Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Compact neighborhood joint offering scratch-made bagels with an array of spreads & toppings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 930 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Phone: (516) 352-1313
Website: http://www.hrbagels.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Hand Rolled Bagels – Hand Rolled Bagels of New Hyde Park. HRB …
Multiple Award Winner · ORDERING AVAILABLE TEXT IN (516) 806-5616 (YOU WILL RECEIVE A CONFIRMATION #) · ONLINE (CLICK BUTTON BELOW) · PHONE (516) 352-1313.
Hand Rolled Bagels Delivery Menu | Order Online – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Hand Rolled Bagels in New Hyde Park! View Hand Rolled Bagels’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …
Hand Rolled Bagels – New Hyde Park – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Hand Rolled Bagels at 930 Hillside Avenue in New Hyde Park. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your …
Reviews
Overit
I’ve hesitated to write this review, mainly because I believe it’s a waste of time and won’t have any impact on the quality of the food or the incompetent service at this establishment. They are coasting on a “best of Long Island” title that is undoubtedly solicited rather than deserved.
I live close by and have frequented the shop countless times because the bagels themselves are good and it is convenient. That said, each time it is a disappointment for one reason or another.
Their staff is entirely made up of teenagers who could not care less about their jobs. This is expected, but the owners literally sit on their stools and do absolutely nothing about it. The wait time is unreasonable, even if you place an order to pick up you are stuck there for 20 minutes waiting for someone to hand you a bag and make you pick your own drink.
Then, you go home with your food and it is either made incorrectly or carelessly. Today, I ordered 2 sandwiches, both with 2 eggs, one with crispy bacon and one with cheddar cheese.
I received one egg practically uncooked bacon, and American cheese on both sandwiches. Both sandwiches weee thrown together like slop. Naturally, I was charged for 2 eggs on both. This is unacceptable and again, just the latest example as something goes wrong every single time I am there.
I genuinely wish this and all of the latest reviews highlighting the poor quality and service impacts their business, because they really are doing so well because of an undeserved award and reputation and don’t care about their customers in the least bit. I will be driving a bit further to get my breakfast from now on. If you need other businesses at which to spend your hard earned money, consider: My Three Sons on Covert Avenue, A&S in Franklin Square, Slim’s in Bayside.
… moreI live close by and have frequented the shop countless times because the bagels themselves are good and it is convenient. That said, each time it is a disappointment for one reason or another.
Their staff is entirely made up of teenagers who could not care less about their jobs. This is expected, but the owners literally sit on their stools and do absolutely nothing about it. The wait time is unreasonable, even if you place an order to pick up you are stuck there for 20 minutes waiting for someone to hand you a bag and make you pick your own drink.
Then, you go home with your food and it is either made incorrectly or carelessly. Today, I ordered 2 sandwiches, both with 2 eggs, one with crispy bacon and one with cheddar cheese.
I received one egg practically uncooked bacon, and American cheese on both sandwiches. Both sandwiches weee thrown together like slop. Naturally, I was charged for 2 eggs on both. This is unacceptable and again, just the latest example as something goes wrong every single time I am there.
I genuinely wish this and all of the latest reviews highlighting the poor quality and service impacts their business, because they really are doing so well because of an undeserved award and reputation and don’t care about their customers in the least bit. I will be driving a bit further to get my breakfast from now on. If you need other businesses at which to spend your hard earned money, consider: My Three Sons on Covert Avenue, A&S in Franklin Square, Slim’s in Bayside.
1ssaa
Celebrated bagel bakers, this part of Nassau county and this stretch of Hillside Avenue, extending into Queens. As regulars, we are in a good place to say they’ve made their bones (meaning bagels). Of course, iconic artwork, quirky branding, loud messaging, and clutter – as an integral part of their business approach – contributes to the charm.
Take a morning walk around this block of Hillside Avenue and get wrapped in aroma of culinary magic-in-making.
Reasonable selection of bagels {may not be as diverse as leading bakers in NYC} & schmears at hand, they specialize in sandwiches. The bagels are bigger, puffed to perfection; and if you go for sandwich option, be prepared to put your jaws through a pain free, range of motion {Maximum Interincisal Opening} test ☺️.
To make a more detached judgement, we got our bagel snob friend to savor the fare. There also, the verdict was aaahhh, ummm! Everest scaled!
