Casual pizzeria offering pies, sub sandwiches & other comfort eats, plus domestic & craft beers.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Al’s Pizza and Subs – OrderCounter
Your cart is empty. Close. Account. © 2026 – OrderCounter. Al’s Pizza and Subs. 40 Noble Blvd. Carlisle, PA 17013. Terms of Service and privacy policy.
Al’s Pizza – Carlisle PA – Facebook
Al’s Pizza – Carlisle, Carlisle. 1765 likes · 1 talking about this · 703 were here. Pizza shop/ Italian restaurant.
Als Pizza Subs Carlisle: Savor the Best Subs and Pizza in Carlisle, PA
Al’s Pizza & Subs Carlisle, located at 40 Noble Blvd in Carlisle, PA, is a cherished local eatery renowned for its fresh and flavorful offerings.
Reviews
Don Family
Great group of guys making great pizza. I was surprised that I could still get slices at 9 o’clock at night, which was a real blessing to me. The slices are very large and very reasonably priced. Make sure you ask them to get them nice and crispy. I sat in the booth and enjoyed watching the football game. Pizza maker was a huge football fan so it was fun to talk to you about it.
… moreSophia Campfield
Best sub bread ever. The Italian sub was amazing. Stuffed with delicious meat, very fresh veggies, and made perfectly to order. Staff is extremely friendly and nice. A few months ago we got the cheese steak boli which wasn’t my favorite, but might be other’s taste.
… moreHunter LaCross
Al’s Pizza in Carlisle is an absolute gem! From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was warm, welcoming, and full of life. The staff went above and beyond with their service friendly, attentive, and quick without ever feeling rushed.
The food was outstanding! Everything was fresh, flavorful, and made with care. You can tell they put real pride into what comes out of the kitchen.
What made the experience even better was talking with the owner. He was genuinely incredible to chat with personable, down-to-earth, and clearly passionate about both the food and the people who come in. It’s rare to find that kind of energy and connection these days, and it truly set Al’s Pizza apart.
If you’re in Carlisle and want amazing food paired with top-notch service and a great atmosphere, Al’s Pizza is the place to go. Highly recommend!
… moreThe food was outstanding! Everything was fresh, flavorful, and made with care. You can tell they put real pride into what comes out of the kitchen.
What made the experience even better was talking with the owner. He was genuinely incredible to chat with personable, down-to-earth, and clearly passionate about both the food and the people who come in. It’s rare to find that kind of energy and connection these days, and it truly set Al’s Pizza apart.
If you’re in Carlisle and want amazing food paired with top-notch service and a great atmosphere, Al’s Pizza is the place to go. Highly recommend!
Dedric Hayes
Best chicken cheesesteak in the area hands down! Can’t go wrong with choosing Al’s. A lot of other great foods as well! Love the fresh home made bread and fries! #flyeaglesfly #gobirds
… moreDiamond Jones
I came to this place based off the Google reviews.
Im sad to say the food was nasty. I spend almost $30 on two hot subs & a drink. The Philly meat didn’t taste like anything. No seasoning nothing. Only thing i could taste was the banana peppers. Maybe it was the time I ordered or what but food quality should be consistent until closing time. Welp another night & no dinner for this trucker due to nasty food. Do better please !
… moreIm sad to say the food was nasty. I spend almost $30 on two hot subs & a drink. The Philly meat didn’t taste like anything. No seasoning nothing. Only thing i could taste was the banana peppers. Maybe it was the time I ordered or what but food quality should be consistent until closing time. Welp another night & no dinner for this trucker due to nasty food. Do better please !
mani williams
I went here for something to drink. It costed me almost 4 bucks for a fountain soda. On top of that…I asked for a refund and still have yet to receive it. Will not be returning here for the greasy food either. However, the workers were nice.
… moreChristopher _is_here_
Delicious!! I love everything about Al’s The crust was nice and thin and the sauce had an excellent taste. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I definitely recommend the “Hot hot hot pizza”
… moreM
Pizza wasn’t bad, it’s alittle different. Not a new york with gooey cheese and grease. Big slice though!
… morejsdjsjsnsn
Good food but it’s the packaging! You guys shouldn’t put that paper stuff under the fries in the containers for delivery. It gets stuck to our fries and we spend 75% of the time picking ripped paper out of our food! Can’t tell if it’s cheese or paper ! Gross .
… moreAndy Berry
Food was excellent. Had a Philly Cheesesteak wrap with fries and a drink.
Definitely will return.
… moreDefinitely will return.