Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 187 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
Phone: (631) 924-3403
Website: http://www.paulsbagelcafe.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bagel Cafe – Holbrook & Middle Isand, NY
Fresh made bagels, coffee and sandwiches with locations in Holbrook and Milddle Island New York.
Order Bagel Cafe – Middle Island, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Bagel Cafe at 187 Middle Country Road in Middle Island. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Bagel Cafe – Middle Island Delivery Online – Postmates
From any restaurant in Middle Island • From tacos to Titos, textbooks to MacBooks, Postmates is the app that delivers – anything from anywhere, in minutes.
Reviews
Monique Rodriguez
Delicious! They’re so kind too. Amazing bagel deals for an office party. Cost almost 1/3 less than everywhere else I looked. But the best part was the service. It was already later in the day and they didn’t have everything we requested. They could’ve said look this so what we got and that’s that. But they baked us a batch of fresh bagels just for our little office party! Heavenly. Don’t miss this local gem!
… moreV33
I was in the area for work and popped in for some bagels. They’re fantastic. We tried the lox spread and it was really good (they’re very generous with the spreads and butter). Service was great. I ended up taking bagels back to share and some to freeze. If I’m ever back in the area I’ll absolutely be coming here.
… moreSteven Dunlop
Grabbed a ham and Swiss hero, BEC, egg salad, and egg everything with lox. All 10/10 very impressed, everything fresh and made generously. Thanks
… moreNema S
Ordered a sausage egg and cheese on a poppyseed roll eggs over medium. They say they are out of rolls. okay no rolls no problem, everything bagel then…bf ordered a bacon egg and cheese on sesame seed bagel. This is what we got. Completely messed up the order (i got the sesame seed bagel instead and he got the everything bagel) and barely any egg on his sandwich. Cost is way too much ($24) for such sad breakfast sandwiches.
… moreDeirdra Sipala
Bagels are great, food is great and the staff was excellent. Went with my mom and cousin for lunch and it was an all around great experience.
… moreKen Hendrickson
Paid $7.98 for 2 bagels with cream cheese. When we got home there Green Mold on the bottoms of both bagels. Selection was limited and (obviously) bagels were Not Fresh.
… moreMick Hargreaves
Quality AND Quantity in this thickie of an egg sandy!
2 eggs scrambled, ham, cheddar, hot sauce on an egg everything bagel. Includes a small (really medium) coffee!
Tremendous!
Ask about the “Buy 3 Bagels, Get 3 Bagels Free” special!
This joint is a new regular!
… more2 eggs scrambled, ham, cheddar, hot sauce on an egg everything bagel. Includes a small (really medium) coffee!
Tremendous!
Ask about the “Buy 3 Bagels, Get 3 Bagels Free” special!
This joint is a new regular!
Rachel
Always my top NY bagel place for visitors and newcomers. Then I left NY… I now have no bagels.
… moreRico Pastel
We order quite often and the egg sandwiches are good but several times my husband’s sandwiches have come with an ingredient missing.
… moreJames Kelly
Got an egg everything bagel with cream cheese and lox. What a lotta lox! No skimping here, that was a righteous bagel. Like, perfect. The coffee is good, too.
… more