Diane Soria
My daughter picked Angelo’s for her Birthday ! She had heard wonderful things and we always try to look for new places. First being welcomed and shown to our table by the owner was personal ( love that touch )! Well this Cozy Authentic Italian spot did NOT DISAPPOINT!! We were a party of five. Drinks were yummy ! Try the strawberry basil martini or the cucumber mojito!!! Ok now Apps- the Lollipop lamb chops were tender, seasoned to perfection melt in your mouth , the spicy oysters OMG , tuna tartare flavorful with a little kick and the sweet chili calamari tender! We skipped salads- Entrees- I had the Short Ribs over risotto ( I asked for peas to be added which was not a problem) first the absolute MOST TENDER short rib I’ve ever had ! ! Flavor on point! Two of the kids ordered the Lemon Linguine Alfredo- Bright and Fresh – yum! My daughter ordered the Penne Ala Spinaci – delightful and bright came with chicken ( shrimp would be amazing also) and my husband I believe ordered the Sea scallops which were tender and amazing! If you haven’t stopped in you MUST! Finding a gem like this doesn’t happen frequently! Angelo’s was wonderful ! ! ! FIVE STARS !
… moreM jg
I went to Angelo’s for a quick small lunch. I had the Calamari, garlic bread, (which was amazing) and finished with the crème brûlée cheesecake—It was to die for!
The staff was very kind and the place is cozy and small. Can’t wait to go back for dinner.
… moreMike OB
Nice spot in Huntington Village. Pretty diverse menu and nice selection of daily specials. The Lamb Chop lollipops were cooked a little too well done, but the sauce flavor made up for it. The Tai Chili calamari was super fresh, and delicious.
Highly recommend the Lobster & Shrimp over fusilli pasta dish. For dessert the Napoleon was fluffy and delicious as well.
… moreCi Elo
This place is a gem. You won’t find a warmer welcome or better service anywhere. It’s a marvel to watch Angelo’s attentive staff work as a team, always ready if needed, but never intrusive. We come to Angelo’s for dinner for our important family events, or any occasion because we love it, and have never been disappointed with any of the dishes we’ve tried, whether seafood, pasta, chicken, or veal. Even the vegetables on the side that you would normally ignore at other restaurants are something special–the chef has a gift even with those, perfectly seasoned and cooked. We enjoy every last bite. The cocktails are fantastic also. It’s always a great night out and a memorable experience.
For lunch, the burger is exceptional. Nothing else comes close. The price is reasonable too.
… moreVictor Kazanjian
In an area where Italian restaurants are seemingly on every corner, this place stands out. Everyone in our group kept talking about the food all night. Calamari, veal chop, short ribs over gnocchi, and tiramisu were just a few of the outstanding dishes. Plus, the wait staff was amazingly polite, and always available to fill a glass or answer any question. Great drinks from the bar as well. Highly recommend.
… moreJj Prete
One of the best Italian restaurants around. It’s a small place thats much more intimate than most, which means the service is great, they are always friendly and nice. The food is simply amazing, they have such a great normal menu, and always have so many specials that are so fresh and delicious. Every time we bring someone here they say how good it is and want to come back. There is plenty of parking on the street because it’s a quiet block of Huntington which is nice too. I can’t say enough good things about Angelo’s and highly recommend it.
… moreJason Nabel
Went for my sisters birthday. Great meal from start to finish. Vibe was small and old school. The type of place you might pass by Michaelcomkng out of the bathroom on his way to deal with sallozzo and McClusky.
Apps from spicy oysters rock , Thai calamari, grilled artichokes and tuna tartare were all excellent. I had a stuffed fish topped with scallops and shrimp which was delicious but the star was the veal chop. Massive, tender in a Marsala type sauce with mozz. Service was also great. Can wait to go back!!!!!
… moreBud Clark
This small,cozy, classy, fine dining OG Italian spot is a find! No joke. Perfect from top to bottom. Everyone there is a total pro who knows how to deliver a high end dining experience. Pristine white table cloths , real Italian waiters (my son ordered the entire tables meal in Italian, so cool!) As far as the food… Wow! You can taste the freshness of the ingredients as u get the intense flavor bomb experience with every bite. Pasta and desserts made in house. Reasonably priced wine list. Total North Shore Huntington gem!
… moreLiz Sullivan
I can’t say enough about this amazing restaurant . The food was INCREDIBLE as well as the service. We had Franny serving us and she felt like family. I was there with my family of four and she made sure they were comfortable and well taken care of. She got us everything and was so polite and professional . She went above and beyond to take care of us . The bussers were also super friendly and fast. We ordered what felt like everything in the menu because every dish sounded delicious . Thanks Franny and the staff at Angelos for one of the best meals my family has ever had.
… moreJordan Medina
Angelo’s is THE BEST Italian restaurant on Long Island! As much as I want to keep this place a hidden gem, I have to give credit where credit is due. When you first walk in, you are greeted by their friendly waitstaff and Angelo. The inside is intimate and cozy. If you are looking for a date night spot, this is it! As much as we loved their main menu, the star of the show was their specials. For appetizers, we ordered the lollipop lamb chops and the stuffed rigatoni in a vodka sauce. The lamb chops were SUPER flavorful and tender and came with 4 pieces, which was perfect for sharing. The pasta was made fresh and was perfectly al dente and the sauce had layered flavors. For our entrees, I got the veal chop. It was stuffed with broccoli rabe and mozzarella and it was pounded thin, coated in breadcrumbs and fried and topped off with a brown sauce with mushrooms. It was served over a bed of mashed potatoes. Simply delicious and ginormous! I was able to have leftovers for lunch. My fiancé got the stuffed pork chop, which came with mashed potatoes and vegetables. His empty plate spoke for itself! For dessert, we were surprised with a dessert board (thank you Chris!). It came with tiramisu, flan, napoleon, a chocolate cake and strawberries in a white sauce that was made fresh and poured table side. I’m drooling just thinking about it! Shoutout to Oscar and his kitchen staff for making such a delicious meal and Angelo and the waitstaff for being so attentive and accommodating. Overall, it was an amazing experience and I can’t wait to come back! Thank you Chris for the awesome recommendation!
… more