Donavan Gill
The Gill Tavern (no relation…haha), is a hidden gem of western Massachusetts! Great quality food and prepared to perfection!! Staff was super friendly and helpful!! Highly recommend !!
… moreMatthew Sullivan
Went here for the first time last night, It was one of the best restaurant experiences we have had! food, service, atmosphere everything was amazing watching the chefs cook was wicked cool you could see the passion we will become regulars for sure
… moreJarrod Woley
Food was great. Service was so nice. Place is beautiful. I’ll definitely be back!
They could have a few more options for appetizers.
… moreAdam Wuoti
This is a local hidden gem that everyone should know about. There is enough parking off the road for the amount of space they have. The staff here were very friendly and professional. I enjoyed seeing the cooks call out for “Service” when a dish was prepared. The food was delicious but I wish my meal had more fish on it for the price point. I always enjoy the interior design when I come here. I am looking forward to going back again soon!
… moreWeston Asselin
Very mediocre experience. After being served dinner waitress never checked on us once until we were done eating. For such a small restaurant, to be walked by over and over and over again with an empty drink glass is weird. Food was alright. Sorta bland for the price. Would definitely never go back
… moreChristine Goepp
I’ve eaten at the Gill Tavern three times and each has been a successively worse experience. The last time will be the last. We waited an hour and fifteen minutes (from ordering) for the food. During that time the waiter did not check in with us or let us know what was going on. When we finally flagged him down, he said they were plating–but it was another fifteen minutes. The food was just awful, like couldn’t eat it awful, and we were hungry! What was really astonishing is there was something significantly wrong with every dish–the steak was charred, potatoes were simply missing (but just from one of three identical dishes!), fish was oily, full of bones, cole slaw was inedible, chicken was dry and chewy–the list goes on. Everything was either over- or under-seasoned. We are honestly not hard to please people and were looking forward to a nice night out with friends. On the plus side, we got to speculate for ages on the drive home about what might have happened. Chef got COVID and a couple enterprising raccoons offered to step in? We may never know. No hard feelings–they comped our meal and we had a nice, if hungry, conversation while we were waiting. But we won’t be back, sadly, because I grew up in Gill and I want to support local businesses if possible.
… moreJoe Heslin
I’m not a bot and I know 5 stars is a little sus, but hear me out. Walker (and his team) have created a place out of a space. An old store with the requisite creaking floors that honors its own humble beginnings. I wouldn’t say that the food has flair, it has honesty. I come here because I like the feel and I like the food, but I return here over and over because it is a total experience. I smell the kitchen and the history and the mixture of all of it before I taste anything. Sometimes the sound and smells and cheer become the perfect sauce to highlight the flavors.
… moreJesse Gouvin
What a great place!! Food was outstanding and Service was just as good. Chef did a great job with seasonal menu and Farm to Table concept. Highly recommend!!!
… moreLisa Neefe
I am OBSESSED with this place. Never have I ever seen a place so adorable. The epitome of small-town quaint, this is the place you take your NYC friends who came in for the weekend to see the foliage or pick strawberries. Solid beer and wine offerings and a menu that is inspiring without being stuffy. The catfish tacos were perfectly portioned and deliciously executed. My partner’s Greek salad with fish made me crane my neck to get a glimpse. She said it was excellent but selfishly did not offer me a bite. The chocolate pot-de-creme was grainy, however. The cream must not have been hot enough, so the texture was off. Disappointing, but not a spoiler. I will be back often!
… moreLachlan Thompson
Hidden gem. Had an amazing meal here with family — accommodating with dietary restrictions (gluten free, vegetarian) in spite of several items on the menu being out of stock. Our server was very attentive and made sure my party was well informed while making our selections.
… more