Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Understated restaurant serving an array of pies with creative toppings plus beer, wine & cocktails.
Hours
| Friday | 5–9 PM |
| Saturday | 5–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 20 N Pennsylvania Ave, Bethany Beach, DE 19930
Phone: (302) 539-2600
Website: https://www.bethanypie.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bethany Pie Menu – Bethany Pie Pizza, Bethany Beach, DE
ORDER ONLINE. Bethany’s Premier Pizza Place! Call 302-539-2600 20 N Pennsylvania ave. Bethany Beach, DE 19930. Explore our Carry Out Menu. Join …
Pie | Bethany Beach DE – Facebook
Pie, Bethany Beach. 3771 likes · 1562 were here. Gourmet grilled pizzas, fresh salads, amazing dessert pies! Full Bar, local craft beers, wine!
Pie (@bethanybeachpie) · Bethany Beach, DE – Instagram
1.5K+ followers · 406 posts · Grilled pizza, amazing wines and local craft beers! Bethany Beach De.
Reviews
Alicia Blair
If you love pizza then you MUST stop here. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the pizza was out of this world, and the staff was incredible. They were so accommodating to us. I haven’t had service this good in a long time. It was much appreciated. The pizza was made from fresh ingredients and the topping combinations were so good. 10 out of 10. The next time I come to Bethany I am definitely coming back.
… moreJJ R.
Amazing staff and great service. Full bar with lots of speciality drinks. Homemade infused vodka and tequila. We tried 2 pizzas and the first one was not so good but the second one came out amazing….the only difference was we added sausage. Tough to rate. The house salad was done well and very good.
… moreShaina Wallace
Pizza was great! Pie was okay. Too cold and a little soggy. Wait staff amazing & on top of things.
… moreAlison M
Very impressed with this yummy location.
Hubs is a pizza fanatic and loves to try it everywhere we go so, this was our spot after looking at pics and reviews.
I love their flatbread-looking pizzas with thin crust. These are more like a rectangle than a traditional circle shape. We each had a salad which was fresh and delicious and a large portion and split a pizza with cheese and sausage. The salads were really good and a super fair price for the size!
Pizza was SO good. Fresh-made to order, hot and perfectly cooked. Crust was just crunchy enough and not overdone and no part of the dough was uncooked. Excellent. They know how to make a good pizza.
We didn’t get any pie for dessert but they had several flavors and all looked wonderful.
Service was great and it’s a charming building from both inside and outside. Clean restroom and very clean tables. Plenty of nearby parking.
… moreHubs is a pizza fanatic and loves to try it everywhere we go so, this was our spot after looking at pics and reviews.
I love their flatbread-looking pizzas with thin crust. These are more like a rectangle than a traditional circle shape. We each had a salad which was fresh and delicious and a large portion and split a pizza with cheese and sausage. The salads were really good and a super fair price for the size!
Pizza was SO good. Fresh-made to order, hot and perfectly cooked. Crust was just crunchy enough and not overdone and no part of the dough was uncooked. Excellent. They know how to make a good pizza.
We didn’t get any pie for dessert but they had several flavors and all looked wonderful.
Service was great and it’s a charming building from both inside and outside. Clean restroom and very clean tables. Plenty of nearby parking.
K C
We ordered margherita, and goat cheese, and artichoke pizza. I would say the goat cheese was slightly better. The ricotta and chocolate pie was really good!
… moreThomas Whitehaus
Artisanal flat bread style pizzas. Nice choice of pizza styles or build your own. Good draft beer list and nice selection of cocktails. Also a good selection of delicious pies for dessert. Very friendly and attentive staff.
… moreDaniel Beirne
The pizza is actually flat breads. Crispy crust is good with a little bit of chew. They have some creative choices. The black and blue short rib is pretty tasty. The salads are generous.
… moreMy Review Matters
Not worth it over priced for food being warmed up in the microwave picture is a part of the meatball over cooked in the microwave next time heat it up on the stove not a damn microwave come on people learn to cook
… morePhil Jackson
Best Gluten Free pizza crust! Couldn’t tell the difference. Decent beer selection, great service.
… moreKelli Kaskel
Loved the staff! We had feta dip appetizer, Cobb salad and meatball sub…All super fresh and delicious food! Would highly recommend!
Update 6/15/25- food is amazing BUT the drink menu has Premium liquors listed, but we watched the bartender make both our drinks with rail Alcohol. So you not paying for what you ordered. Very disappointing.
… moreUpdate 6/15/25- food is amazing BUT the drink menu has Premium liquors listed, but we watched the bartender make both our drinks with rail Alcohol. So you not paying for what you ordered. Very disappointing.