gosser
Probably the best pizza I have had in Knightstown. We had take out and he had it ready right on time and it was well worth the money.
… moreErica Gunn
Best pizza we’ve EVER had! The cheesebread is a MUST have to start off with. The house made root beer is fantastic. Extremely friendly service, too. We live 45 min away and stopped in after a basketball game—and will definitely be back. We ordered the Margherita Pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. BOTH pizzas are fabulous!!!! House made pizza sauce is a family recipe from Sicily and worth it!
Stop in, you will not regret it! I can’t get over how fantastic this brick oven pizza and root beer is!
… moreMarie Gail Stratford
Cozy little pizza joint with a fantastic selection of specialty craft sodas on tap. Service was friendly and prompt. When I mentioned it was my first visit and ordered a soda to go with my pizza, he offered one on the house for me to try. Delicious! I will definitely be going back soon.
… moreAndrew Cain
Marko is the man and he makes the best authentic Italian pizza in Indiana. The housemate root beer was the best I’ve ever had. He was nice, conversational, and informative! I will return frequently.
… more