James Buckley
Decided to try Lorenzo’s for take out for the family tonight. Coming from NYC not only was the pizza delicious but we went with their Philly cheese steaks and they were incredible! For the amount of food it was a good turn around for the pickup wait time. Definitely will be coming back here next vacation!
… moreElizabeth Raimondo
First time ordering Lorenzo’s. We ordered 6 Philly cheesesteaks and 2 Trio pies. DELICIOUS!
The closest we’ve ever gotten to Philadelphia. Spot on. Pies were so crispy. So glad that we have a new restaurant to add to our LBI repertoire.
… morejustin Madonia
Really good solid pizza. Got the hot honey pepperoni. Chicken buffalo cheese steak and the seasoned fries. It was 4th of July weekend and it took 40 min and the food was great. Would order again. Staff were slammed and were handling it quite well.
… moreTayla Wakefield
Staff is always friendly. I go after work at least once a week since last summer. Their slices are always delicious and their pies are even better. Objectively the best pizza on the island!
… moreJordan Burkhalter
The best cheesesteaks! Sharp shoota cheesesteak was delicious!!! Amazing hot honey pizza! Can not recommend enough!!
… moreDan
The cheesesteak rivals all the best in Philly even Angelo’s. The cooper sharp wit onions is my go to. Phenomenal cheesesteak.
… moreConnor
Pretty average pizza. Nothing great, nothing bad. If you’re in the area and can walk to it, it’s a great spot. I would not waste time driving to it and dealing with parking though. Also their “online ordering” is not accurate. You have to online order through grubhub or DoorDash where they grossly inflate the prices of the pizzas. If you offer online ordering I’d suggest a system similar to chegg. Also you cannot order wings from chegg if you call, I understand not having the whole menu from chegg but you’re called “Lorenzo’s pizza at the chegg” so you would imagine you can get a few items from chegg.
Again, not bad pizza but nothing special, would hope they make a few system changes down the road.
… moreMatt Hauben
Unfortunately nothing good to say. We called to order 3 pizzas (because their online ordering was down) and were told it would take 40 minutes which in of itself is a bit surprising for a place that only sells pizza. But was shocked to show up 40 minutes later to see a crowd waiting to only sit there for 40 additional minutes just to get 3 pizzas (1 hr and 20 minutes total wait). Wait aside, the pizzas were very poor. The margherita pizza was undercooked and mushy with no basil, the plain pie had basically no sauce and tasted like cardboard, and the beesting pizza lacked chicken and sauce. Also super surprising that they are so isolated from the CHEGG even though it carries its name. Hopefully they can figure things out and make some changes.
… moreScott Bice
Plain slice looked great until it was heated in their pizza oven. I ordered 1 plain slice and after heating it had no under carriage, so I asked for it to be heated longer in the oven. 2 more minutes in the oven and the slice came back with even less structure and in a pool of oil. Straight into the garbage it went. The staff seemed clueless and offered a new slice which was nice, but it would be no different as it was from the same pie on display. I don’t know if the cheese quality caused the abundance of oil or the crust was too thin, either way i will not be back which is sad because I frequent the chicken or the egg often. Do not recommend.
… moreDeęz
The closest you’re gonna get to New York pizza on LBI. Shaving off one star because there’s ample place to add seating but the place is pretty barren and stark
… more