4.3 – 282 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Old-school outpost offering classic Italian pies & pasta dishes plus hot & cold subs.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
slicelife.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
Mo W
Ordered a fish fry, a large pizza with pepperoni, & and order of chicken tenders. Everything was great. Price is great, food is great, delivery was super fast. Accepts payment over the phone. I couldn’t have asked for a better Friday evening experience. 3 star for atmosphere because we didn’t eat in the restaurant.
… moreBreanne Upright Van Hatten
Best pizza and wings in overall atmosphere that I have had in a long time. I highly recommend you go there.
… moreRetonya Flowers
I ordered Chicken Parmigiana on New Year’s Day. The chicken smelled and tasted spoiled and the spaghetti was watery. Not sure what happened because I haven’t been here in years.
… moregerard grohol
Tony’s pizza of Yorkville has a great Extra chesee with pepperoni pizza. At first this pizza was steaming hot and i did end up burning the roof of my mouth on the first bite. But that’s just an indication of a fresh well made pizza but that did not stop me from gorging down the slices of Fresh hot pizza
… moreVICKY SCHNEIDER
I frequent tonys pizza and normally they are amazing tonite i ordered went and picked it my mistake for not checking the pizza before i left. We got home to eat it mind u we ordered extra sauce and the pizza looks like it had been sitting while. And had little sauce. When i called and spoke to chrissy she was very rude told me the dough was made at 1:30 and she couldnt help me. And hung up. The pizza though it was cut couldnt be pulled apart. Smh so done ordering from them.
… moreGunner Morrow
Excellent pizzas. Had two large, one plain and one garlic.
First timers, will be back !!
… moreObed Lozada
First of all, do anybody listen when they order food? What’s up with the delivery guy? He is lazy. Doesn’t wanna get out the car and why is he smoking cigarettes on top of my food?
… moreJamie Rodeo
Went there to get some slices and told me they didn’t have time to add toppings to a slice, closed window on us while we were standing and then had us wait after pressing bell. The man behind the counter that was dealing with us was nothing but rude and nasty. Should be ashamed of himself as he was nasty in front of a child. Only time I’ve had poor service is when he’s working. Will no longer get my business. 2 lunch specials were supposed to be 10 as the man charged me 14. Never been treated like that at pizza shop! Doesn’t deserve a 1 star but the pizza was ok
… moreRob Rios
Love this pizza.Shop one of my best in Utica.They’re cheese on their pizza is fabulous
… moreKayla Wasyleski
I ordered a pizza from Tony’s and i don’t even know where to start. My delivery driver, Tony was hilarious, extremely charismatic and all around brightened my day. The care he delivered my pizza with was spectacular. I would definitely recommend ordering from this beautiful establishment again! 10/10
… more … View more