Michael Caputo
Nasty staff and bad food. Chicken parm was rubbery and tasteless. My friend I was dining with did not like the ravioli, sauce tasted like they added rosemary. Owner was defensive and not nice,
… moreLove Light
They don’t have the natural root beer but they push this garbage as natural. They lied to my friend and he took their word for it. Its filled with garbage and overpriced as usual. I respect the owner for my own personal reasons but this place is going down fast. You can not lie to your customers.
… moreAndrew Klein
From a different town and went to go see newphews basketball game, so we stop in at patio pizza after because we definitely wanted to eat outside. Ordered a Regular Pie some garlic knots. I tell ya I never ate 3 slices until today. This place makes sause just like my grandmother’s. Simply amazing pizza cooked just right. Service was awesome, and the locals that ate there were so friendly. I recommend anyone passing by St. James to go to this place.
… moreMark Freeley
My favorite local pizza place.
Great food and outdoor seating.
… moreHimmy Butler
Messed up order. I ordered a full buffalo chicken pizza a while back, and I got a half buffalo chicken and half cheese pizza. I went back, and they didn’t do anything to make up for it. I also asked if the price i was charged was correct, and she said the pizzas both cost the same. But in my head how would a half chicken and half cheese pizza cost the same as a full chicken pizza! But I let it go since it wasn’t a big deal. But once I got home to try the pizza the buffalo chicken side just tasted like buffalo. There was barely any chicken. It was clear they were skimping out on ingredients on top of the fact they made the wrong order. I’ve usually had a good experience with this place, i’ve ordered slices before, and the environment and people are nice. I don’t know if this was a rare occurrence but for my first time ordering a full pie it was kind of upsetting.
… moreCarmela V
Great pizza and eggplant parmesan is delicious. Very friendly, courteous and fun staff. Always a good time. Oh and love the rice pudding. Always a great time.
… moreTracy Lent
Great friendly staff make all the difference, elevating this local spot. Good old school Italian food.. great outdoor seating, open atmosphere, some shade umbrellas.
… moreLiz Slack
Our family has been a.patron for 40 years. But when they posted pictures of Trump we never went back. Business should not post their political views!
… morefran ny lu
over 40 years getting the same Pizza, Sicilian special no anchovy only 1/2 with mushrooms. well done crispy crust.
… moreMichele M
Been here a few times. Nice, cozy place. Food was so fresh and delicious. Many great dishes to choose from and plated so nicely. Portions are generous.
Service was excellent. Management and staff super nice and friendly. Very courteous. Made us feel so welcome. I’ll keep coming back.
… more