American Pie Pizzeria

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Hagerstown, MD! American Pie Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …

American Pie Pizzeria | Hagerstown MD – Facebook

American Pie Pizzeria, Hagerstown. 858 likes · 21 were here. Authentic American-Italian food for the whole family. Parking available in front and back….

Order American Pie Pizzeria – Hagerstown, MD Menu … – DoorDash

Get delivery or takeout from American Pie Pizzeria at 17520 Virginia Avenue in Hagerstown. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your …

Reviews

Erin Valdez

Girl upfront was nice but very short with me. I got a chicken ceaser salad and it came with one little container of ceaser dressing. I could only eat a little bit with the dressing I was given before I had to go and buy my own to finish it. Salad was great, just wish they gave more dressing to go with it.
I would have given 5/5 for food if I had more dressing to accommodate the large salad I ordered.

… more

Jason Norton

Got a basic pepperoni pizza. It had a real chewy crust, nice underside, thick cut cupping pepperonis, flavorful sauce, and a good amount of parmesan on the crust. It was exactly my preferred style of pizza. I saw the reviews about delivery so I did takeout and will say the man at the counter seemed pretty friendly. The seating inside looked homely. Slightly expensive but I will definitely order again.

… more

Lisa Richard

Enjoyed a great dinner. The salad was fresh, the grilled shrimp were delicious. The gluten free and vegan cheese pizza was so good. Happy with this new find. My 7 yr old said the pizza was the best she’s ever had.

… more

Cheyenne Kennedy

Pizza was amazing! I had the gluten free crust pizza and it was the best gluten free crust I had tried anywhere. We were just passing through town on our way home from vacation and found this place on google and was very pleased. Will definitely go back if we have the chance!

… more

Debbie Khwaileh

The restaurant is very relaxing and has a cozy warm vibe. We own a new pizza shop, Zaid’s Pizza, on the other side of town, and I enjoyed speaking with the owner and compared notes. Nice friendly people and the meatball parm sub was excellent! I liked the cozy booths and plants every where.

… more

Jesse P

I went here during a snowstorm a few weeks ago. I heard good things so I was excited. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a side of mozzarella sticks.

The mozzarella sticks were great and I loved the cup of marinera with a fold up lid with a hinge rather than the traditional lid you have to put back on after use.

The pizza was okay and VERY greasy.

The man who worked the cash register I’m guessing was the owner. He was very nice and friendly.

… more

Yasin Talha Sekercigiller

The food here is simply amazing! I try different type of pizza every time I come here and it just keeps getting better and better

… more

JJ Peters

I didn’t go in to the place, I ordered delivery because I have 2 babies in the house and it’s hard to get out sometimes so I ordered for convenience and threw away my $. The delivery arrived all smashed on one side of the box, clearly the pizza was dropped so I called to tell them what happened and they told me they can’t control what happens after it leaves and that he won’t refund my money or deliver the food that I’d have to come and get it. Told me essentially it isn’t their problem. Needless to say whoever is working on 1/2/24 was dismissive and rude and we won’t be ordering again to say the least, this was our 3rd time ordering from this place since we moved here not long ago. 1/3 experiences were ok. The last 2 were gradually got worse.

The reply just proves my point.

… more

Jonathan Berman

Jumped off at Hagerstown on trip from VA to OH and Google search showed this Pizzeria with excellent reviews. As we wanted Italian and not just pizza (and generally have had bad luck at Pizzeria Italian) we gave it a try. As it was 3 p.m. the place was empty but the counter was manned by owners wife. When technical question came up regarding Calamari, the chef (who spoke much better English) came out personally to explain. Had a great meal – salads, calamari, onion rings, fries – and owner/chef and his wife were attentive throughout. Perhaps not gourmet but giving my hard earned cash to a family run business that cares wins hands down. Great meal and great company.

… more

Jennifer Ackley

OMG…what great food…this was my son and my 1st time eating here…if you never stopped in you should…service was on the really slow side…seeing my son and I were the only customers there…but do not get the pink lemonade…my son said it didn’t taste good….as for the pizzas…wow…my son got the buffalo chicken pizza and I got the fun guy….really amazing pizzas…we will be back for more…sorry no pictures of the menu…they have a sign up asking people not to post it or I would have

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results