Art Toth
This is one of the better pizzerias in Pittsburgh. The pepperoni thin crust is great as long as you tell him to make sure it’s extra crispy. The same with a Sicilian and it’s probably one of the best in Pittsburgh and it’s very flavorful but they undercook it too much so you have to ask to have it cooked a little more for my preferences
… moreLucas Schmidt
It’s a great place with lots of tvs for sports viewing also a nice bar. It also has by far the best pizza in the Pittsburgh area. In addition they also have great hoagies salads and much more.
… moreBrogan McGowan
Pizza is somewhere between the nostalgia of Sbarro slices & NYC $1.99 slices, with a strong marinara and plenty of cheesy gooey goodness on each slice. Garlic bites were probably my favorite. Limited on seating, and a nice large bar for sit down dining/watching sports games.
… moreThe McCormick Companies
This is one of the best New York style pizzas in the Pittsburgh area, hands-down. This isn’t on everyone’s radar. I won’t understand, but I went in there one day for a slice and it was phenomenal. It also has the feel of a real Italian New York pizza shop, but is top-tier not some rundown place the slices are huge and cooked to perfection and the prices are fair compared to their New York style pizza places if you like large New York style pizza Mike’s hot honey, and get to do your pizza with whatever you’d like this is your go to spot
… moreSabrina
Food was delicious, first time I was ever there. The person waiting me was young and not very personable. The gentleman cooking the pizza was about the same. I will definitely go back though. I had the garlic knots they were so soft and doughy lots of garlic. I also had a slice of Sicilian and it just the right amount of crunch. Delicious
… moreJacob Marcus
Love the pizza. Funding quality pizza outside of NYC is a challenge and impossible in some areas. Mamma Lucia’s nails it, every time. Saves me from driving out to NYC to satisfy my NY slice cravings and even better than some places in the Big Apple. Nice spot, I enjoy their food, will continue to go back.
… moreS. Medina
Wow, okay currently I am being blocked from speaking to a manager by staff when I call.
Yesterday we walked in the door. And the first thing we saw behind the counter was a beautifully freshly made, melted cheese, pepperoni pizza.! Well, we definitely wanted some of that!
So I requested three pieces of that pizza and ask them to add mushrooms on one piece for my daughter.
As per their very clear,” no outside beverages”,policy they have… I walked over to the cooler to select a drink. I heard some commotion next to me. I turned my head to the left and saw. The pizza maker that’s bald, (Forgive me, I don’t know his name) Wave his hands forward to the other guy like, “just go”
Well, it turns out they put ice cold mushrooms on my daughter‘s pizza
And then attempted to sell it to me that way.
I reached out and touched to very cold mushrooms..asi was getting ready to pay.16.00 for 3 slices.
I didn’t yell, but I did ask the counter guy to heat the mushroom slice , …we exchanged some words. Told me, I could “take my pizza and go!” I said,” I’ll do you one better. You can keep your pizza”
The reason I was so upset is no apology was attempted even now. Ive called three times, each time asking for an apology. Its all gas lighting and blame. The bald guy denies everything blames the counter guy,
Throwing out customers because you are wrong is not how to do business. And blaming co workers is not good for retention of help.
There is a good looking pizza maker there, he is friendly and provides good service, they should hold on to him at all costs, if he is still there, haven’t seen him in a minute.
But the bald guy, and guy who hasn’t shaved in about a month are both ridiculous.
The unshaven guy told me to, “ yeah , go get your husband..” my reply was, “ Husband? Honey my kid could take you”
These are the guys left to run the place?!?!
I only posted because the refused to get a manager for me, and I could find no usable email, and he refuses to apologize.
… moreShannon Buha
The pizza by the slice option is convenient. It’s already cooked, they add the additional toppings you want(if any) and heat it in the oven. Pizza was good, loved the garlic knots.
… moreHollyRNBSN
Excellent pizza excellent buffalo chic grinder, made the ham and cheese calzone as we had requested online and the small cut Sicilian with the half mushroom extra cheese is the best Sicilian I’ve had in 25 years. Delicious we order from here frequently for special occasions and are never disappointed!! The red sauce is superb-!! So good! Delicious food!!!
… moreBronson Smith
My family used to go to the location in the mall years ago and were big fans. Sadly, today I went in and requested a buffalo chicken pizza with grilled chicken and got breaded chicken. The only other request I had was to leave the pizza uncut because we wanted to reheat it later. Yeah they didn’t bother doing that. The guys were nothing short of dismissive at the counter. Do better fellas.
… more