Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6367 Lakeshore Rd S, Canastota, NY 13032
Phone: (315) 762-5516
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gary’s Restaurant | Canastota NY – Facebook
It’s fun in the summer and it’s fun in the winter! Right on the shores of Oneida Lake, Gary’s Restaurant has been around for 92 years!
Garys Restaurant: A Hidden Gem for Culinary Delights in Canastota …
Located at 6367 Lakeshore Rd S, Gary’s is renowned for its comfort food, warm service, and picturesque waterfront views, making it ideal for a romantic …
Gary’s Restaurant – Oneida, NY – MenuGuide
Gary’s Restaurant in Oneida, NY — Steak , Scallops , Haddock , Pasta , Wings , Chicken Parm , Salad bar , Fish — menu photos — call 315-762-5516.
Reviews
debbi brodfuehrer
First time here. Place was great, nice and homey. Food was fantastic! Husband had steak, cooked perfectly, I had scallops parmesan with angel hair pasta. Had the hodgepodge which had a wide variety of finger foods (looked like homemade breading) fantastic! Wonderful salads with lots of extras in them. Would suggest this to everyone!
… moremartin mierek
God awful food. Surprised they manage to stay in business. We were taken care of sweetly however. But if you can’t go for the food, sadly that doesn’t matter. No one in our party of 5 liked literally anything. I was embarrassed to have brought some out of state company to this place. Further I think their sides come out of a generic plastic tub where it rots/ molds…
… moreCorinne Dries
5 star view, 0 star service. I got to watch a a party of 12 receive incredible service though,saw them order, eat and then even receive cake plates for a birthday for desert. All while never receiving my appetizer. Wild experience.
… moreLonnie Etter
Linda took great care of us! Great food. Wonderful atmosphere with a view of the lake.. Fish sandwich was huge. Sweet potato fries were delicious. Fantastic hot covered meatball sandwich. We’ll be back.
… moreAmelia Treharne
Absolutely horrible experience all the way around. 3 of 4 meals were awful. Strip steak was grizzly and boiled tasting and over cooked. Sirloin steak was undercooked. Scallops were smaller than a dime. Hair in the food. Took over an hour for the meal to arrive. Such a let down. Bathroom soap dispenser covered in mold and overall building is badly run down, waitress was rude. Shall I go on. Health department should shut this place down!!!
… moreRenée A Sutton
Our group of four popped in for some beers and bar food on the way back to our campsites at Verona Beach State Park. The service was fast and friendly, beers were cold, and our snacks were hot and tasty. We sat at the bar, and the other patrons were friendly. We will definitely return the next time we are in the area.
… moreLexie Pietruniak
Gary’s is a perfect spot for anyone looking to enjoy the view of the lake. The Buffalo wings were amazing and Linda was very informative about the area as my family and I are from out of state.
The atmosphere is very homey and I would highly reccomend this place to anyone.
… moreThe atmosphere is very homey and I would highly reccomend this place to anyone.
Dawn Case
Fast, Friendly Service. Very attentive. Hot Dinner Rolls to start w Side Salad. I got the Shrimp & Summer Vegetable w Angel Hair pasta and it was Beautiful & Delicious!
… moreSuzanne Karow
When scallops turn black and taste fishy they are beyond their freshness. My French Onion soup wasn’t very good. Surprised my husband went to finish mine and said it didn’t taste right but his was ok – food should taste the same for each guest. I wasn’t expecting skin on my haddock so that just put the disappointment over the top. Service was excellent and very friendly – that was this place’s only saving grace.
… moreThats My “Woke Wrecker” Business
When tempted to eat at Sylvan Beach, skip the mainstay restaurants that charge a fortune for mediocre food, and stop-in at Gary’s Restaurant. We did. And we were very pleased with the view, the menu, the food, and the service. Well worth going back to. Very clean. Dining room is quiet compared to most restaurants at Sylvan Beach, that charge a fortune for a noisy atmosphere. Enjoy the sunset view, while dining or having a cold one. The ice cream, afterwards hit-the-spot. Gary’s is close to Verona Beach State Park. Walking distance. And that’s just what we did. It’s a hidden gem, on the shoreline of Oneida Lake.
… more