Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Caraglio’s Pizza is a locally owned pizzeria serving up classic, crowd-pleasing favorites made with quality ingredients and a whole lot of care. From our hand-tossed pizzas and signature wing flavors to hearty subs, salads, and family-friendly meals, we’ve got something for everyone and every occasion. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, feeding the family, or ordering for game day, Caraglio’s is your go-to spot for great food, friendly service, and consistent quality.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3869 Lyell Rd, Rochester, NY 14606
Phone: (585) 426-0270
Website: https://www.caragliospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza and Wings in Rochester | Best Local Pizzeria
We’ve got the best pizza and wings in Rochester! Visit Caraglio’s Pizza for fresh, flavorful meals and unbeatable deals!
Order Caraglio’s Pizza – Rochester, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Caraglio’s Pizza at 1169 North Greece Road in Rochester. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Caraglio’s Pizza | Hilton NY – Facebook
Caraglio’s Pizza, Hilton. 6765 likes · 96 talking about this · 162 were … Pizza and Wings in Rochester | Best Local Pizzeria. We’ve got the best pizza …
Last Updates
Reviews
Elikathal Find me on All Platforms
Pay $1 for a quarter filled cup of blue cheese. Are you guys for real? This isn’t the first time. Every time we get wings or pay extra for blue cheese this is what we get. It’s ridiculous. The pizza is also always hit or miss. Sonetunes over sauced when we ask for light. Sometimes no sauce when we ask for it light. Sometimes cut correctly sometimes cut so unevenly one persons slice is 8 inches wide and the others is 2. Honestly I’m not tipping from now on if this is the service level. You’re acting your wages I guess but what should I tip for if there is no consideration for customer experience. I’ll pay for my food, I’m not paying your workers extra for this experience. I highly doubt it’s the business telling them to cut the pizza or sauce it like that. Maybe they’re told to fill the blue cheese like this. But I’m done. Actions have consequences, if you don’t care about how your job is done why should I care if I tip you for a job well done ♀️
… moreAaron C
IDK what it is lately, but places we’ve enjoyed in the past have gone to the dumps. We use to visit Caraglios pretty often back in the day until their deal was no longer on Local Flavor. We passed by the other day, and decided to go back cause we use to love the pizza and boneless wings. I wouldn’t even call it pizza anymore. It’s more garbage in a box. Half the pizza had no toppings, couldn’t get a slice out without it falling apart. Also, what should be dough was non existent. Also, boneless wings were not tossed in sauce. And, no blue cheese given. Both just got off work, we were starving, didn’t want to deal with bringing it back, so just made trash plates and ate whatever you want to call it. I think the pictures shows you what you get from this place now, just like all the other gross looking pictures in other reviews. Wish I looked at reviews before wasting money.
… moreLaura Kline-Taylor
My family has ordered the large pizza special every Tuesday for three years! For the first time in 3 years last week we got a burnt pizza. My kids were starving and so we made quick dinners at home instead of driving back to return and wait for a new pizza, but I did call and ask what could be done. They told me I’d get a discount on our next order. This week we didn’t get the discount, because the pizza special on Tuesdays is already a discount. I don’t want to order anything else full price just to get a discount, I wanted my burnt pizza acknowledged. I told them that. Instead of recognizing our weekly loyalty for 3 years and offering to waive the price, or add on anything for free that would make us happy, they offered 25% off of whatever full price thing I wanted to buy. I never want to buy more things and tell myself I’m saving money. So I’m super bummed, but will be taking our weekly business elsewhere from here. This one experience was bad, but in all the years we’ve gone there, it’s been great, which is why it’d be dishonest to leave 1 star. I just can’t tolerate not being valued by my neighborhood pizza place when I speak kindly about a mistake and ask what can be done and am met as if I’m any person off the street who came there once.
… moreDana Gern
They can never seem to get our order correct. They cannot make the pizza well done consistently, cut the pizza the way we want (ever). There is always something wrong with it. At least the flavor is halfway decent. There Monday deal is the reason we come. The good pizza place is closed on Mondays.
… moreBrandon Capers
Ordered a large pepperoni and fried dough received a burned cheese pizza and burned fried dough. Call to tell them about it and was told with a attitude that she would refund my card and that I did not need to return to the store for her to do a refund. She was very rude and unprofessional and I don’t recommend going there when she’s on. Talking about the older white chick with tattoos everywhere. Fried doe was hard as a rock smh. Than to top it all off they were laughing about it when I called to complain never again will I go there
… moreJae Bermudez
Just went through this past weekend and the food has not been the same. They are lacking out ingredients for the pizzas and for the price is ridiculous. Unhappy with the service this time and this was usually my two-go spot
… moreMichael M Coleman
Not sure what’s going on here but lately the food has been TERRIBLE!! The wings are soft not crispy(even when requested) and they come drowning in sauce or grease (garlic parm wings). So much so that the The pizza is also TERRIBLE lately..ITS DRIED OUT, and HARD. The employees are very nice and accommodating but when the re make the food it comes out the same or worse!
… moreHun Ho
Our go to place for pizza and wings! What’s underrated is their fries! We always get pizza with wings and fries! Just thinking about it now makes me want to order all of that food! Do yourself a favor and order from there! Sign up for their rewards acct and you earn points for free large pizzas and stuff!
… moreSusan Christian
I’m not even a big pizza fan, but the pizza was delicious. I would order from them again. Nice amount of sauce. Not dry.
… moreKaren Petrillo
My family and I go there after visiting Vivid Hair Studio! We always get the excellent and easy price special (pizza & drink) too!
… more