Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Craving authentic New York pizza? We are your go-to destination for the best pizza in town. Our expertly crafted pies are made with the freshest natural ingredients & our dough made with famous NYC water, captures the true essence of New York style pizza. From classic cheese to gourmet toppings, each slice offers a taste of the Big Apple. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, come savor the flavor at one of the top pizza places around. Experience the bustling ambiance and friendly service that make us a fan favorite. Join us and discover why our customers say we serve the best pizza in the Upper West Side!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
Phone: (646) 449-8556
Website: https://madeinnewyorkpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza is built on a foundation of fresh, natural ingredients, high-quality cheeses, and that legendary NYC water that gives our dough its …
Made In New York Pizza – Facebook
Made In New York Pizza · Classic Margherita · New Margherita · Vodka · Street Fair · Pepperoni · Yo Paulie · Chicken Bacon Ranch.
Made In New York Pizza – 271 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
Order online at one of the best restaurants in New York, NY! Made In New York Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Last Updates
Reviews
Kevin Ericson
Pathetic delivery. Get a load of this thing-
Delivery guy literally drops the pizza in our foyer, tucks tail and runs. Pathetic. Toppings look like he literally frisbeed the damn thing from the street. I’m sure it might have tasted good at some point; guess I’ll never know now.
… moreDelivery guy literally drops the pizza in our foyer, tucks tail and runs. Pathetic. Toppings look like he literally frisbeed the damn thing from the street. I’m sure it might have tasted good at some point; guess I’ll never know now.
Jennifer Wilde
Our neighborhood go-to for pizza. Friendly staff, quick service, delicious pizza. You can’t go wrong grabbing a slice or two here. Limited seating inside and a few outdoor stand-up tables.
… moreJean Semere
Excellent pizzas, especially the square ones that have a crunchy yet doughy and very digestible dough. The marinara is very garlicky (in a good way) and excellent as well, and the eggplant pizza is to die for. The setting is dull but it’s always useful to have a place to sit, and prices are very decent
… moreJudy Hochberg
I agree word-for-word with Jean Semere’s review. I live in the suburbs but come to the UWS from time to time and always love to have a slice of the grandma-style square pizza with eggplant, which is pictured on their website. The ingredients are fresh, the sauce is delicious, and the crust is just right.
… moreIris K
Great quality pizza ! Employees are friendly. You can request how much you want your pizza heated up
… moreT N
The square pizzas are sooooo good and crispy. The margarita pizza was ok. I wished I had tried the original slice and the mushroom. It looked really good. There was two other customers that were eating and went to order more. The a/c w felt really good. The place was really clean and felt good to eat in. I will definitely come back to eat more!
… moreSawako Y
4.5 / 5.0 – If you’re looking for a solid NY pizza, look no further! Made In New York Pizza has another location in UWS, but this newer location is more accessible, right by the 72 St Station.
They are famous for their Spicy Pepperoni Square ($5+) with little round pepperoni, but I generally get a slice of the Plain ($3.50+) or Margherita ($4.75+).
They have a small seating area for dine-in, with a counter for a quick bite.
So happy with this new addition to the neighborhood, to be able to easy drop in for a great slice of pizza.
One thing to note is that they charge a 3.99% fee for credit cards, so bring cash!
… moreThey are famous for their Spicy Pepperoni Square ($5+) with little round pepperoni, but I generally get a slice of the Plain ($3.50+) or Margherita ($4.75+).
They have a small seating area for dine-in, with a counter for a quick bite.
So happy with this new addition to the neighborhood, to be able to easy drop in for a great slice of pizza.
One thing to note is that they charge a 3.99% fee for credit cards, so bring cash!
Robert Cardoni
Classic New York slices and a few modern takes. Pepperoni and sausage slice is amazing.
… moreShany Thakur
We visited that place a couple of times. It’s a good place to grab NY style pizza. The workers were professional and quick in delivering the pizza that we asked for. If you’re in the area, give it a try!
… moreRachel Beaton
I was excited to see that this casual pizza place had a gluten free, vegan pizza listed on their website. Unfortunately, they do not actually serve either vegan and/or gluten free pizza. When I tried to order, I was told that they have never had any of these options and the serving staff seemed very annoyed that I was even asking, even though the gluten free option is also listed on the menu in the actual restaurant.
My daughter is allergic to dairy and I had planned on her being able to eat here with her friends based on the information on the website and on the board when we arrived, and when it was made clear to me that she would not be able to eat here, I had to scramble to find her another option at a different restaurant.
I can understand not having allergy friendly options, but it is false advertising to list them and not follow through.
Note: This place is fine if you do not have a dairy or gluten allergy.
… moreMy daughter is allergic to dairy and I had planned on her being able to eat here with her friends based on the information on the website and on the board when we arrived, and when it was made clear to me that she would not be able to eat here, I had to scramble to find her another option at a different restaurant.
I can understand not having allergy friendly options, but it is false advertising to list them and not follow through.
Note: This place is fine if you do not have a dairy or gluten allergy.