The staff always appears to have a convival spirit. We were well served by David on the last visit; who also did a quick course correction for a flub I did in placing the order.
HR is a takeout-only establishment, located on a 5 store-front strip. To fully realize the real potential of their fare, we hope HR opens bite-in option in the adjacent premises, now (as of 09/2025) papered-up.
Highlight Reel:: Ice cubes in HR cold coffee are frozen from the same brew. Which means, melt does not dilute consistency; experience stays what you walk out with.
… moreTake a morning walk around this block of Hillside Avenue and get wrapped in aroma of culinary magic-in-making.
Reasonable selection of bagels {may not be as diverse as leading bakers in NYC} & schmears at hand, they specialize in sandwiches. The bagels are bigger, puffed to perfection; and if you go for sandwich option, be prepared to put your jaws through a pain free, range of motion {Maximum Interincisal Opening} test ☺️.
To make a more detached judgement, we got our bagel snob friend to savor the fare. There also, the verdict was aaahhh, ummm! Everest scaled!
The staff always appears to have a convival spirit. We were well served by David on the last visit; who also did a quick course correction for a flub I did in placing the order.
HR is a takeout-only establishment, located on a 5 store-front strip. To fully realize the real potential of their fare, we hope HR opens bite-in option in the adjacent premises, now (as of 09/2025) papered-up.
Highlight Reel:: Ice cubes in HR cold coffee are frozen from the same brew. Which means, melt does not dilute consistency; experience stays what you walk out with.
Meggie Badillo
Best Bagels in Long Island! Bagels are always hot and fresh! Service is fast and friendly. They have the best coffee! BEC on a hot plain is my favorite! Owners are super friendly. Place is clean and recently updated. The pick up counter on the side is fast and convenient. Best Bagel Spot!
… morejonathan nieves
The bagel was ok but overall very disappointing. I got such a small and single thin piece of ham on my ham egg and cheese. For almost 9 dollars I honestly felt robbed. Seems like even the egg portion is extremely small. I had high hopes for this bagel shop but don’t think ill be returning unfortunately.
… moreJessica Rahner
I regularly drive two towns over just for these hand-rolled and always fresh bagels. Their ingredients are of the best quality, especially the flour (I have inquired). Their ingredients staff and owners are friendly and they give off that small town, family feel when are there as much as I am. Cream cheese is also house made and fresh with new flavors to try all the time. Totally recommend checking them out
… moreJohn Riley
Place is a little old but they have been updating everything! They recently got new screen tvs in the front of the place for their menus. They are also very clean! They have been here for years, and have the best bacon, egg, and cheese bagel! Trustworthy, Clean, & amazing food! Highly recommended!
… moreErika Naranjo
First time experience at this establishment was well below my high expectations. It took us 30 minutes to receive out order despite there being 7 workers on the bagel line. That being said, our order was wrong and we had to ask it to be remade twice. We felt very unwelcome and there was an extreme lack of hospitality and attention to the customer. Out receipt showed we were overcharged but due to the unwelcoming environment we did not go back
… moreJacob Cohen
Very good bagels here, maybe slightly overpriced but what isn’t these days however the bagel is delicious and so is the cream cheese. I got an everything bagel with smoked salmon cream cheese it was very good flavor and texture a nice big bagel really beautifully design in the dough.
… moreSamantha Venezia
Amazing bagels, especially their French toast bagel and an excellent bacon, egg, and cheese! Reasonable prices, good quality and quantity. They updated a few things in store and have a variety of options to choose from! Highly recommend!
… moreFaiza Chaudhry
One of the tastiest bagels I’ve ever had. NY bagels are out of this world and this location has one of the best ones.
We called ahead and so glad we did bc there was a long line. But that’s pretty standard for NY bagel shops. Still had a bit of a wait but wasn’t to bad, for our food in 15 mins like they said on the phone.
We ordered two sesame bagels and one egg and cheese bagel. Both tasted phenomenal. As well as an iced French vanilla coffee which was pretty good as well. Overall the food here is 10/10 for sure.
… moreWe called ahead and so glad we did bc there was a long line. But that’s pretty standard for NY bagel shops. Still had a bit of a wait but wasn’t to bad, for our food in 15 mins like they said on the phone.
We ordered two sesame bagels and one egg and cheese bagel. Both tasted phenomenal. As well as an iced French vanilla coffee which was pretty good as well. Overall the food here is 10/10 for sure.