Rachel Frate
We used Tony Tomatoes to cater our daughter’s first birthday party, and they truly went above and beyond. The food was absolutely delicious — all of our guests commented on how good it was — and the service was incredible from start to finish. My husband and I kept saying how nice it was to actually be present and enjoy the day because they took care of everything. We didn’t even have a single dish to wash!
One of the most special touches was the wooden pizza board they brought for everyone to sign as a keepsake. They even wrote “Happy Birthday” on it for our daughter — such a thoughtful detail that we’ll cherish forever.
We really couldn’t recommend Tony Tomatoes more highly. They made our day easy, memorable, and full of joy… an event we will undoubtedly remember forever!
… moreMartina Barley
We had the best experience having Tony cater our housewarming party in Penfield. The charcuterie display was gorgeous, creative and delicious. The pizzas were a mix of classics and specialty – all unbelievable. They even made gluten-free and vegan pizzas on the spot. Our favorite was the paella, our guests went nuts for it! They are beyond generous with portions we even had leftovers to give our guests to bring home. Tony and his team especially Josephine made our party so much fun and the food was simply amazing. We can’t wait to have them back again! 10/10 overall
… moreRachel Cumella
The pizza was incredible!! We have always loved the personal pies and are familiar with them from the food truck. We tried to Romanian style tonight and it was great. The dough was just right. Crunchy outside just how we like it. We got a half sheet Romanian style and it was plenty for 4 grown adults. Even enough for leftovers! Tony and his wife Angie always greet everyone with a smile and their new place looks awesome! We will be coming back to try the rest of the menu and look forward to stopping in for lunches in addition to takeout dinner! Thanks Tony!!!!
… moreAdam
We had Tuscan Wood Fired Pizza cater our daughter’s first birthday party, and they were absolutely amazing. All of our guests were raving about their delicious varieties of pizzas along with their courteous and fast service on the food truck. We will be using them again for sure! Great job!
… moreLauren Smith
Tony and Tom were an absolute delight! Such a welcoming environment from the moment I walked in the door! Absolutely loved their kind demeanor! They even let me sample something incredible that they were trying to see if it would make a good menu item! Absolutely incredible! A must check out place! Definitely worth it!!
… moreKevin Wiktorski
My wife and I selected Tony for our backyard wedding. It turned out absolutely perfect and everyone was raving about the food Tony provided. It was the perfect choice for us. His food is amazing and his attention to detail is simply above and beyond what we expected. Thanks for making our wedding the best!! We love Tony and highly recommend him for your event.
… moreJamie Catalano
Tony makes the BEST pizza in town, flavor is unmatched. A Friday lunch treat for our staff done right. Break room was SILENT today if you know what I mean. delicious!!!!
… moreKeith Hendricks
We had their food truck cater our son’s graduation party 7/13/2025. Everyone loved the pizza! This is the second time we have had Tony cater a grad party. He takes a big part of the party prep and makes it easy!!! We had 5 choices of pizzas so everyone was able to get their own personal pizza. Did I mention the pizza is delicious? 10 out of 10 and highly recommend!!
… morePeter DeBerger
We recently had the pleasure of hiring Tuscan Wood Fired Pizza Catering for a special event, and it was hands-down one of the best decisions we made. From the moment they arrived, the team was professional, friendly, and completely dedicated to providing an unforgettable culinary experience.
The wood-fired oven setup was both impressive and charming, adding a unique, rustic vibe to our event that our guests absolutely loved. But the real star of the show was the pizza—fresh, hot, and bursting with flavor. Every pie was made to order with high-quality ingredients, expertly crafted dough, and that perfect crisp you can only get from a real wood-fired oven. Whether it was a classic Margherita or one of their gourmet specialty pizzas, each slice was a hit.
What really stood out was their attention to detail and customer service. They seamlessly accommodated dietary preferences and kept the food flowing with efficiency and a smile. The team clearly takes pride in their work, and it shows in both the taste and presentation.
If you’re looking for a catering option that will wow your guests and elevate your event, Tuscan Wood Fired Pizza Catering is it. They’re more than just pizza—they’re a full-on experience. We’re already looking for another excuse to bring them back!
… moreAlly Guarnieri
We are obsessed and plan to be regulars!! We love the cortona, like a margarita and it’s super thin crust, and the Lucca pepperoni with a little bit thicker but still NY style thin, NO FLOP! The owners and staff are always so kind, they smile while they work so you know they love what they do and that’s a vibe! Tiramisu was so good I love that they put it in a cup, and the cannoli with the chocolate and vanilla coating on the shell was genius because the shell didn’t collapse as fast as a plain cannoli would.
10/10 will be back!!!
… more