Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Italy’s best 3 is a pizzeria owned from a family born and raised in Napoli ( Italy ) where pizza was born. We serve the community with some delicious food since 1992. Our delivery service is pretty fast , we cover all of Toms river , highland heights, pine lake park and beachwood. There is a big difference between the big chains and the indipendent pizzeria , you will taste the difference in our products. We proudly use only the finest ingredients and everything is made from scratch. Our motto is “THERE IS A REASON WHY THEY CALL US ITALY’S BEST”
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Italy’s Best III – Toms River, NJ – 984 NJ-166 – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:30 AM-8:45 PM; Shop address is 984 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753984 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753; (732) 785-4107.
Italy’s Best 3 | Toms River NJ – Facebook
We are a Pizzeria located off route 166 in Toms River, NJ. Visit our website, www.italysbest3me… See more. Pizza place · $$ · (732) 240-9449.
Italy’s Best III – View Menu & Order Online – 984 NJ-166, Toms River …
Italy’s Best III · Italy’s Best III – View Menu & Order Online – 984 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753 – Slice.
Last Updates
Reviews
scott yakimoto
I ordered the penne w/vodka sauce & I was surprised with how good it was. The sauce was executed well, thick and rich, creamy, honestly better than some I’ve had at much more formal and expensive Italian restaurants. The portion was large, the pasta was cooked perfectly al dente, it came with a roll and salad, and the price was great. Would definitely recommend. I don’t know if i look like the kind of guy who would eat a full meal on a 3 hour drive, but i am, so i loved that my takeout was placed inside of a box. Great meal, thank you!
… moreOscar A
I’m no pizza reviewing pro but they are serving up solid slices of pie. Pepperoni was really nicely done.
Came in for dinner and enjoyed my meal.
… moreCame in for dinner and enjoyed my meal.
SniperPeep
I gave this place two separate chances and unfortunately had poor experiences both times, mainly due to service and order handling rather than the food itself.
First visit:
I called ahead and placed a phone order for fettuccine Alfredo. I was told the order would be ready, so I arrived about 25 minutes later. When I got there, the staff had no record of my order and didn’t seem to know what I was referring to. There was no apology or clear explanation — just confusion. I ended up wasting time and leaving frustrated.
Second visit:
I returned on another day hoping the first experience was just a one-off. I came in to order a couple slices of pizza. While standing at the counter, the employee was on the phone taking a catering order for approximately 15 minutes, with no acknowledgment of the customers waiting in line. There was no “I’ll be right with you,” no effort to pause or manage the counter while the call continued.
Once my order was finally taken, a woman who was standing behind me placed her order after mine — just a single slice of pizza. When the pizza came out of the oven, her slice was removed and served to her before mine, even though I ordered first. There was no explanation or acknowledgment of the situation, which made it feel dismissive and disorganized.
I understand kitchens get busy, but basic order flow and customer acknowledgment are essential. Being repeatedly overlooked, having orders lost, and watching later customers get served first makes it hard to justify returning.
There are many pizza places in the area, and unfortunately, based on multiple visits, this one needs significant improvement in customer service and order management.
… moreFirst visit:
I called ahead and placed a phone order for fettuccine Alfredo. I was told the order would be ready, so I arrived about 25 minutes later. When I got there, the staff had no record of my order and didn’t seem to know what I was referring to. There was no apology or clear explanation — just confusion. I ended up wasting time and leaving frustrated.
Second visit:
I returned on another day hoping the first experience was just a one-off. I came in to order a couple slices of pizza. While standing at the counter, the employee was on the phone taking a catering order for approximately 15 minutes, with no acknowledgment of the customers waiting in line. There was no “I’ll be right with you,” no effort to pause or manage the counter while the call continued.
Once my order was finally taken, a woman who was standing behind me placed her order after mine — just a single slice of pizza. When the pizza came out of the oven, her slice was removed and served to her before mine, even though I ordered first. There was no explanation or acknowledgment of the situation, which made it feel dismissive and disorganized.
I understand kitchens get busy, but basic order flow and customer acknowledgment are essential. Being repeatedly overlooked, having orders lost, and watching later customers get served first makes it hard to justify returning.
There are many pizza places in the area, and unfortunately, based on multiple visits, this one needs significant improvement in customer service and order management.
Carl Rinck (CR)
First time I ordered the Chicken Franchese & Italys Best Salad. Loved them both. Smoke portions for sharing ir leftovers. Then, I ordered the cheessteak pizza. Absolutely delicious.
… moreAlicja
If slice life didn’t lie about the price ($11 instead of $18) then it would have easily been 5 stars.
… moreaaron charnick
We stopped here on the way home from Seaside Heights. The foods was decent at good prices. Really liked the staff! They are on top of their game! We ordered our food and it was our within 15 mins. That’s with them starting to get busy at that point. I highly recommend the Brooklyn Sicilian Pizza! The plain was ok and the cheese steak was ok. Really not the way I like it but it was ok. I would recommend stopping while in town!
… moreDana Gassler
Tried this place for the first time and I’m so happy we did. My husband said the lasagna was fantastic and my gnocchi and vodka sauce was delicious! I’m very picky when it comes to vodka sauce and I am extremely pleased. The gnocchi melted in my mouth and it was swimming in vodka sauce. They also gave us more than enough bread for each meal. We will be ordering again from here for sure!
… morePatrick Giacobbe
Speciality slices and cheese steaks are out of this world. Service is super friendly and pizzeria is clean. This is one place you don’t want to skip out on this summer.
Slice in photo is buffalo chicken.
… moreSlice in photo is buffalo chicken.
Edwin
Been ordering from here for years, but just had a terrible and frustrating experience with their delivery. My order was misdelivered and I waited over 3 hours without ever getting my food. My address on the Slice app was correct and the house number is clearly marked on the mailbox in front of my house, so I don’t understand how the delivery driver messed up.
Had to go through multiple calls with them about this issue and I also had trouble understanding one of the guys as well, but at least they tried to help.
Even though they offered to remake it multiple times and try again, I had enough because at this point i felt that the delivery driver would just mess up again and I did not want to wait another hour for the food. Was finally able to get my refund after going back and forth with the restaurant and the app.
… moreHad to go through multiple calls with them about this issue and I also had trouble understanding one of the guys as well, but at least they tried to help.
Even though they offered to remake it multiple times and try again, I had enough because at this point i felt that the delivery driver would just mess up again and I did not want to wait another hour for the food. Was finally able to get my refund after going back and forth with the restaurant and the app.
Kool Dj daze (KOOL DJ DAZE)
I’ve been ordering from them for years when I lived at 20 Grand Avenue and my new house of 4 years now. Hands down the best Mikes hot honey pizza period Even did it for me in a Sicilian incredible There zeppoles are the best around not just fried dough but made with the ricotta cheese like the boardwalk’s do. Amazing food always and great people. Ty once again guys
… more