Brandon Pickett
Nice little pizza spot. The atmosphere is very laid back. The staff were friendly and welcomed me right when I came in.
They had pepperoni, sausage, and cheese by the slice. $3.50 each which is pretty good!
I got one pepperoni and one sausage.
I really enjoyed the crust. The sauce was not too sweet and I got a couple small chunks of tomato. That was a pleasant surprise.
The pepperoni was overall really good, but my favorite of the two was the sausage. Nice big pieces that tasted like sausage and were seasoned fantastically.
For the price and overall flavor, if you’re in the area, definitely stop in!
3*** = Good but no separation from similar restaurants
4**** = Set themselves a part with great food and I want to go back.
5*****= You have to go out of your way and make a special trip to try the deliciousness that is there!
… moreJames Apicella
Stopped by to grab take out and just ate half a pie from my drive from Scottsdale back up to Surprise. Pizza was made fresh and definitely reminded me of a New York slice. I’ll definitely come back every time I’m in Scottsdale
… moreSteve Dworman
Pizza has little to no cheese, and you can see light through the dough. The salad is basically an individual size at best. Maybe they had an off night but for what we paid it’s doubtful we’ll be back.
Guys at the store are nice.
… moreNight Shift
Being a New Yorker when I saw this on Google maps, I definitely wanted to try it. Went in towards the end of the night on Friday night. Love the atmosphere one of the owners was working was very friendly and helpful. Didn’t have the typical New York attitude. Then I found out his business partner is the New Yorker. Lol.
I ordered two slices the pizza was good. Next time I’m going to order a fresh pie. I’m sure the slices in the case were sitting for a few hours I would like to taste a nice fresh pie. That’s what I will do on my next visit.
I added some ricotta cheese to the sausage and pepperoni and it really hit the spot. I took my time nice and slow since the atmosphere was so nice in that place.
… moreNtasha D
Quaint pizzeria with tasty pizza! They sell jumbo slices of pizza for $5. The pizza crust is light, fluffy, and flaky with stretchy cheese, & the toppings are delicious.
… moreLorenzo Bean (Beans on the scene!)
Stopped by for lunch yesterday and I am glad I did!! If you want a solid New York slice then this is the place to be!! I got the holy trinity of slices, cheese slice, pepperoni slice, and a sausage slice! They all were amazing with the sausage slice being my favorite! And for $3.50 per slice. You can’t beat it especially in this area! Check out my full review on YouTube @ Lorenzo Bean ( beans on the scene)
Stop by this spot for you pizza cravings, you will not be disappointed!!!
… moreJacqueline Montgomery
Johnny T’s Brooklyn Pizzeria is a great place to go when you’re craving true New York–style pizza. The crust has the perfect balance of crisp and chew, and the sauce and cheese are well proportioned without overwhelming the slice. Everything tastes fresh and made with care, whether you’re ordering a single slice or a whole pie. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, and service is quick and friendly. It’s a dependable local pizzeria that consistently delivers satisfying, classic pizza.
… morePaul Cullen
If you like NY Style pizza this is a hidden gem. I have eaten pizza in NY and this place is better. Everything is fresh. The food is high quality and the customer service was very good.
It is a family run business and Javier was so helpful. Just a great place. Can’t say enough. We will go here for pizza now.
… moreJackie Hernandez
The food is AMAZING.!! Pizza is deliciously, thin and crunchy made to perfection. The salad was very fresh and the wings were so good and saucy! Definitely a must try! The customer service by far exceeded my expectations. The two gentlemen that attended us were very knowledgeable, kind and professional. This is my favorite pizzeria!!!
… moreVanessa Vidal
Johnny T’s Brooklyn Pizzeria is exactly what you want when you’re craving a real New York–style pizza slice. The crust is thin with just the right chew, the sauce is flavorful without overpowering the cheese, and the slices are generously sized. Everything tastes fresh and made with care, whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or taking a pie to go. Service is fast and friendly, and the laid-back atmosphere makes it an easy place to stop in. It’s a solid local spot for dependable pizza that hits the mark every time.
… more