Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Compact counter serve providing specialty pizzas, pasta, hoagies & gyros in a bare-bones interior.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5832 Library Rd, Bethel Park, PA 15102
Phone: (412) 833-5200
Website: https://fatangelospizza.com/order/fat-angelos-bethel-park-5832-library-road
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Fat Angelo’s
Fat Angelo’s – Pittsburgh(BETHEL PARK) · (412) 833-5200 · 5832 Library Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102. Open now • Closes at 10PM. All hours. View menu · Order …
Fat Angelo’s Pizzeria Bethel Park – Facebook
Pizza place. . Follow. Details. . 94% recommend (13 Reviews). . 5832 Library Rd, Bethel Park, PA, United States, 15102. Links. . fatangelospizza.com …
Menu – Fat Angelo’s
Official menu for Fat Angelo’s – Pittsburgh(BETHEL PARK). See the most … Menu. 5832 Library Road, Bethel Park, PA. Change location. Fresh Salads. Baked …
Reviews
Vincent Capuano
Got white pizza with pepperoni. Definitely best part of the meal, would order again.
Steak hoagie had good bread, we ordered with just steak and mushroo(no peppers onion or lettuce tomatoes) kinda bland as it was missing seasoning but maybe we should not have altered it.
Got the fired dough, it was good but obviously something you need to eat right out of the fryer. By the time we ate the pizza and hoagie it was not really great. Kinda cold and chewey. But would order again if I was dining in, or eating right away.
My only real critique is that it wasn’t busy on a friday night when I walked in. Pizza cook and counter cook were chilling but their pizza station was visually dirty from the counter I picked the food up at. Not like filthy, just toppings all over the place, which concerns because how long is that sitting out with out getting discarded. If basic clean up is not done than I wonder if deep cleaning is getting done.
Not stellar but tasted decent. Would order the pizza again just based on flavor alone.
… moreSteak hoagie had good bread, we ordered with just steak and mushroo(no peppers onion or lettuce tomatoes) kinda bland as it was missing seasoning but maybe we should not have altered it.
Got the fired dough, it was good but obviously something you need to eat right out of the fryer. By the time we ate the pizza and hoagie it was not really great. Kinda cold and chewey. But would order again if I was dining in, or eating right away.
My only real critique is that it wasn’t busy on a friday night when I walked in. Pizza cook and counter cook were chilling but their pizza station was visually dirty from the counter I picked the food up at. Not like filthy, just toppings all over the place, which concerns because how long is that sitting out with out getting discarded. If basic clean up is not done than I wonder if deep cleaning is getting done.
Not stellar but tasted decent. Would order the pizza again just based on flavor alone.
Savannah Smith
I regular this place a lot. Roughly every other week for a few years now (since they opened). Most of the staff is amazing there. Food is great! Highly recommend as a whole.
It’s my favorite pizza place honestly. No one has a better Hawaiian! The owners are always friendly and are very helpful should you have any issues.
… moreIt’s my favorite pizza place honestly. No one has a better Hawaiian! The owners are always friendly and are very helpful should you have any issues.
Carmine Lauderback
Got take out today Clearly 2 1/2] slices and more areas have nothing on them Taste is just OK. Nothing to write home about Lost my appetite looking at it so this review is based on someone that tasted it. The pizza should never have been given to a customer Im sure the worker wouldnt have paid for a pizza that looked like this Btw ive decided to not call for a refund or replacement being theyll probably spit on it the owner has made comments online about my facebook post Shes clearly not going to be open long from the local pizza community feedback There were no good comments on my post at all She can have her snide facebook comments to me and hoping she enjoyed herself typing them The customer is always right Ive worked in alot of food places and from experience i can say this Guessing she didnt appreciate our business or anyone elses by posting that on my comment section.
… morekatarina mercurio
Ordered a cheese pizza and fried zucchini. I don’t live nearby so the food wasn’t exactly ‘fresh’ but it was still good! The zucchini was sliced a bit too thick but the flavor was great. The woman working was very nice and friendly. Really good experience! I will definitely come back.
… moreChristopher Mest
We’ve been to the Washington location and had a fine experience. Food was good, service was good. My wife was over near the bethel park location, the other day, so we figure i would order the food and she would pick it up. I called at 3:30 and was told it’ll be ready in 30-35 minutes. My wife shows up at 4:10, and the food isn’t ready. No big deal, except they didn’t even start making it. My wife said it wasn’t busy either. At 4:30, the food went into the oven. She also said she received some attitude from cashier when she asked how much longer, considering she had our young daughter and her friend waiting and we were told the food would be ready over 30 minutes ago. At least the food was good. We’ll stick with the washington location.
… moreCaylee Calhoun
Food is good but lord almighty this place is always listed as open and never is. I think I’ve called 5 seperate occasions not even over a holiday and the phone just rings and rings, I’ve also watched them turn the light off on me when I tried to order saying they were closed. Great food if you can get it!
… moreSabrina Tatalias
Large pizza and large hoagie for $40 is a joke. The “Large” pizza is literally the size of a small pizza … if that.
The Groupon policy is a scam for usage – they said we couldn’t use the Groupon for this Friday due to a “Friday weekend special” so we paid full price.
Honestly disappointing. I wanted to support local but they need to do something about the pizza size. It’s literally a normal pizza with peppers..
A piece of pizza is smaller than my hand (I’m a women) try Nobbys or Luciano’s you will be so much happier.
… moreThe Groupon policy is a scam for usage – they said we couldn’t use the Groupon for this Friday due to a “Friday weekend special” so we paid full price.
Honestly disappointing. I wanted to support local but they need to do something about the pizza size. It’s literally a normal pizza with peppers..
A piece of pizza is smaller than my hand (I’m a women) try Nobbys or Luciano’s you will be so much happier.
Jeff Direng
Buyer beware! I’ve eaten at other Fat Angelo’s locations and always had good food. Ordered from here tonight and when my mother picked it up she was was told they “lost the ticket” and had to wait for them to remake the order. After another half hour she then brought over a terrible burnt sad excuse of a pizza and a second burnt pizza in the box that was supposed to have bread sticks. Tried calling back to complain and they had stopped answering the phone at 530 on a Wednesday. Just save yourself the headache and go somewhere else.
… moreNicholas Basile
I heard of this place’s opening through social media (Pittsburgh pizza, hoagies, and wing joints) and saw that one of the group members (a manager of the place, possibly?) was partaking in a lot of the posts so I had to give it a try. I was super happy I did — the crust was buttery and crispy and the cheese had a phenomenal flavor; very nice blend. It may be my new favorite pizza place in Bethel Park, and I have tried every one of them. The staff was very friendly for the 2 seconds I was in the shop; oh, and I paid about $25 for 2 large pizzas with a topping on each (plus a little extra for the added topping I had on one of the pizzas) — you can’t beat that deal! Next time I’ll leave a bigger tip 😉 I’m very excited for this place and love the enthusiasm of the staff.
… moreRobert Stinner (Pizza with Bob)
What a total MESS. Needs a new system. Pizzas being ordered, nothing being completed. I walked in with 0 pizzas in the oven and they asked me what I ordered. The team member did not know how to make it and had to pull up the website. Even then, it is still made incorrectly. The pizza was drenched in hot sauce and should have had a drizzle of ranch. While waiting, the store was so cold that I had to go to the car to wait.
***edit*** the owner reached out to me to rectify the situation.
… more***edit*** the owner reached out to me to rectify the situation.