Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 515 W Un St, Waterloo, IN 46793
Phone: (260) 837-2777
Website: https://mytastypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Tasty Pizza: Pizza Delivery & Takeout in Waterloo IN
For pizza delivery and takeout, Tasty Pizza in Waterloo IN offers mouthwatering pizzas, subs, grinders, salads, and more. Call (260) 837-2777 for delivery …
Tasty Pizza | Waterloo IN – Facebook
Details ; . 74% recommend (19 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 515 W Union St, Waterloo, IN, United States, 46793 …
Order Tasty Pizza – Waterloo, IN Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Tasty Pizza at 515 West Union Street in Waterloo. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
LadyBoss 77
YUCK, YUCK, YUCK. This is hands down the nastiest pizza I’ve ever tried. The taste is absolutely horrible. It’s insanely SPICY, has basically NO SAUCE, and is EXTREMELY DRY. I honestly can’t believe how bad it is. What a complete waste of money. So gross!!
… moreHeather Pollock
Nice little local pizza joint. Really like their cheese sticks and chicken bacon ranch calzone. Pizza was good, but I’m a fan of white garlic sauce, I wish they had it. The garlic sauce they do have just wasn’t quite enough, so maybe we’ll try something different next time. Their website has an email address, I thought I could email my order, but don’t do that. Good thing I called. We will definitely be ordering from here again!
… moreZayden Longardner
Where to start with this place. The menu is PACKED with many different choices that includes way more than just pizza. Our waitress was OUTSTANDING. She was very quick with her service and was amazing at her job. The pizza was the best part though. It was probably the best pizza I ever had in my whole lifetime of living. It had a great crunchy crust, yet at the same time, it wasn’t too thick or too thin to enjoy! The atmosphere was very cute too, it felt like I was walking into a 1980’s vintage environment. It was very welcoming at first sight and I am so excited to come back. I love the local vibes this place brings too, just so cute, warm, and welcome. So yeah, 5/5 AMAZING SERVICE AND FOOD IS SOME OF THE BEST I EVER HAD!!!!!
… moreJohn James
The gentleman got my order wrong and so I ended up having to pay for extra cheese that I didn’t want. I wanted extra sauce. It barely had any sauce on it and the dessert Pizza was, oh my God, that was like almost twice as much as the. Regular Pizza, right? I couldn’t believe it, but anyways, I didn’t get what I wanted, and they didn’t seem to care or fix it. They just looked at me like it was my fault.
… moreAmber Bradbury-Huepenbecker
My husband and I, ordered from Tasty Pizza last Saturday for the first time, and it was absolutely delicious. So we ordered from them again today, and we were not disappointed. We got the taco pizza & all meat pizza, both were so yummy.
… moreDeb Keezer
We’ve been ordering from Tasty Pizza regularly for about a year now. Today I ordered our usual on line. I received a phone call from them to let me know that they were almost out of one of my toppings and asked if I wanted to add anything else or change it to another topping. Now that right there is excellent service in my opinion. This place and all of the people working there are amazing. THANK YOU EVERYONE!!!
… moreHolly Stackhouse
Have always ordered delivery from them call today to place a delivery and the lady tells me I can’t place an order because I never picked up my carry out order. One I’ve never done carry out we have only ever done delivery but to automatically assume and refuse service is wild! Do better! Even after I explained to the lady we have never done carry out and only ever do delivery she says I’m sorry my manager says I can’t take your order! Shitty Business and customer service. Support a better family restaurant.
… moreRachel West
Since I’ve had Tasty Pizza, I have a hard time enjoying other pizza in this area.This little gem is small but mighty. They make their own dough and sauce. They use REAL cheese. Everything just feels and tastes authentic. Love the pizza, pizza rolls, AND the subs. Totally worth the drive to Waterloo.
… moreDouglas Chapman
I recently savored the Tasty Supreme pizza from Tasty Pizza in Waterloo, Indiana, customizing it without green peppers for my first trial. The experience was nothing short of delightful. Right from the first bite, the crust impressed me with its perfect bake and texture. The toppings were cooked to perfection, each ingredient melding harmoniously while retaining its distinct taste.
What stood out the most was the sauce — it had a unique flavor profile that set this pizza apart from others I’ve tried. Despite the older, somewhat worn appearance of the building, the quality and taste of the pizza spoke volumes about the family tradition of making “Pizza Fantastic Since 1958!” It’s a testament to not judging a book by its cover, or in this case, a pizzeria by its facade.
I’m already looking forward to my next visit and would highly recommend Tasty Pizza to anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience in Waterloo. Their craftsmanship in pizza making is evident, and it’s no wonder they’ve been a culinary staple since 1958. Two thumbs up for Tasty Pizza!
… moreWhat stood out the most was the sauce — it had a unique flavor profile that set this pizza apart from others I’ve tried. Despite the older, somewhat worn appearance of the building, the quality and taste of the pizza spoke volumes about the family tradition of making “Pizza Fantastic Since 1958!” It’s a testament to not judging a book by its cover, or in this case, a pizzeria by its facade.
I’m already looking forward to my next visit and would highly recommend Tasty Pizza to anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience in Waterloo. Their craftsmanship in pizza making is evident, and it’s no wonder they’ve been a culinary staple since 1958. Two thumbs up for Tasty Pizza!
Joseph Reed
By far the best pizza in Dekalb county I’ll order this day in and day out if I could. The cookie is amazing as well.
… more