Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–5 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 101 12th St, Fortuna, CA 95540
Phone: (707) 725-1123
Website: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Paul’s Live from New York Pizza | Pizza restaurant in CA
Come in and try the best pizza in CA!
Paul’s Live from New York – Fortuna CA – Facebook
Paul’s Live from New York – Fortuna, Fortuna. 307 likes · 4 talking about this · 29 were here. Pizza place.
Paul’s Live From New York Pizza – SinglePlatform
Paul’s Live From New York Pizza. Call Menu Info. 101 12th Street. Fortuna, US-CA 95540 … California Crust (12″) Cheese Pizza. $17.99. $2 more than your …
Reviews
Lucas Morris
The menu here is awesome, so much great food. While we are non stop to go orders we’re pouring out the door. You can tell that in Fortuna this is THE SPOT! We had pizza and the crust was crappy and yet not too chewy. Just a well done pie. Highly recommend!
… moreROBOACE
This place is FANTASTIC! A great spot for pizza and the slices are HUGE! I got a sausage and black olive slice. It was cooked perfectly, the thin crispy crust and the ingredients on top were perfect. The texture of the dough was great and definitely held up for the fold test. This is a great spot to stop and grab a meal. It is decorated nicely.
… morethat guy
Small menu. Its so close to a jersey boardwalk slice/pie the chicken parm was a bit on the small side byt very tasty
Tyeyran out of canolli so i didnt get to try it.. you should offer zeppolies/zeppelins as some call them . I wo7ld takw any of my of ew York or jersey people here to eat without a second thaught .. happy n5o find you! Yes new york pizza in the redwoods of ca ..so good
… moreTyeyran out of canolli so i didnt get to try it.. you should offer zeppolies/zeppelins as some call them . I wo7ld takw any of my of ew York or jersey people here to eat without a second thaught .. happy n5o find you! Yes new york pizza in the redwoods of ca ..so good
janine Lauritzen
Totally enjoyed Paul’s live. Second visit as good as the first. As you can tell nothing left from the Fried Ravioli and mozzarella sticks. The mussel’s marinara were amazing last time and Cindy loves the pizza. Amazing that we can just have a slice. Btw, best fries in town. Thanks for coming to Fortuna.
… moreMelinda Hogan
Fantastic service every time. Constantly great pizza, East Coast style pizza. Great prices. They have a lunch special too!
Whole pizza and pizza by the slice.
Lots of incredible Vegetarian options.
Great atmosphere. I can’t say enough good things about this place.
10/10
… moreWhole pizza and pizza by the slice.
Lots of incredible Vegetarian options.
Great atmosphere. I can’t say enough good things about this place.
10/10
Alan Miller
“Don’t Get Burned”
Consistent Pizza?
I think not! This is what we got for $60.00. As the last three times we ordered pizza from Paul’s it’s been burnt, as this time it is was EVEN worse. Whats even more bother some is we are 25 mins way, only to get home to find this monstrosity, Again…. What’s even more difficult to stomach is the taste of burnt pizza; something I found root beer cannot wash away! So, shame on me for going back! I will NEVER go back to Paul’s EVER again!!
FYI… my dog even turned it down, but the trash didn’t deny it!
… moreConsistent Pizza?
I think not! This is what we got for $60.00. As the last three times we ordered pizza from Paul’s it’s been burnt, as this time it is was EVEN worse. Whats even more bother some is we are 25 mins way, only to get home to find this monstrosity, Again…. What’s even more difficult to stomach is the taste of burnt pizza; something I found root beer cannot wash away! So, shame on me for going back! I will NEVER go back to Paul’s EVER again!!
FYI… my dog even turned it down, but the trash didn’t deny it!
Michael Anderson
Excellent food, excellent service. It echos a lot and there are several TVs on loud, if you’re sensitive to sound (I am). I will come back again. The prices are fair for the portions.
… moreIsaac Croteau
Pizza and service are good enough, but the prices are not worth it. 2 18 inch pizza’s (cheese and pepperoni) and a garlic knot was a little over $75. For that price I will go elsewhere.
… moreJohn Myers
If you love pizza and slice pies this place is the perfect atmosphere for you and your family the slices are huge and there’s about 30 different pizza toppings and selective pies to choose from if you are from the East Coast and you already had real N.Y pizza and Philly pizza then this has to be your first stop each employee there has a lot of experience and always treats you like your part of the family best pizza joint in Fortuna Hands down!
… moreAbigail Pinedo
Recommend! Had my son’s birthday dinner there. He just turned 4. They have great food and amazing customer service. They didn’t make us feel awkward about our kids running around. Kids weren’t going crazy but doing what most toddlers do (can’t keep still) it was a good experience! Thank you!
… more