Single eyed Cat
I love this bakery! I’ve bought my sons 1st and 2nd birthday cakes here and they have always done an amazing job. They’re pricing is astounding, I was fully expecting and happy to pay atleast 100 for his custom cakes but I ended but only paying $27! Will forever recommend this bakery to anyone who will listen and will ESPECIALLY recommend Kristi White for any custom cake orders.
For reference I had asked for a mixture of both the farm animal cake and the ducky cake and this was the result! So happy!
… moreJason Stanley
Loved this bakery since I was a kid, they still have day old donuts for 1/2 price. Very good and not a chain like the other donut shop in town.
… moreJamie K
I called to request a birthday cake for my son, who is attending college in Newark. The young lady who took my order was very kind and asked great questions to ensure the cake would be what was wanted. They delivered the cake to his residence and also texted me updates (since I’m over 2 hours away). My son called me not 5 minutes after it delivered. He said it was impressive and delicious. He shared with his roommates, 2 of whom apparently don’t like cake, but all of them said it was “really good” – high praise from a bunch of 18-20 year old guys. Their care, assistance, attention to detail were appreciated and the cake and pricing were great.
… moreJulia Priest
I would give them even more than 5 stars if I could because of everything they did for my fiancé and I. When we decided to get married we knew we needed our R&M favorites to serve our guests. Even though it was during their renovations, they still came through for us and went way above and beyond delivering our hometown favorites for our special day. You’ll never beat the quality of their bakery or their customer service.
… moreMichelle Robinson
We love r&m. Our family frequently buys cookies here but the cake is my mom’s favorite. Every year I get her a birthday cake from r&m. Previous years were nice but this year especially I was just really impressed with the colors and decorations added to this cake. It’s beautiful and served the day very well! The price for this cake and 6 cookies was like $21. I guess I was just shocked at how nice this was for what I paid. Thank you to the maker and decorator, you did a fabulous job. We will be buying more in the future, as we have in the past.
… moreAmber Sprague
I called the bakery with a bit of an unusual request, and the owner was so kind and helpful! He helped shaped my query into something manageable for me, and doable for them, and it was a great experience. 10/10 will order from them again. It is run by such a caring and lovely person!
… moreJayson Wright
They did an amazing job on my wedding cake! I was impressed with how quick they were able to handle my request and get it done on such short notice. It tasted as good as it looked and would highly recommend for anybody looking for a great local bakery to do their wedding cake. I added on dozens of delicious donuts and cookies as well because the pricing was so great!
… moreBrooke Pfan
I had no idea what exactly i wanted for a 30th birthday I was hosting but R&M Bakery went above and beyond! Helping me pick out a design, even added pretty sparkles, short leadtime and great price, I will absolutely be back!
… moreElaine Farore-Love
Authentic homemade bakery housed in a 100years+ building, so handmade as if your own grandma made it with love… donuts are UNIQUELY shaped and not even round with sloppy icing, dough has more consistency than fluffy Krispy Kreme donuts but yummmmy and ONE OF A KIND truly. No-bake cookies is a must and avalanche cookies surprisingly delicious! Also worth trying the cherry filled cookies and chewy oatmeal cookies.
… moreTasha Maybury
My daughter had a 4h meeting here to learn how to decorate cakes . The owners are so sweet . Thankful for the experience
… more