Michael Nagatoshi
The pizza is consistently good. The crust is delightfully crisp. The Margherita is a winner too.
*************
House Signature was on point today; very much on par with great slices I’ve had in Manhattan. The Hawaiian as well; ample pineapple and quality Canadian bacon. My only remaining ask would be that they add a Sicilian to the menu.
Wow! The BBQ Chicken is great. Definitely upping to 4+!
*****************
They are upping their game. Pizza was perfect today. Crust was flexibly crisp. Toppings and sauces were quality. Even without a Sicilian, I am giving them 5 stars.
… moreMitchell Quevedo
Came here for lunch and got the special: 2 slices of pizza and drink. Pizza was fantastic with a nice crispy crust. Really hit the spot on a nice summer day after the beach. Would recommend
… morePamela Nelson
Was very disappointed the ‘lunch special ‘ price is NOT so special. BEWARE of the price, you can buy a whole medium pizza for MUCH less than the 2 slices on the so called special. I didn’t see the ‘special’ price posted anywhere so was surprised to find 2 slices and a soda was over $24.00 for two people. It used to be reasonably priced.
… moreMaybelline Vasquez
Best New York Pizza in town. Close to the Seal Beach pier. Piz za crust is crispy. Tried the pepperoni and sausage slice as well as the tomato and basil. Super delicious. Got to get yourself some to believe it.
… moreKim Pemberton
Fantastic gluten free pizza, probably the best I’ve ever eaten out! Had the Margherita and the pepperoni! And what a treat to have gluten free by the slice available! Run don’t walk to this place! So good!
… moreMax Pedroza
Great pizza at a decent price. I come here when I’m feeling like getting some pizza in the Huntington Beach area.
They have a good amount of outside seating, the workers are really friendly, and they have good deals if you buy a few slices with a drink.
I recommend the pizza here! It’s delicious!
… moreMike Cammarata
Great pizza in a real slice of New York. Friendly owner. It’s in a small mall and it’s not visible from the parking lot. However, it’s worth the search. BTW, I’m a NYer.
… moreray andcats
When I’m anywhere near Algonquin and I am craving a slice of pizza I go to a slice of New York. The pizza is pretty thin crust so you can really taste what’s on top. They use a cheese blend I think because it doesn’t just taste or feel like mozzarella and it’s really good. And they have lots of different types of pizzas that are ready made and they’re all good. Last time I got the buffalo chicken pizza and the meatball sausage pepperoni pizza, and are ready made and they go into a hot oven so they come out pretty quick. They have beers on tap and they have bottles to. I haven’t tried anyting but the pizza here, but I would like to because this pizza has nice quality ingredients. The atmosphere of the place is like a sports theme with lots of TVs and it looks nice, and it’s always clean. And they have Tabasco!
… moreJasmine Melendez
Pretty solid slices of pizza. Not the best though, but solid and worth coming. Prices are decent and staff are really friendly.
… moreGillian
This is a favorite spot to bring my son for an after school treat. The pizza is always delicious, service is excellent and the restaurant and bathroom are always immaculate. My son said they should get a thousand stars. Thank you for being a reliably great lunch spot in Huntington Beach!
… more