Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Valley Stream, NY, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Valley Stream pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Valley Stream or stop by 583 West Merrick Road for carryout to order the best pizza in Valley Stream, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 583 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580
Phone: (516) 823-7272
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Johns West Merrick Road | Papa Johns Valley Stream, NY
Call us for pizza delivery in Valley Stream or stop by 583 West Merrick Road for carryout to order the best pizza in Valley Stream, along with breadsticks, …
papa johns stores in valley stream, ny
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Valley Stream, New York to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa Johns Pizza, 583 W Merrick Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11580, US
Get more information for Papa Johns Pizza in Valley Stream, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Last Updates
Reviews
Ghostk
I ordered two pizzas for dinner for myself, my wife, and my children from Papa John’s in this location. While my wife eating her slice, she found a one inch piece of hard broken plastic baked into the pizza dough.
For the safety of your Kids don’t buy from this Store.
… moreFor the safety of your Kids don’t buy from this Store.
Juandy Castro
Do not order or eat here. Ordered 2 pizzas and one of them had a piece of GLASS in it and had someone almost CHOKE ON THE GLASS. called and all they said was they would be another pizza over after they said they had no idea where the glass came from said no to it. Then they said the manager would call me the next day and it’s been a week and no call. So be aware of what your about to eat because they definitely don’t care
… moreFlorence Ede
They stole my order. I ordered buy one get one free and only one was delivered. I called and the manager was very very rude and disrespectful.
I regret that I’ve always bought pizza here for over two years now and only to have this horrible experience.
He lied that it’s only for large orders when I proved to him that it was wrong that size 12 shows. Same buy one get one free… he put the phone off on me. When I called back he became very rude asking me to call uber that it’s not their store problem.
Just imagine that… ?
… moreI regret that I’ve always bought pizza here for over two years now and only to have this horrible experience.
He lied that it’s only for large orders when I proved to him that it was wrong that size 12 shows. Same buy one get one free… he put the phone off on me. When I called back he became very rude asking me to call uber that it’s not their store problem.
Just imagine that… ?
Mark Lord
They delivered someone else’s order to my house. When I reached out and requested a refund all the guy would say is my friend, next time I give you free brownie. I said no, I want a refund and he kept saying he’d give a free brownie, like he couldn’t understand English. For $20, I’ll cut my loss before arguing with an idiot, but will NEVER be a customer again!!
… moreSean Zapart
be warned they will take your money then cancel your order and if you try to contact customer support you cant with out a number thats on the sticker with the delivery…. haha which you obviously never received. What a joke
… moreLisa touissant
They mess up your delivery order on purpose so you don’t have to call them again to deliver. Look at the wings, they drained it in BBQ sauce on purpose. They don’t normally put excessive amount of sauce on it. That was too much and uncalled for.
… morePearley Lakhan
THE EMPLOYEES CONTAMINATE THE FOOD AND EAT PIECES OF THE FOOD AND LEAVE EATEN SAUCES IN THE PIZZA BOX FOR PICKUP!!!!
I came to pickup my order after mistakenly choosing pickup instead of delivery. I came home to find my order of 8pc buffalo wings sticker on the box, but there were only 6pc. I opened the pizza box & I see the blue cheese ordered with the wings is open and dripping. Clearly the employees are eating out of the food, contaminating the food and leaving dipping sauces open and dripping for customers to pickup. The manager, Hermanprhhe, stated it was impossible… multiple times… and then that there is nothing they can do…. THAT IS NASTY. I ORDERED FOOD AND IT WAS HALF EATEN BY THE EMPLOYEES AND STILL GIVEN TO ME. I asked for the supervisor and, at first, manager Hermanprhhe tried to withhold the name and contact information on how to refund a contaminated order I received. I finally received supervisor’s name, Mangor Singh, and arrival time for Monday after asking Hermanprhhe what he thinks it would feel like ordering food to come home and find it half eaten and everything contaminated….EWWW…
The supervisor is not due back until Monday, a day and a half later from Saturday night’s issue. Hermanprhhe states supervisor is in from 11am-6pm, but may only be there for 2 hours on Monday. Since there is confusion on the hours of operation for the supervisor, I asked manager Hermanprhhe to have the supervisor reach out to me once they’re in. I also confirmed, from Hermanprhhe, that there are cameras in the shop and that it goes back 6 months, they do not record over days.
I confirmed this would not be the first of the conversation Mangor Singh, the supervisor, would be hearing of this issue. I confirmed Hermanprhhe was aware of the complaint when he repeated back to me in his words, that the complaint consisted of 8pc wings being 6pc with the 8pc sticker confirming 8pc. He also confirmed an open, dripping blue cheese that was ordered was found in the pizza box itself.
I thought this was a clean, safe place to order from, but never again will I order from this location. The food and decisions of it being served is not safe with the people currently employed there unfortunately.
… moreI came to pickup my order after mistakenly choosing pickup instead of delivery. I came home to find my order of 8pc buffalo wings sticker on the box, but there were only 6pc. I opened the pizza box & I see the blue cheese ordered with the wings is open and dripping. Clearly the employees are eating out of the food, contaminating the food and leaving dipping sauces open and dripping for customers to pickup. The manager, Hermanprhhe, stated it was impossible… multiple times… and then that there is nothing they can do…. THAT IS NASTY. I ORDERED FOOD AND IT WAS HALF EATEN BY THE EMPLOYEES AND STILL GIVEN TO ME. I asked for the supervisor and, at first, manager Hermanprhhe tried to withhold the name and contact information on how to refund a contaminated order I received. I finally received supervisor’s name, Mangor Singh, and arrival time for Monday after asking Hermanprhhe what he thinks it would feel like ordering food to come home and find it half eaten and everything contaminated….EWWW…
The supervisor is not due back until Monday, a day and a half later from Saturday night’s issue. Hermanprhhe states supervisor is in from 11am-6pm, but may only be there for 2 hours on Monday. Since there is confusion on the hours of operation for the supervisor, I asked manager Hermanprhhe to have the supervisor reach out to me once they’re in. I also confirmed, from Hermanprhhe, that there are cameras in the shop and that it goes back 6 months, they do not record over days.
I confirmed this would not be the first of the conversation Mangor Singh, the supervisor, would be hearing of this issue. I confirmed Hermanprhhe was aware of the complaint when he repeated back to me in his words, that the complaint consisted of 8pc wings being 6pc with the 8pc sticker confirming 8pc. He also confirmed an open, dripping blue cheese that was ordered was found in the pizza box itself.
I thought this was a clean, safe place to order from, but never again will I order from this location. The food and decisions of it being served is not safe with the people currently employed there unfortunately.
Rajan Sangroha
HarNaam Singh is very good person service is very good papa John is always good and good food good stuff and everything good
… moreJocelyn Murillo
So call manager was being rude and unprofessional. The manager called me back about my order I explained to him it was a miscommunication he ends up telling me Oo your harassing us your harassing the lady in the front only because they gave my order to a Spanish guy and not me a female customer telling me Oo why didn’t you let us know who was there when I didn’t know who is working down stairs. I was rudely spoken to and it’s ok I told him I was not going back and forth and told me he would call the cops on me just because of a miscommunication there was with someone downstairs taking my order without me knowing. Threatening to call the cops on me over an order that was a miscommunication and I had to handle it on my own !! I’m in shock a manager or supervisor will speak to a costumer this way.
… moreDot
Ordered a pizza with 2 topping and they barely put anything on the pizza. There was a whole slice with no topping and other slices with a single pepperoni. I’ll probably go again though
… more