Haven Evenson
We love Brooklyn, it’s definitely, hands down, the best pizza and pasta place. I drive all the way from Hampstead for it and wish they would open one out here. This location is definitely the best, the food is on point and the staff are amazing. I’ve eaten here every day this week. (not an exaggeration) I’m very pregnant and super picky but they always make sure my food is perfect.
… moreMonica Pileggi
I went out with a friend today and tried a slice of sausage pizza at Brooklyn Pizza Co. on Oleander. My husband was there recently and thought it was excellent. I’m on the fence because the crust was not as crispy as I like it to be.
It was served in a paper bag – I guess the guy at the counter thought we were doing take-out. That might have attributed to the soft dough. Too soft to pickup, fold, and eat.
I’m going to go back and get another slice and ask the cook to keep it in the oven a little longer. I did like the flavors of the sauce and sausage.
… moreSig Jamison
The food was fresh and very good. Staff were helpful and there were solid seating options both inside and outside. The “typical cheese” pizza isn’t on the menu, but if you ask for a “small cheese,” it’s just right for younger kids. My 7 and 6-year-olds loved it. I ordered wings, a small cheese, and two large slices of pepperoni all for $40 including a 20% tip. We’ll be back soon.
… moreNicole M
I was down at the beach and of course I had to get some pizza, looked up some places and I came across this place. I called in and ordered. My service was really good, seating I think was a little tight but it was chill. Everyone was enjoying themselves eating or waiting on food. So I only eat cheese and the pizza was good except it was quite burnt on the bottom so it didn’t leave a great taste afterwards but other than that, the pizza was good. I would like try them again!
… moreElizabeth Moffett
Fantastic experience from start to finish. The staff were welcoming and so friendly.
The food was phenomenal! We tried the calzone, pizza, pepperoni pinwheels and fried cheesecake.
Pricing felt more than fair for the quality and top-notch service.
Huge shoutout to Otto for going above and beyond. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreCarlos Figueroa
Brooklyn Pizza offers a delightful slice of pizza heaven, almost bringing the classic New York experience to life. Their pizza is superb, boasting a perfectly crispy crust and flavorful toppings that are sure to please any pizza lover. While it may not be exactly like authentic NYC pizza, it comes impressively close.
The wings are another highlight, packing a delicious punch of flavor, though be prepared for a spicy kick! They strike a nice balance for those who enjoy a bit of heat with their meal.
As for the garlic knots, they’re decent – soft and garlicky, making a nice accompaniment to the main dishes. Overall, Brooklyn Pizza provides a satisfying and tasty experience that’s well worth a visit.
… moreJohn Forte
I am a self-described pizza snob from Brooklyn. The pizza is authentic to New York. The Sicilian slice is exceptional! It’s hard to find a Sicilian slice and when you do, it’s hard to find one that’s done right this place nailed it.
Their regular slices are good as well nice and crispy. The sausage is real sausage not those sausage crumbles you get at other places.
Their chicken marsala is amazing! You can actually cut the chicken with a fork. Very flavorful good sized portion.
If you’re looking for authentic New York style pizza in Wilmington, this is your place!
… morePaul Reed
Mmm!!! Delicious food and fun crew! I haven’t had good Brooklyn pizza since moving out west from NYC. On vacation and found this slice of heaven! Good stuff!!
… moreLauren McCoy
Best pizza we have found locally! Pristine kitchen, friendly and helpful staff! We tried cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, mushroom and onion pizza, chicken and broccoli roll, and sausage roll- all excellent!!
Edited to add a few more photos! The rice ball is so good!!
… moreChad Smith
The food at this place is purely amazing and the convenience of the service was phenomenal. This place is an authentic New York style pizza with many options, and the prices great!! I highly recommend this place for one of the best pizza restaurants!! They recently won “BEST PIZZA” from Best of Cape Fear and it is a must visit!!
… more