Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5808 Big Tree Rd, Lakeville, NY 14480
Phone: (585) 346-2680
Website: https://www.pizzapauls.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza Paul’s: Home
A slice of tradition and innovation that has been a beloved part of the Lakeville and Geneseo, NY communities since 1993.
Pizza Paul’s | Lakeville NY – Facebook
$10 per large (16”) cheese pizza. Full menu available *offer valid until 3 pm for a limited time. Additional toppings $2 extra. Price does not include taxes …
Pizza Paul’s | Lakeville, NY 14480 – ILoveNY.com
A staple on Conesus Lake, Pizza Paul’s has online ordering, delivery and eat-in options for patrons. They specialize in calzones. They also carry completely …
Reviews
Penny Nowack
Called in for a pizza this afternoon the girl on the phone was amazingly friendly repeated my order back to me to make sure it was what I wanted. When I picked up the pizza she was very friendly and I felt like I was back in the 80’s when people cared about the customer service. When we got home and opened the box and saw the amount of toppings and the way they were put on the pie liked she cared. I have to say this was the best pizza we’ve had in a very long time.
… morePatrick Paulot
This has been a few orders coming because I really wanted to give this small business a chance. Tonight I got 2 chicken finger subs, a cold ham sub, pizza logs, and wings. All subs had disgusting wilty lettuce on them, the chicken fingers I don’t think had ever been crispy, I ordered pickles on the ham sub and there was only one pickle per side on the sub. The wings were not ever crispy either. I understand distance to my house and loosing some crisp but these were mush to start. The only redeeming part of this order was the pizza logs. I am sadly done with Pizza Pauls since their pizza has had varying levels of quality in the past and I have never had a crispy wing since I started ordering from them years ago. I hope it improves in the future.
… moreVicki Rawlins
This place is always great. We order pizza & wings several times per month. Wings are waaaaay better than most places–meatier, actually fried extra crispy as requested.
… moreI. Adam
GREASY is an UNDERSTATEMENT. We ordered a large grilled chicken wing pizza. Holy grease. The pictures are after we used 4 sheets of paper towel to get some of the surface grease off, it puddled on top of the pizza. We had to flip the lid under the box because the bottom of the box was so saturated it puddled on my counter. Disappointed, the first time we stopped in we loved it, huge affordable slices and it wasn’t greasy at all. One slice and we were done, stomach wasn’t happy with us. Not sure we’ll be returning.
… moreTracy
Apparently they do not take phone orders under any circumstances and the online order choices did not meet all of my family’s needs. When I finally completed my order, I noticed it was for pick up instead of delivery. I called again, this time to ask if they can switch my order to deliver. I was told no but they could cancel my order and I can start over. I cancelled and ordered elsewhere. I will never order from them again. It was not an experience I wish to revisit.
… moreAnthony Bovee
I just ordered 2 LARGE chicken parm subs. One was $12.96 and the other was $13.71 (extra cheese).
They were delicious. BUT, they were very small. I’m talking 9” small. My wife saw the measurements of these subs and realized she’s been lied to her whole life about how big 9 inches is!
Seriously though, these subs were obnoxiously small. I can’t believe they’ve got the Paul’s Ball’s to charge $13 for a 9 inch sub. Even Subway doesn’t rip us off that bad. They tasted great, but c’mon. Don’t screw us like this! Pick one, either go small or charge more, don’t do us like that or we’ll stop ordering all together. Be better Pizza Paul’s.
Update 7/28/23
We had received a gift card on 6/13/23 from my review. It was such a nice gesture and very much appreciated.
We placed an order on 7/28/23 for a medium veggie lover pizza, 4 basic balls and a large chicken parm. Everything tasted great as usual.
We didn’t receive any sauce for the balls though.
… moreThey were delicious. BUT, they were very small. I’m talking 9” small. My wife saw the measurements of these subs and realized she’s been lied to her whole life about how big 9 inches is!
Seriously though, these subs were obnoxiously small. I can’t believe they’ve got the Paul’s Ball’s to charge $13 for a 9 inch sub. Even Subway doesn’t rip us off that bad. They tasted great, but c’mon. Don’t screw us like this! Pick one, either go small or charge more, don’t do us like that or we’ll stop ordering all together. Be better Pizza Paul’s.
Update 7/28/23
We had received a gift card on 6/13/23 from my review. It was such a nice gesture and very much appreciated.
We placed an order on 7/28/23 for a medium veggie lover pizza, 4 basic balls and a large chicken parm. Everything tasted great as usual.
We didn’t receive any sauce for the balls though.
jason lucas
We just had the New Yorker pizza. It has ricotta, spinach and fresh tomato. This pizza is super gourmet. As a chef of 31 years, I will say that this pizza is excellent and well worth the money. The staff is very nice as well.
… moreAmber Granata
Each time I end up here it’s a happy accident and I get so excited when I realize where I am because the food is SO good. I get the cheese cake raspberry Pauls balls 10/10 highly recommended. The workers are so nice the vibe is clean and calm and overall haven’t found something that I didn’t like about this place! Can not wait to come back!
… moreKarl Kramer
Got 2slices tonight and pauls balls…the balls were good but the slices were old and completely burned…worst slice ever…when we asked for refund the guy said it was our fault it was burned because we asked to re-heat…most likely will NOT be returning and DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS PIZZA PLACE!!! STEER CLEAR!
… moreR Worner
Always greeted warmly. Food is always ready and great!! Restaurant is clean and tidy.
… more